Baseball Toaster Dodger Thoughts
Log in | Register | Help
Jon Weisman's outlet
for dealing psychologically
with the Los Angeles Dodgers
and baseball.
Hot from the Toaster
BlogAds
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Dodger Thoughts
Archives

2008
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
09  08  07 
About Jon
Support Dodger Thoughts

Dodger Thoughts T-Shirts
On sale through February 16, 2008
DT Blue on WhiteDT-WhiteonBLue
Click here to order.

* * *

Cover 11.25 jpeg

The Best of Dodger Thoughts
A 325-page book featuring the top selections from this website from 2002-2005.

Click here for more information.

On Sale Now at Lulu.com

Support independent publishing: buy this book on Lulu.

* * *

Or, just make a donation to support the site. Many thanks.

"Dodger Thoughts, like TiVo, is one of those things you can completely do without until you start using it."

- Fanerman

Dodger Sites
Dodger Resources
Non-Partisan Baseball Sites
Partisan Baseball Sites
Baseball, Among Other Things
Invaluable Resources
Less Dodgers, More L.A.
All in the Family
Other Writing by Jon on the Web

SI.com
NL West Preview
Evaluating Defense
Colletti and Depo
World Baseball Classic
Minor League Broadcasters
Slow Starts
Eric Gagne
Groundball Pitchers
Dodger Prospects
Albert Pujols
Humbled Angels
You Be the Manager
Eric Gagne II
Unreliable Relievers
Revived Angels
It's Okay To Sell
Dodger Turnaround
Andre Ethier
Padres-Dodgers Showdown
NL Final Weekend
Mets-Dodgers NLDS
Postseason ratings
NL Wish Lists
Manny vs. J.D.
McGwire Controversy
Dodger Offense
Trainers Matter

Variety
Will Arnett
John C. McGinley
Laura Dern
Imelda Staunton
SAG Awards
Ellen Pompeo
Grey's Anatomy
2004-05 Rookie Dramas
Anthony Hopkins
NATPE
Scrubs
Award Shows
Topher Grace
Ashton Kutcher
Writing on Improv Shows
Rainn Wilson
T.R. Knight
Guest Actors
Animation Guests
Joey Carson and Tennis
Donald Trump and Golf
2006 Emmys Nominees*
*Comedy Series
*Comedy Director
*Comedy Writer
*Comedy Actor
*Comedy Supporting Actor
Blue's Clues
Lizzy Caplan
Ann Donahue
CMT: Giants
CMA Awards
Little Miss Sunshine
Actor-Directors
Freshman Series
Clint Eastwood
Showrunners vs. Censors
Little Children
Breaking and Entering
Tartikoff Legacy Awards
Jackie Earle Haley
Knights of Prosperity
Office Online
2007 Screenplay Noms
Friday Night Lights
Robert Benton
ABC Fridays
Rookie Actors
Global Casting
2007 Pilot Casting
Sublime Slime

Also ...
A Season in Savannah (Stanford Magazine)
Five Questions: Los Angeles Dodgers (2005) (Hardball Times)
Rick Monday (Baseball Analysts)
Baseball's Odd Couple (Baseball Prospectus)
Five Questions: Los Angeles Dodgers (2006) (Hardball Times)
Five Questions: Los Angeles Dodgers (2007) (Hardball Times)

More Shameless Self-Promotion
2008 Season

Dodger home record: 50-35 (.588)
When Jon attended: 9-5 (.643)
When Jon didn't: 41-30 (.577)

1991-2008

Dodgers at home: 795-635 (.556)
Jon attended: 302-238 (.559)*
Jon didn't: 498-404 (.552)
* includes road games attended

2009 Payroll Worksheet

Current Roster with Estimated 2009 Salaries
(updated November 14)

Most figures are estimates (some are wild estimates) but will be updated as information comes in. Corrections welcome.

More contract details here.

Starting Pitchers (5)
$10,000,000 Hiroki Kuroda
*$475,000 Chad Billingsley
*$415,000 Clayton Kershaw
*$405,000 Eric Stults
*$400,000 James McDonald
*Total: $11,695,000

Bullpen (7)
*$2,500,000 Takashi Saito
*$1,300,000 Scott Proctor
*$1,500,000 Jonathan Broxton
*$425,000 Hong-Chih Kuo
*$420,000 Cory Wade
*$410,000 Ramon Troncoso
*$400,000 Scott Elbert
Total: $6,955,000

Also on 40-man roster
Mario Alvarez
Yhency Brazoban
Greg Miller
Justin Orenduff

Starting Lineup (8)
$17,100,000 Andruw Jones
*$3,000,000 Russell Martin
*$2,500,000 Andre Ethier
*$600,000 Matt Kemp
*$600,000 James Loney
*$500,000 Angel Berroa
*$410,000 Blake DeWitt
*$400,000 Tony Abreu
Total: $25,110,000

Bench (5)
$10,000,000 Juan Pierre
*$600,000 Jason Repko
*$410,000 Delwyn Young
*$400,000 Danny Ardoin
*$400,000 Chin-Lung Hu
Total: $11,810,000
Note: Team can buy out Ozuna's 2009 option for $200,000

Also on 40-man roster
A.J. Ellis
Lucas May
Xavier Paul

Disabled List
$12,000,000 Jason Schmidt

Also Paying ...
$2,000,000 Brad Penny (buyout of $9,000,000 option)
$50,000 Gary Bennett (buyout of $900,000 option)
Note: Kansas City is responsible for $500,000 buyout of Angel Berroa's $5,500,000 option for 2009.

