Baseball Toaster Dodger Thoughts
Log in | Register | Help
Baseball America Dodger Prospect Report
2005-02-09 09:44
by Jon Weisman

Because of time constraints, analysis of the Baseball America report on the Dodgers' Top 10 Prospects will mostly have to give way to an open chat thread. Just try to remember that the rising players on this list are all too young to bank on, and the falling players on this list are all too young to give up on.

Before you rush to point out how few Dodger prospects have made it over the years, remember that times change. At the same time, we have to wait and see, even on the Joel Guzmans of the world who look so good but might take as long as Adrian Beltre to conquer the world, if that's even in the cards.

Just more of your anti-generalizing, glass-is-both-half-empty-and-half-full proselytizing from Dodger Thoughts!

The list:

1. Joel Guzman, ss
2. Chad Billingsley, rhp
3. Edwin Jackson, rhp
4. James Loney, 1b
5. Andy LaRoche, 3b
6. Russell Martin, c
7. Greg Miller, lhp
8. Blake DeWitt, 3b
9. Jonathan Broxton, rhp
10. Chuck Tiffany, lhp

Best Hitter for Average: Blake DeWitt
Best Power Hitter: Joel Guzman
Best Strike-Zone Discipline: Cory Dunlap
Fastest Baserunner: Jason Repko
Best Athlete: Matt Kemp
Best Fastball: Edwin Jackson
Best Curveball: Chuck Tiffany
Best Slider: Chad Billingsley
Best Changeup: Alfredo Gonzalez
Best Control: Steve Schmoll
Best Defensive Catcher: Russell Martin
Best Defensive Infielder: Ching-Lung Hu
Best Infield Arm: Andy LaRoche
Best Defensive Outfielder: Jason Repko
Best Outfield Arm: Xavier Paul

(Note: There will be a live chat on the Dodger prospects on Baseball America at 11 a.m.)

Nowhere on the Top 10 is Willy Aybar, whom Baseball Prospectus today hinted was the second-best second-base prospect in baseball. However, some discussion on Baseball Primer contends that the Dodgers' Nos. 11-20 prospects could compete with the top 10 of most other teams. Post No. 19 by "CanuckDodger" lists some names for that second 10: Hu, Scott Elbert, Dunlap, Dioner Navarro, Yhency Brazoban (still qualifies as a rookie with only 32 2/3 innings in his career), Delwyn Young, Aybar, Kemp, Julio Pimentel, Joel Hanrahan.

Honestly, if the Dodgers can't get a star or two out of that group of 20, either through performance or through trade ...

Update: Bad news, good news on Greg Miller, according to BA's Alan Matthews:

He had surgery approximately two weeks ago on his shoulder. Why is that good? Because finally a concrete ailment was discovered and Miller had his shoulder scoped to clean it up, hopefully, once and for all. He should begin playing catch in spring training and could be back in a minor league game by June.

Isn't this the kind of thing we should learn about - much sooner - on Dodgers.com?

Update 2: In addition to the above news about Miller, Matthews had some interesting information and opinions to share in his chat. Some other highlights:

  • Repko has really persevered and is coming off his finest season after going in the first round in 1999. He is the organization's best outfielder and could contribute in a part-time role as soon as this season in L.A.

  • Chin-Lung Hu and the aformentioned Julio Pimentel are two guys who were on the cusp of the top 10 who have considerable ceilings. Hu has a great glove and can really pick it, but also pleased many scouts with his pop at the plate. Pimentel dominated at times last year at Columbus when he got his breaking ball over for strikes, like the 16-strikeout, seven-inning outing in June versus Rome. His fastball has been clocked as high as 94 mph and sat near 90 with boring action.

  • Long term, I still like Martin over Navarro, though Navarro is more developed and seasoned as a catcher and should contend for a backup-platoon role in the majors this season.

  • The Dodgers like (Cody) Ross, and he had a great close to the season last summer. But he's one of those "upside down" guys, who throws left and hits right, which makes it tough to slot him in a lineup, especially with lofty strikeout totals. He's a good defensive player,though not as good as Repko. Ross needs to learn to be more selective at the plate.

  • Also, the organization made some changes in minor league instructors and will likely adopt a slightly less agressive approach to moving players up, in light of the recent injuries to Miller, (Mike) Megrew and Jose Diaz.

  • The Dodgers shifted Aybar from third base to second base where his power numbers play better. He is a good athlete and made the adjustments at second base well, though I see him as an extra infielder on a contending big league team. He is ranked in this year's Top 30.

  • I do not believe [Jackson] will be a "flop." The organization changed his mechaincs and he never looked comfortable last season. He lost his balance over the mound. It looked like Edwin was dragging his arm through and not collapsing at the wasit the same way he was when he soared up the prospect charts in 2003. He is still young and has only been pitching full-time since 2002, so let's not give up on him just yet.

    Update 3: Here's an excerpt from John Manuel's Baseball America feature on Miller:

    Miller’s first operation was arthroscopic surgery on his left shoulder in March 2004. The Dodgers expected him back by June or July last season. Instead, he missed the whole year. Miller would progress well with his throwing program, long tossing to build up his arm strength, but when he got back on a mound, inflammation and soreness returned in the shoulder. Finally, the Dodgers and Miller found the problem during an MRI exam. The tip of his shoulder blade was shaped in such a way that it was causing the inflammation by rubbing up against tissue in the shoulder.

    Surgery was performed to shave down the bone, hopefully precluding further inflammation and giving Miller a chance to get back on the mound pain-free. The procedure technically is known as acromioplasty, the surgical reshaping of the acromion (the tip of the shoulder blade).

  •  

    Comment status: comments have been closed.

    Jon Weisman's outlet
    for dealing psychologically
    with the Los Angeles Dodgers
    and baseball.
    Hot from the Toaster
    BlogAds
    Search
    Google Search
    Web
    Toaster
    Dodger Thoughts
    Archives

    2008
    07 
    06  05  04  03  02  01 

    2007
    12  11  10  09  08  07 
    06  05  04  03  02  01 

    2006
    12  11  10  09  08  07 
    06  05  04  03  02  01 

    2005
    12  11  10  09  08  07 
    06  05  04  03  02  01 

    2004
    12  11  10  09  08  07 
    06  05  04  03  02  01 

    2003
    12  11  10  09  08  07 
    06  05  04  03  02  01 

    2002
    09  08  07 
    About Jon
    Support Dodger Thoughts

    Dodger Thoughts T-Shirts
    On sale through February 16, 2008
    DT Blue on WhiteDT-WhiteonBLue
    Click here to order.

    * * *

    Cover 11.25 jpeg

    The Best of Dodger Thoughts
    A 325-page book featuring the top selections from this website from 2002-2005.

    Click here for more information.

    On Sale Now at Lulu.com

    Support independent publishing: buy this book on Lulu.

    * * *

    Or, just make a donation to support the site. Many thanks.

    "Dodger Thoughts, like TiVo, is one of those things you can completely do without until you start using it."

    - Fanerman

    Dodger Sites
    Dodger Resources
    Non-Partisan Baseball Sites
    Partisan Baseball Sites
    Baseball, Among Other Things
    Invaluable Resources
    Less Dodgers, More L.A.
    All in the Family
    Other Writing by Jon on the Web

    SI.com
    NL West Preview
    Evaluating Defense
    Colletti and Depo
    World Baseball Classic
    Minor League Broadcasters
    Slow Starts
    Eric Gagne
    Groundball Pitchers
    Dodger Prospects
    Albert Pujols
    Humbled Angels
    You Be the Manager
    Eric Gagne II
    Unreliable Relievers
    Revived Angels
    It's Okay To Sell
    Dodger Turnaround
    Andre Ethier
    Padres-Dodgers Showdown
    NL Final Weekend
    Mets-Dodgers NLDS
    Postseason ratings
    NL Wish Lists
    Manny vs. J.D.
    McGwire Controversy
    Dodger Offense
    Trainers Matter

    Variety
    Will Arnett
    John C. McGinley
    Laura Dern
    Imelda Staunton
    SAG Awards
    Ellen Pompeo
    Grey's Anatomy
    2004-05 Rookie Dramas
    Anthony Hopkins
    NATPE
    Scrubs
    Award Shows
    Topher Grace
    Ashton Kutcher
    Writing on Improv Shows
    Rainn Wilson
    T.R. Knight
    Guest Actors
    Animation Guests
    Joey Carson and Tennis
    Donald Trump and Golf
    2006 Emmys Nominees*
    *Comedy Series
    *Comedy Director
    *Comedy Writer
    *Comedy Actor
    *Comedy Supporting Actor
    Blue's Clues
    Lizzy Caplan
    Ann Donahue
    CMT: Giants
    CMA Awards
    Little Miss Sunshine
    Actor-Directors
    Freshman Series
    Clint Eastwood
    Showrunners vs. Censors
    Little Children
    Breaking and Entering
    Tartikoff Legacy Awards
    Jackie Earle Haley
    Knights of Prosperity
    Office Online
    2007 Screenplay Noms
    Friday Night Lights
    Robert Benton
    ABC Fridays
    Rookie Actors
    Global Casting
    2007 Pilot Casting
    Sublime Slime