Working total: *$68,020,000

The 2008 Dodgers

ESPN BR BP Cube Alvarez
ESPN BR BP Cube Abreu
ESPN BR BP Cube Beimel
ESPN BR BP Cube Bennett
ESPN BR BP Cube Billingsley
ESPN BR BP Cube Brazoban
ESPN BR BP Cube Broxton
ESPN BR BP Cube DeWitt
ESPN BR BP Cube Ethier
ESPN BR BP Cube Furcal
ESPN BR BP Cube Garciaparra
ESPN BR BP Cube Hu
ESPN BR BP Cube Jones
ESPN BR BP Cube Kemp
ESPN BR BP Cube Kent
ESPN BR BP Cube Kuo
ESPN BR BP Cube Kuroda
ESPN BR BP Cube LaRoche
ESPN BR BP Cube Loaiza
ESPN BR BP Cube Loney
ESPN BR BP Cube Lowe
ESPN BR BP Cube Martin
ESPN BR BP Cube May
ESPN BR BP Cube McDonald
ESPN BR BP Cube Meloan
ESPN BR BP Cube Miller
ESPN BR BP Cube Orenduff
ESPN BR BP Cube Park
ESPN BR BP Cube Paul
ESPN BR BP Cube Penny
ESPN BR BP Cube Pierre
ESPN BR BP Cube Proctor
ESPN BR BP Cube Repko
ESPN BR BP Cube Saito
ESPN BR BP Cube Schmidt
ESPN BR BP Cube Stults
ESPN BR BP Cube Sweeney
ESPN BR BP Cube Troncoso
ESPN BR BP Cube Wade
ESPN BR BP Cube Young

Selected Recent Ex-Dodgers

ESPN BR BP Cube Alomar
ESPN BR BP Cube Alvarez
ESPN BR BP Cube Aybar
ESPN BR BP Cube Baez
ESPN BR BP Cube Bako
ESPN BR BP Cube Beltre
ESPN BR BP Cube Bradley
ESPN BR BP Cube Cabrera
ESPN BR BP Cube Carrara
ESPN BR BP Cube Carter
ESPN BR BP Cube Chen
ESPN BR BP Cube Choi
ESPN BR BP Cube Cora
ESPN BR BP Cube Crosby
ESPN BR BP Cube Cruz
ESPN BR BP Cube Dessens
ESPN BR BP Cube Dreifort
ESPN BR BP Cube Drew
ESPN BR BP Cube Encarnacion
ESPN BR BP Cube Edwards
ESPN BR BP Cube Erickson
ESPN BR BP Cube Falkenborg
ESPN BR BP Cube Finley
ESPN BR BP Cube Flores
ESPN BR BP Cube Gagne
ESPN BR BP Cube Grabowski
ESPN BR BP Cube Green
ESPN BR BP Cube Guzman
ESPN BR BP Cube Hanrahan
ESPN BR BP Cube Hernandez
ESPN BR BP Cube Hundley
ESPN BR BP Cube Ishii
ESPN BR BP Cube Izturis
ESPN BR BP Cube Jackson
ESPN BR BP Cube Karros
ESPN BR BP Cube Ketchner
ESPN BR BP Cube Ledee
ESPN BR BP Cube Lima
ESPN BR BP Cube Lo Duca
ESPN BR BP Cube Lofton
ESPN BR BP Cube T. Martin
ESPN BR BP Cube Mayne
ESPN BR BP Cube G. Mota
ESPN BR BP Cube Mueller
ESPN BR BP Cube Myrow
ESPN BR BP Cube Nakamura
ESPN BR BP Cube Navarro
ESPN BR BP Cube Nomo
ESPN BR BP Cube Osoria
ESPN BR BP Cube A. Perez
ESPN BR BP Cube O. Perez
ESPN BR BP Cube Phillips
ESPN BR BP Cube Proctor
ESPN BR BP Cube Roberts
ESPN BR BP Cube Robles
ESPN BR BP Cube Romano
ESPN BR BP Cube C. Ross
ESPN BR BP Cube D. Ross
ESPN BR BP Cube Sanchez
ESPN BR BP Cube Schmoll
ESPN BR BP Cube Sele
ESPN BR BP Cube Seo
ESPN BR BP Cube Shuey
ESPN BR BP Cube Stanley
ESPN BR BP Cube S. Stewart
ESPN BR BP Cube Thompson
ESPN BR BP Cube Thurston
ESPN BR BP Cube Valentin
ESPN BR BP Cube Venafro
ESPN BR BP Cube Ventura
ESPN BR BP Cube Weaver
ESPN BR BP Cube Werth
ESPN BR BP Cube Wilson
ESPN BR BP Cube Wunsch

Dodger Thoughts Land
Thank You For Not ...