    Also ...
    A Season in Savannah (Stanford Magazine)
    Five Questions: Los Angeles Dodgers (2005) (Hardball Times)
    Rick Monday (Baseball Analysts)
    Baseball's Odd Couple (Baseball Prospectus)
    Five Questions: Los Angeles Dodgers (2006) (Hardball Times)
    Five Questions: Los Angeles Dodgers (2007) (Hardball Times)

    More Shameless Self-Promotion
    2008 Season

    Dodger home record: 22-20 (.524)
    When Jon attended: 3-2 (.600)
    When Jon didn't: 19-18 (.514)

    1991-2007

    Dodgers at home: 745-600 (.554)
    Jon attended: 293-233 (.557)*
    Jon didn't: 457-374 (.550)
    * includes road games attended

    2008 Payroll Worksheet

    Current Roster with Estimated 2008 Salaries
    (updated March 28)

    Most figures are estimates (some are wild estimates) but will be updated as information comes in. Corrections welcome.

    More contract details here.

    Starting Pitchers (5)
    $12,300,000 Hiroki Kuroda
    $10,000,000 Derek Lowe
    $9,500,000 Brad Penny
    $7,000,000 Esteban Loaiza
    *$500,000 Chad Billingsley
    Total: $39,300,000

    Bullpen (6)
    $2,000,000 Takashi Saito
    $1,925,000 Joe Beimel
    $1,125,000 Scott Proctor
    *$500,000 Jonathan Broxton
    $500,000 Chan Ho Park
    *$400,000 Hong-Chih Kuo
    Total: $6,450,000

    Starting Lineup (8)
    $14,100,000 Andruw Jones
    $13,000,000 Rafael Furcal
    $9,000,000 Jeff Kent
    $8,500,000 Nomar Garciaparra
    $8,000,000 Juan Pierre
    $500,000 Russell Martin
    *$400,000 James Loney
    *$400,000 Matt Kemp
    Total: $53,900,000

    Bench (6)
    $875,000 Gary Bennett
    $600,000 Mark Sweeney
    $424,500 Andre Ethier
    $391,000 Delwyn Young
    $390,000 Chin-Lung Hu
    $390,000 Blake DeWitt
    Total: $3,071,000

    Disabled List
    $12,000,000 Jason Schmidt
    *$400,000 Tony Abreu
    *$390,000 Andy LaRoche
    Total: $12,790,000

    Also Paying ...
    $1,000,000 Brett Tomko
    $750,000 Odalis Perez
    $540,000 Yhency Brazoban
    $500,000 Randy Wolf
    $487,500 Jason Repko
    $135,225 Rudy Seanez
    $100,000 Mike Lieberthal
    $50,000 Ramon Martinez
    Total: $3,562,725

    Working total: *$113,268,725

    *Rough salary estimate

    The 2008 Dodgers

    ESPN BR BP Cube Alvarez
    ESPN BR BP Cube Abreu
    ESPN BR BP Cube Beimel
    ESPN BR BP Cube Bennett
    ESPN BR BP Cube Billingsley
    ESPN BR BP Cube Brazoban
    ESPN BR BP Cube Broxton
    ESPN BR BP Cube DeWitt
    ESPN BR BP Cube Ethier
    ESPN BR BP Cube Furcal
    ESPN BR BP Cube Garciaparra
    ESPN BR BP Cube Hu
    ESPN BR BP Cube Jones
    ESPN BR BP Cube Kemp
    ESPN BR BP Cube Kent
    ESPN BR BP Cube Kuo
    ESPN BR BP Cube Kuroda
    ESPN BR BP Cube LaRoche
    ESPN BR BP Cube Loaiza
    ESPN BR BP Cube Loney
    ESPN BR BP Cube Lowe
    ESPN BR BP Cube Martin
    ESPN BR BP Cube May
    ESPN BR BP Cube McDonald
    ESPN BR BP Cube Meloan
    ESPN BR BP Cube Miller
    ESPN BR BP Cube Orenduff
    ESPN BR BP Cube Park
    ESPN BR BP Cube Paul
    ESPN BR BP Cube Penny
    ESPN BR BP Cube Pierre
    ESPN BR BP Cube Proctor
    ESPN BR BP Cube Repko
    ESPN BR BP Cube Saito
    ESPN BR BP Cube Schmidt
    ESPN BR BP Cube Stults
    ESPN BR BP Cube Sweeney
    ESPN BR BP Cube Troncoso
    ESPN BR BP Cube Wade
    ESPN BR BP Cube Young