1) using profanity or any euphemisms for profanity
2) personally attacking other commenters
3) baiting other commenters
4) arguing for the sake of arguing
5) discussing politics
6) using hyperbole when something less will suffice
7) using sarcasm in a way that can be misinterpreted negatively
8) making the same point over and over again
9) typing "no-hitter" or "perfect game" to describe either in progress
10) being annoyed by the existence of this list
11) commenting under the obvious influence
12) claiming your opinion isn't allowed when it's just being disagreed with

Syndication

rss2.0

Add to My Yahoo!
The Last Nine Innings Before Flipping the Switch
2008-07-31 23:10
by Jon Weisman

When Matt Kemp lined a perfect hit-and-run single the opposite way to right field in the sixth inning tonight, I beamed. I felt so proud of him. And I began to believe the Dodgers might actually beat Brandon Webb, straight up. Derek Lowe had thrown six shutout innings, retiring 10 of the past 11 batters. Russell Martin and James Loney were coming up to bat.

But even after Martin's infield quail bounced in front of second baseman Orlando Hudson's glove, allowing Kemp to reach second and Juan Pierre to score the first run of the game, the Dodgers couldn't hold on. Conor Jackson lined a fat fastball from Lowe leading off the seventh for a double, and Mark Reynolds and Chris Snyder followed with hits to give Arizona the 2-1 lead.

Still, the Dodgers had more chances. In the eighth, pinch-hitters Andre Ethier and Mark Sweeney singled, and Pierre bunted them to third. (I don't really mind the strategy when you're just trying to get one run to stay alive, though Pierre probably would have been a good bet to at least generate a productive out swinging away.)

Kemp came up, and quickly got in the hole 0-2 against Webb. But then he got wood on a changeup and lined it to Jackson in left field. Ethier tagged up, and I really thought he'd make it home. Jackson's throw was even slightly up the line. Ethier knew to slide on the opposite side of the plate. But he went in head-first, leaving his upper body close enough to the plate for Snyder to tag him on the face. Deflation.

And still it wasn't over. Despite throwing under 100 pitches, Webb didn't come out for the ninth inning - I suppose because of the shaky eighth. Arizona turned Webb's game over to Brandon Lyon again, just as the Diamondbacks did in their recent loss to the Dodgers. Lyon quickly got two out, but then gave up a single to Casey Blake.

Up came Andruw Jones. Jeff Kent stood in the on-deck circle to bat for Angel Berroa, and you were faced with the reality that you would rather see Kent/Berroa then Jones/Kent. Nonetheless, Jones it was, on the day that his $36.2 million signing officially became a failure.

Jones made contact. But even when Jones makes contact these days, he almost never generates any power. He hit a playable fly to left field, ending the game.

Manny Ramirez arrives Friday, amid speculation about whose place he will take in the starting lineup. Kemp is safe. Who plays among Ethier, Pierre and Jones?

Look, it should be Ethier. We all know it should be Ethier. He's the only one of the three that remotely threatens a pitcher. Pierre's a gnat; Ethier's a hitter. And yet, Ethier's the easiest guy for an Old School manager to rationalize benching against Johnson. Jones bats right, making him a candidate, but Pierre has actually been outperforming Jones against lefties in 2008. It's not as if Jones' wins many of these kinds of comparisons this season. And the fact of the matter is, you don't acquire Ramirez if you think Jones is going to amount to anything.

I don't think Friday's starter is necessarily going to be an indication of who the No. 3 outfielder is. We may continue to see Jones against lefties, but I believe he'll play the least. Ethier vs. Pierre? That's an open question, though I think we'll see a lot of Ethier at least in the late innings. I do think Ethier could come away with the third starting job, but I won't promise it.

* * *

This quote on Diamond Leung's blog at the Press-Enterprise stirred some reaction:

Logan White spoke with Andy LaRoche and Bryan Morris, and he said LaRoche was excited to go to Pittsburgh. Asked if White was sad to see LaRoche go, he said, "Not at all."

I asked Leung to give the context of White's response, and Leung replied that White meant in terms of "Look who we got back."

* * *

Alex Eisenberg of Baseball-Intellect.com offers a scouting report on Ramirez.
* * *

We broke every Dodger Thoughts visitation record today, including the 2,000-comment barrier. And it was really a great day in the chat - filled with lively debate that included plenty of healthy but well-tempered disagreement. Not everyone is happy with what went down today, but I hope most of you who participated enjoyed coming here to talk about it.

Comments (180)
Show/Hide Comments 1-50
2008-07-31 23:24:56
1.   silverwidow
Congrats to Andy LaRoche on finally getting a chance to begin his career.
2008-07-31 23:29:07
2.   Tripon
The Webb game was pretty much the reason why we had to trade for Manny when we had the chance. The D'Backs would be crapping their pants if they had to face Manny instead of Andruw Jones.
2008-07-31 23:33:04
3.   Neal Pollack
It will be a very different Dodger team tomorrow night. Oh boy oh boy oh boy!
2008-07-31 23:33:37
4.   bigcpa
Tomorrow night: madhouse. Brings back memories of this game I foolishly left early: http://tinyurl.com/bigcpaleftearly
2008-07-31 23:33:59
5.   Eric Stephen
Assuming Nomar is still out for tomorrow, I find it interesting in a weird way that the Dodger lineup will likely feature three players the Dodgers are paying exactly $0 this season (Blake, Berroa, Manny).
2008-07-31 23:34:39
6.   Eric Stephen
4
I'm shocked that tinyurl was available! :)
2008-07-31 23:35:04
7.   bhsportsguy
3 Well, it will have Manny but I just don't know if Kemp and Ethier will ever start a game together for the rest of the year.

And if Pierre and Manny start a game together, whoever else is playing better drink a lot of coffee that day.

2008-07-31 23:36:13
8.   LAT
I spent a lot of time online today and one thing is clear: this is by far the most intelligent, informative baseball blog on the web. The discussion was thoughtful, answered all my questions and many I hadn't even thought of. Thanks all.
2008-07-31 23:36:35
9.   Longhorn Bill
You are right Jon, it has been a good day.

July is gone and August arrives with many reasons for hope in Dodgerland.

The starting and relief pitching have been fantastic and the offense finally has a chance to produce the kind of runs that make winning easy, given how our arms have been performing. Kemp is starting, Manny is in Dodger blue, Martin is Martin, and I believe Ethier will secure his place in the lineup in the coming days.

Martin
Ethier
Kemp
Manny
Loney
Kent
Black
Berroa
Pitcher

Fellas, that is pretty darn good. Things have not been perfect this year, or close to it, but when have they ever been? Let's agree on the notion that the Dodgers finally are ready to make some noise, specifically the kind of noise that brings a smiles to fans faces. It's going to be a fun couple of months.

2008-07-31 23:36:41
10.   Jon Weisman
7 - I will bet you any amount of money that Kemp and Ethier will start another game together this year, and I'll bet you some amount of money that it will happen in the next week.
2008-07-31 23:37:19
11.   Longhorn Bill
woops, Blake
2008-07-31 23:38:05
12.   natepurcell
10

I need odds!

2008-07-31 23:41:08
13.   bhsportsguy
Just some levity.

"The movie or the planet?"

"And you are starring ... as the human."

"It's the part I was born to play baby!"

"I hate every ape I see from Chimp-pan-a to Chimp-pan-zee."

"Oh my god, I was wrong. It was earth all along."

"Down in front!"

2008-07-31 23:41:31
14.   silverwidow
I'm excited about our young, defense-first team in 2009.

1B Loney
2B DeJesus
SS Hu
3B DeWitt
LF Pierre
CF Kemp
RF Ethier

Go hardcore with pitching (money from all the expiring contracts should go to Sabathia and Sheets). Decline Penny's option.

Sabathia
Billingsley
Sheets
Kershaw
Kuroda

2008-07-31 23:42:28
15.   KG16
i'm just bummed that i was without a connection today. made it rather difficult to know what was going on.
2008-07-31 23:43:01
16.   sporky
14 That rotation would be unreal.
2008-07-31 23:43:52
17.   bhsportsguy
10 I will give you a dollar for every game they start togetherr from tomorrow until the DT picnic. I hope comes to double digits.

And this only goes for Jon, I don't want any other DTers asking for money that day, it is enought that I am making breakfast.

2008-07-31 23:43:53
18.   sporky
1 Amen.
2008-07-31 23:44:21
19.   Blue81
Manny-Kemp-Ethier just makes too much sense to occur on a regular basis. Ethier I fear will sit the majority of the time, supplanting Manny here and there. Jones is a non-factor, and has been all season, but I imagine Torre will look to get him AB's.
2008-07-31 23:44:58
20.   bhsportsguy
15 I think underdog will be at the game next Friday at AT&T.
2008-07-31 23:45:27
21.   KG16
13 - that was such a great episode.
2008-07-31 23:45:38
22.   Alex41592
I don't think Torre is going to feel comfortable playing Pierre in center. He chose Kemp over Pierre in center for a reason. I really think Pierre is going to lose significant time. Manny is going to play left field. Torre would have to choose to play Pierre over Kemp in center with left field now hereby known as Mannyland. I just don't see it happening.
2008-07-31 23:45:59
23.   bablue
From the Manny scouting report: "2. If you look at the players on the Dodgers roster and their contract situations...this is really their last chance. The Dodgers should be going into full-blown rebuilding mode after this year."