    Selected Recent Ex-Dodgers

    ESPN BR BP Cube Alomar
    ESPN BR BP Cube Alvarez
    ESPN BR BP Cube Aybar
    ESPN BR BP Cube Baez
    ESPN BR BP Cube Bako
    ESPN BR BP Cube Beltre
    ESPN BR BP Cube Bradley
    ESPN BR BP Cube Cabrera
    ESPN BR BP Cube Carrara
    ESPN BR BP Cube Carter
    ESPN BR BP Cube Chen
    ESPN BR BP Cube Choi
    ESPN BR BP Cube Cora
    ESPN BR BP Cube Crosby
    ESPN BR BP Cube Cruz
    ESPN BR BP Cube Dessens
    ESPN BR BP Cube Dreifort
    ESPN BR BP Cube Drew
    ESPN BR BP Cube Encarnacion
    ESPN BR BP Cube Edwards
    ESPN BR BP Cube Erickson
    ESPN BR BP Cube Falkenborg
    ESPN BR BP Cube Finley
    ESPN BR BP Cube Flores
    ESPN BR BP Cube Gagne
    ESPN BR BP Cube Grabowski
    ESPN BR BP Cube Green
    ESPN BR BP Cube Guzman
    ESPN BR BP Cube Hanrahan
    ESPN BR BP Cube Hernandez
    ESPN BR BP Cube Hundley
    ESPN BR BP Cube Ishii
    ESPN BR BP Cube Izturis
    ESPN BR BP Cube Jackson
    ESPN BR BP Cube Karros
    ESPN BR BP Cube Ketchner
    ESPN BR BP Cube Ledee
    ESPN BR BP Cube Lima
    ESPN BR BP Cube Lo Duca
    ESPN BR BP Cube Lofton
    ESPN BR BP Cube T. Martin
    ESPN BR BP Cube Mayne
    ESPN BR BP Cube G. Mota
    ESPN BR BP Cube Mueller
    ESPN BR BP Cube Myrow
    ESPN BR BP Cube Nakamura
    ESPN BR BP Cube Navarro
    ESPN BR BP Cube Nomo
    ESPN BR BP Cube Osoria
    ESPN BR BP Cube A. Perez
    ESPN BR BP Cube O. Perez
    ESPN BR BP Cube Phillips
    ESPN BR BP Cube Proctor
    ESPN BR BP Cube Roberts
    ESPN BR BP Cube Robles
    ESPN BR BP Cube Romano
    ESPN BR BP Cube C. Ross
    ESPN BR BP Cube D. Ross
    ESPN BR BP Cube Sanchez
    ESPN BR BP Cube Schmoll
    ESPN BR BP Cube Sele
    ESPN BR BP Cube Seo
    ESPN BR BP Cube Shuey
    ESPN BR BP Cube Stanley
    ESPN BR BP Cube S. Stewart
    ESPN BR BP Cube Thompson
    ESPN BR BP Cube Thurston
    ESPN BR BP Cube Valentin
    ESPN BR BP Cube Venafro
    ESPN BR BP Cube Ventura
    ESPN BR BP Cube Weaver
    ESPN BR BP Cube Werth
    ESPN BR BP Cube Wilson
    ESPN BR BP Cube Wunsch

    Dodger Thoughts Land
    Thank You For Not ...

    1) using profanity or any euphemisms for profanity
    2) personally attacking other commenters
    3) baiting other commenters
    4) arguing for the sake of arguing
    5) discussing politics
    6) using hyperbole when something less will suffice
    7) using sarcasm in a way that can be misinterpreted negatively
    8) making the same point over and over again
    9) typing "no-hitter" or "perfect game" to describe either in progress
    10) being annoyed by the existence of this list
    11) commenting under the obvious influence
    12) claiming your opinion isn't allowed when it's just being disagreed with

    Syndication

    rss2.0

    Add to My Yahoo!