That's pretty harsh.

14, That would be exciting but no way we sign both CC and Sheets and I doubt we won't sign at least one FA bat.

2008-07-31 23:46:29
24.   KG16
20 - i confirmed that i will be in SF next weekend, i just don't know what i'm going to be doing when i get there.

game is still an option.

2008-07-31 23:47:17
25.   bhsportsguy
19 Can you imagine this graphic on the Fox game of the week.

~$800K (Manny, Kemp, Ethier)

Sitting on the bench - ~$27M (Pierre, Jones).

2008-07-31 23:47:38
26.   trainwreck
7
To answer your question from previous thread:

I said earlier that I think Kim and Logan are no longer free from criticism. If we make a change in management, I want a complete change.

2008-07-31 23:48:12
27.   natepurcell
14

I don't think Dejesus is going to be ready to start next year.

1b Loney
2b Hu
ss Furcal (1 year deal)
3b Dewitt
RF Ethier
CF Kemp
LF Manny

I have no idea what happens to Jones and Pierre but that team isn't that expensive and should be defensively sufficient enough.

2008-07-31 23:50:26
28.   MonkeyBlue
22. I have to agree with you there! Pierre and Manny would make the worst combo of outfielders.
2008-07-31 23:50:58
29.   bhsportsguy
26 You mean none of them deserve DeWayne Walker status?

An aside to trainwreck, I saw Coach Walker in June and he told me how taken aback he was by all the support he got from everyone.

I'll be at some of the practices next week so I'll you posted on what is going there.

2008-07-31 23:50:59
30.   KG16
23 - last chance? wha?

Aren't the Dodgers in a position to be contenders for a decade? Kemp, Martin, Loney, Ethier, Billingsly, Kershaw, Broxton - that sounds like a pretty solid core of guys to build around.

I think the better analysis is that the team has done pretty much all it can with respect to building from within and now must build through free agency. There's still a chance for Hu, DeJesus, or DeWitt to become part of the core, but not all of them (one likely). Time for better decisions on the free agency front.

2008-07-31 23:52:15
31.   Paul Scott
After thinking a lot about this trade, a trade my gut told me was terrible for the Dodgers from the start, I decided some math was in order.

The problem with that, however, is that the sample size for the remainder of the season is so small that a "net-wins" analysis is far more likely to be wrong than right (in either direction). What we need is beyond me, other than to say that as I thought it out, that we need it is further evidence of how awful this trade is.

Basically, long term, what we did was trade LaRoche and Morris for two top-50 draft picks. That is a trade that is clearly stupid.

The remainder of the trade is some increased probability of winning our division this year. As we stand today, before the trade and before tonight's loss, we had a 35ish% chance to make the playoffs (for the Dodgers, making the playoffs and winning the division are so close to the same thing as to consider them identical). So, what will our probability be tomorrow, before the game starts? I don't know. The math is beyond me. What I do feel, however, is that it just can't be that great an amount.

I also feel very certain that by merely playing the right players (forget all year - just start doing it now) would have meant more than the acquisitions of Blake and Ramirez. There is a substantial possibility that the Ramirez acquisition could mean very little (assume he replaces Either) and certainly a non-zero chance that it hurt us (assume he replaces Either day-to-day and several more games are Ramirez-Jones-Pierre).

Given what Torre has shown us all year, I don't see how the conclusion can be that the right choices will be made. But, even if they are, I just don't see this move as likely to move us from 35% to 60+% to make the playoffs. Maybe someone more capable can do the math and convince me I am wrong.

2008-07-31 23:52:59
32.   Blue81
22

Don't forget Blake and Kent in the infield.

Manny-Pierre OF.

Atrocious.

2008-07-31 23:53:03
33.   KG16
27 - I could live with that line up. I hear Cincinatti might be looking for an outfielder next year...
2008-07-31 23:53:46
34.   trainwreck
29
Sweet, thanks. DeWayne's not long for UCLA, so we got to appreciate him while we can. Same for Chow obviously. Hopefully they can lay down the foundation for the future.
2008-07-31 23:55:33
35.   sporky
Assuming we pick up Penny's option, $55.75M is owed to Jones, Schmidt, Kuroda, Penny and Pierre in 2009.
2008-07-31 23:59:39
36.   trainwreck
Plus $4 million for Joe Torre.

We really know how to waste money.

2008-08-01 00:01:53
37.   Tripon
33 Cincy still got to pay Adam Dunn, and I doubt Manny would want to go to the Reds, the guy's been incredible successful, playing for some really great teams that are either in the playoffs, or in the world series. Even Manny must know that the Reds don't go to the playoffs, they just go to the back of the line.
2008-08-01 00:02:12
38.   Eric Stephen
Don't forget the $4m due Furcal in January 2009 (signing bonus), plus the $1.25m due Nomar in each of the next 2 seasons (also signing bonus)!
2008-08-01 00:03:02
39.   natepurcell
37

I think he meant for a spot for Jones or Pierre..

2008-08-01 00:06:39
40.   Xeifrank
If Manny is a sure thing to start in LF (which he is). Then this Ethier vs Pierre for the 3rd OF spot, would mean that Kemp would have to go to RF on games that Pierre started. I can't imagine for the life of me, Juan Pierre and his weak arm, starting in RF. And if Jones gets the occasional start in CF, then Pierre has no spot to play in those games too.
vr, Xei
2008-08-01 00:08:08
41.   Eric Stephen
If Manny was traded last trading deadline, he would have had close to the same amount of PAs in both Cleveland & Boston. He's been a remarkably and consistently great hitter his whole career:

w/Cleveland (1993-2000)
4095 PA, .313/.407/.592, 152 OPS+

w/Boston (2001-2008)
4682 PA, .312/.411/.588, 155 OPS+

2008-08-01 00:11:31
42.   Alex41592
40 - Exactly.

Manny/Kemp/Ethier

OR

Manny/Jones/Kemp

OR

Manny/Pierre/Kemp (though starting Pierre over Kemp in center is a terrible idea)

The only way Pierre plays with Manny in the lineup is in center field.

2008-08-01 00:14:18
43.   Tripon
31 You're pretty cheerful. Even if you liked LaRoche, and feel that he should be the 3rd baseman of the future, he wasn't trusted by the current staff for whatever reason. (Personally, I think his whining his way back up to the Dodgers after his rehab stint hurt his stock with Torre. LaRoche didn't handle that as a Team First kinda way, he handled it pretty selfishly, even if it was his right to complain he wasn't on the roster, but I'm sure that pissed off Torre enough that he just stuck with DeWitt until had to swap him for LaRoche for a couple of games, and then Casey Blake.)

We can talk about stats, and all that, but the reality is that 'playing the right players'(who I assume you mean the majority of the younger players) wasn't going to happen. Management would never allow that to happen unless massive injuries happened to all the Vets on the team like Kent, and Pierre, and even then, they would go sign a vet from the scrap heap like Ozuna, and Berroa. Getting Manny means that this current team is greatly improved that what it was 24 ago, and he instantly becomes our best player. Yes, even Matt Kemp who I love, but is still only 23 and might actually learn a thing or two to become a better player from one of the best in Manny.

But to say this trade was stupid just because you want to simplified the trade for LaRoche, and Morris for Two draft picks, that is your precognitive. But you're seriously underrating the impact Manny has on this team, and might have on future years since McCourt has shown he is a huge spender in the offseason. McCourt is the same owner who allow Ned Coletti to give Andruw Jones a $36 million contract, Juan Pierre $54 million, Jason Schimdt $39 million. And McCourt doesn't even like those guys. McCourt's still a Red Sox fan at heart and with Manny's he's going to vote with his heart. He's going to pay Manny whatever he wants. Anyway, that's my two sense.

2008-08-01 00:19:16
44.   Eric Stephen
Numbers for Manny to live up to:

Bill Madlock, 1985
34 G, .360/.422/.447, 147 OPS+ Dodgers are 22-13 when he starts

Steve Finley, 2004
58 G, .263/.324/.491, 112 OPS+, 13 HR, 46 RBI, Division-winning slam

Marlon Anderson, 2006
25 G, .375/.431/.813, 208 OPS+, 7 HR, "The Marlon Anderson Game" (before it got renamed)

2008-08-01 00:21:27
45.   Eric Stephen
43
Personally, I think his whining his way back up to the Dodgers after his rehab stint hurt his stock with Torre

When did LaRoche do this? He never bashed the organization in interviews, and for the most part said all the right things when asked about his demotion.

He earned his way back to the club by hitting in AAA.

2008-08-01 00:23:28
46.   bhsportsguy
I'm surprised no one typed witness to my bet with Jon.

And no, you will not get a percentage.

2008-08-01 00:23:58
47.   bhsportsguy
44 I caught a foul ball from Bill Madlock.
2008-08-01 00:25:37
48.   Eric Stephen
46
Well, it's out there on the interwebs now, unless of course Bob comes along and deletes it, vigilante that he is.
2008-08-01 00:27:01
49.   Paul Scott
43 I wouldn't be noting my inability to calculate the full value of the trade if I, as you claim, simplified it to LaRoche and Morris for two draft picks. I note that it is that (something I hope everyone would agree would be stupid) PLUS some increase in our chances to make the playoffs this year. I am incapable of quantifying the plus.
2008-08-01 00:32:06
50.   Tripon
45 And then he complained that he was healthy in Triple A, and was wondering why he wasn't called up. Maybe I'm not remembering it the right way, and I'm trying to find the Dodgers report in the Times that talk about this. I'm not saying that it wasn't in his right to question why he wasn't called up, but I gotta say it was the wrong play for him if he wanted to A) play everyday, and B) Get on Torre's good side which he never seemed to do.
Show/Hide Comments 51-100
2008-08-01 00:34:58
51.   Andrew Shimmin
Personally, I think his whining his way back up to the Dodgers after his rehab stint hurt his stock with Torre

If that's true, then Joe Torre is a little girl.

In a frilly pink dress.

2008-08-01 00:40:51
52.   sporky
50 Who are we talking about?
2008-08-01 00:40:57
53.   GoBears
31. That's basically how I feel about the trade, and what I tried to say in the pre-game threads.

Of course, to actually explain the decision, in addition to allowing for the possibility that Colletti et al., way overestimate the marginal 2008 on-field impact of Ramirez, you have to consider:

1. The marginal impact on butts-in-seats, and the attendant concessions, parking, etc.

2. The marginal impact on Colletti's future stream of income, either from McCourt or Peter McGowan, or whomever.

Both of those numbers are big, I would imagine, or at least perceived to be big, which would explain, if not excuse the decision.

Colletti made the 3rd base decision Torre-proof with the Casey Blake pickup and LaRoche demotion/exile. But he really screwed up the OF choice set, and increased the probability that Torre will choose to leave win shares on the bench. And like you, I have no faith that Torre will avoid the mistake of wasting one third of the outfield at-bats.

Don't get me wrong - I'm very excited to see Ramirez bat as a Dodger. But then I enjoyed having Sheffield here. I love to watch great hitters hit. But I still think this was a mistake, unless they dump Pierre AND Jones this winter and play them precious little between now and then.

I'm also going to root very hard for Andy LaRoche in Pittsburgh. Who knows - maybe we'll take him back as a free agent once he's all veterany and stuff.

2008-08-01 00:41:47
54.   bhsportsguy
50 I'm not sure its productive to go down this road regardless of whether Andy LaRoche said anything or not.

The key thing is that Pittsburgh felt that he and Morris were enough when addded to Boston's prospects to give up Bay.

Jayson Stark's early review of this deal is that Pittsburgh again went with quantity if not a big sure thing prospect after talking to other scouts. I will repeat what I have said about Andy for months now, if we cannot take his work in the minors and rely upon that for any kind of prediction in how he will do in majors than we should just promote guys straight out of Rookie Ball because Andy had the best work than the guys who remain in Dodger Blue today.

That is why there is some concern about the deal.

That said, given all the alternatives, if you are going to get a 2 month rental, the price was reasonable and you can't really dispute Manny's credentials. But even when they produce like Teixeira did for Atlanta, that doesn't mean you will achieve your ultimate goal.

And that is how this deal will be measured since Manny will be gone the second the last out of the Dodger season is made.

2008-08-01 00:49:37
55.   Andrew Shimmin
I don't really think Joe Torre is a girl. My theory is that Torre doesn't think Andy LaRoche is good at baseball. I think he's wrong about that. But I don't think he would sit a player he thought was better because of nebulous personal problems he would have had to strain to invent. He's a professional baseball manager. It's his job to field the best team available to him. I think he did that, to the best of his judgment.
2008-08-01 00:51:47
56.   GoBears
55. Yeah, unfortunately, I think you're right.
2008-08-01 00:55:10
57.   paranoidandroid
Do we DL Nomar tomorrow or send a pitcher down with an off day on Monday? I think we want a stacked pen for the next three games.

When was Nomar's last game? He has to sit out 15 days after that. We can always bring up Hu on Tuesday and send a pitcher down then until Nomar is ready but then we are left with the same dilemma.

It was interesting to see Martin at third and Blake at second. Those kind of moves could leave Ozuna out of a job if Nomar is really ready to go soon. But we can't count on his health for sixty days, can we?

Does someone like Jones develop a phantom injury and then has to rehab in Vegas until the end of August?

Lost in all of this is what to do with Delwyn when he comes off the DL. He is out of options. Does he get traded for Maddux or Jack Wilson or David Eckstein or just DFA'd?

2008-08-01 00:55:28
58.   bhsportsguy
55 I will always view it as he showed patience with a young player that had the confidence of a new coaching staff that had nothing to compare against since LaRoche got hurt in ST.

It was always hard for me to say push DeWitt out because really if he was one of the other guys (and mean any of them), everyone here would be pleased that the management was giving him time to work things out.

It didn't happen and once they went another way, they sent DeWitt down to play everyday.

LaRoche never got that opportunity that I think this staff was ready to give him back in ST. That's unfortunate but because his value remained high, the Dodgers did not have to give up one of their young regulars nor a better lower level prospect than Morris.

2008-08-01 00:56:32
59.   Andrew Shimmin
I'm also not sure I see why it would be okay to sit one of Pierre or Jones, but not both. Once you decide you can (must, even) sit a big money player, you've broken the taboo of doing it. What's left to keep you from sitting them both?
2008-08-01 00:56:44
60.   bhsportsguy
57 Or Delwyn could just stay on the DL until September 1st.

I think that is the most likely thing.

2008-08-01 00:57:48
61.   sporky
Surreal.

http://losangeles.dodgers.mlb.com/team/player.jsp?player_id=120903

And there are currently 26 players on the active roster.

2008-08-01 01:00:38
62.   sporky
Sweeney's OPS is up to .364!
2008-08-01 01:01:34
63.   paranoidandroid
60 The prolonged nonsense phantom injuries are common in the NBA, but it is more rare in MLB. First Sweeney, now Delwyn. Can we really keep him on the DL until Sept 1st and then activate him? I hope you're right but it seems to be really bending the rules a bit.
2008-08-01 01:01:52
64.   bhsportsguy
61 They could put Nomar on the DL, call up Hu and DFA Ozuna, I think Sweeney stays for now. I think with 3 starters that you don't know what you'll get, Joe won't feel comfortable with only 11 on his staff.
2008-08-01 01:03:03
65.   Tripon
59 They have the excuse that Juan Pierre's playing fairly well since he came off the DL, and they might actually talk themselves into it.
2008-08-01 01:03:49
66.   bhsportsguy
63 Its an oblique, I mean he said it still hurt when he did the chat. Why not drag it out, I mean they do have at least 2 outfielders who will be on the bench already.

And you don't want to risk that type of injury anyway. A bad swing can reaggravate it.

2008-08-01 01:05:42
67.   GMac In The 909
Not everyone is happy with what went down today, but I hope most of you who participated enjoyed coming here to talk about it.

I enjoyed it all ... up until 541 & 542 of the previous thread. I'd hope both the comments and author get deleted soon. There has to be a violation or seven in there somewhere.

2008-08-01 01:06:01
68.   Andrew Shimmin
58- I know. And it's a perfectly respectable opinion. I thought it was an imprudent patience, and I think it's had pretty ugly consequences, but it's over now, so, there you go.

Also, I'm a D'backs fan, so, I'm happy LaRoche is out of the division. I just wish you'd had to give up Kershaw, too.

2008-08-01 01:06:02
69.   Tripon
From rotoworld.com

Nationals released catcher Paul Lo Duca.
Lo Duca, who was given a $5 million contract over the winter, hit .230/.301/.281 in 139 at-bats for the Nationals. While there was no interest in him at his current salary, he figures to be pretty popular once he becomes available for the minimum. The Astros, Dodgers and Reds could consider him.

Because we need a no power slug like Lo Duca again.

2008-08-01 01:11:04
70.   Tripon
67 Its a violation of rule one.

1) using profanity or any euphemisms for profanity

2008-08-01 01:12:02
71.   GMac In The 909
69 tinyurl.com/heartANDsoul
2008-08-01 01:16:01
72.   GMac In The 909
70 ... and at least 3, 6, 7 and 8.
2008-08-01 01:31:00
73.   bablue
54,
How do you know we won't resign Manny?
2008-08-01 01:31:59
74.   trainwreck
I miss Andy. Even though he would have more pop if he changed his name to Andrew. But, I still miss him.

But since I was so negative at the report of the trade, I will try to be positive and hope we can win a playoff series and justify trading him away. I like Manny Ramirez, even if he is lazier than I am.

All I want is Joe to start the right outfield and I will give Ned & Co. leeway for a bit. I am willing to be reasonable for a little bit, so the ball is in your court Dodgers. Please do not let me down, like you have pretty much done the entire time that I can remember being on this planet.

2008-08-01 01:41:08
75.   Michael D
69

Hey Lo Duca could be Martin's caddy. Ardoin seems to actually know how to play defense so I'm in no rush to see it, but it would make a nice little story for Mr. "heart and soul" to come back and finish his career here mentoring the next heart and soul of the Dodgers. That of course assumes he's willing to accept being a backup, and doesn't hate us over the trade.

2008-08-01 01:49:56
76.   Andrew Shimmin
Lo Duca's previous mentoring experience is the sort of thing that could have gotten him some prison time. It might be time for him to write his memoirs. I just hope he's diligent in checking the ages of his research assistants.
2008-08-01 02:23:44
77.   Michael D
Also speaking of DL shenanigans, it looks like we've made Gary Bennett go away somehow. Not that I'm complaining.
2008-08-01 05:29:41
78.   D4P
I asked Leung to give the context of White's response, and Leung replied that White meant in terms of "Look who we got back."

To me, that doesn't really dispose of the issue. Of course White's excited to get Ramirez. We never doubted that.

The point is that he says nothing positive about Andy. Normally in these situations someone in White's position would say something like, "Yes, we're sorry to see Andy go, but we're excited to get Ramir