Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
Jon's other site:
Screen Jam
TV and more ...
1) using profanity or any euphemisms for profanity
2) personally attacking other commenters
3) baiting other commenters
4) arguing for the sake of arguing
5) discussing politics
6) using hyperbole when something less will suffice
7) using sarcasm in a way that can be misinterpreted negatively
8) making the same point over and over again
9) typing "no-hitter" or "perfect game" to describe either in progress
10) being annoyed by the existence of this list
11) commenting under the obvious influence
12) claiming your opinion isn't allowed when it's just being disagreed with
The real story tonight is the Dodgers' Game 3 National League Championship Series victory, but I do have to get this out of the way. I don't really want to hear Shane Victorino complaining that Hiroki Kuroda threw at his head.
Despite being a card-carrying member of baseball's Pacifist Society, even I felt the Dodgers had to show some kind of retaliation in the third inning tonight. And the picture to the right is why.
The Dodgers had been pitched tough inside all series, but that's no sin. Among other things, Manny Ramirez had a Brett Myers pitch go behind him - but supposedly, that slipped. Okay. Then tonight, Russell Martin got hit by a Jamie Moyer pitch in the first inning, but it was a sub-80s changeup that loaded the bases. Even though a potential beanball war had been a significant topic of discussion Friday night and Saturday, Moyer is absolved.
But with this pitch that you can see to your right, enough was enough. This one was heading for Martin's chin if not his eyes, and this was the one that moved the needle beyond intimidation into something worse. This was the one that passed the limit of making excuses, to the point where it seemed clear to everyone that the Phillies did not care whether a Dodger got hurt. Paramount for the Dodgers was to win the game on the field. But until the Dodgers sent a Phillie spinning to the dirt, nothing was going to stop Philadelphia from continuing to make the Dodgers duck and cover.
I am not endorsing hitting people with pitches. I am not endorsing throwing at someone's head. But Victorino and the Phillies had no right to complain. It started with them. They don't get to throw at Martin's face and then be offended.
I'm hoping that now, it's over. While the Dodger Stadium crowd (already energized by the five-run first-inning and 6-1 lead in a critical Game 3) seemed eager to see the benches empty, I was petrified. I don't want to see players from either team ejected. I want to see baseball.
For the most part, the umpires kept the situation under control. But something occurred to me for the first time tonight as I watched those six black-suited men try to keep about 70 people at bay. In theory, major league baseball doesn't want a fight to break out. Assuming that's the case, should the sport allow stadium security to step in and help keep the combatants apart?
On first glance, this might really seem excessive. It's just a game. But I'm not talking about having bobbies with billy clubs raising cain. I'm just talking about having more people to separate the two teams, because if the fight doesn't break out in the first few seconds, it won't unless it's given the opportunity to. Tonight, there were almost too many pockets of tension for the umpires to police.
At some point, if the chaos got really out of control - you know, chairs thrown, knives drawn, Jets and Sharks security probably would get involved. I'm just wondering about whether security should be preventative instead of reactive. (Unless, of course, baseball really doesn't mind that much if some punches get thrown.) I just would have hated to have seen ejections and suspensions - or worse, injuries - that could have been prevented. It seems awkward, maybe even untenable, especially because fighting isn't a rampant issue in baseball like it is in hockey, but I'm wondering if it would be better for the sport to have security help the umpires keep the peace.
But enough about the extracurriculars - let's talk about the Dodgers' win. After Rafael Furcal made a nice tag to help nab Chase Utley on a somewhat surprising steal attempt with Ryan Howard at bat in the top of the first inning, Furcal helped the Dodgers jump on an ineffective Jamie Moyer with a leadoff single. Andre Ethier and Manny Ramirez also singled to give the Dodgers an early lead for the third straight game, and one Nomar Garciaparra strikeout after Martin's first hit-by-pitch, Casey Blake looped one to right to score a second run.
With two out, Matt Kemp got the count to 3-0 before striking out on a pitch that was probably too close to take, but then Blake DeWitt, after being down 0-2, drove a no-doubter bases-loaded triple to right - and suddenly, the mojo of the Cubs series had returned. Every Dodger starting position player reached base, with Furcal answering the Phillies' second-inning run with a home run, his first since May.
Kuroda might have been even better tonight than he was a week ago in the NLDS clincher. He retired 13 consecutive batters from the third inning through the end of the sixth. But just like last week, he couldn't get out of the seventh. It was frustrating, because after giving up a leadoff double to Utley, Howard reached on what appeared to be a catchable fly ball that Ethier didn't get a good read on and shied away from, and then Burrell looped a weak 140-footer to cut the Dodger lead to five and bring Joe Torre out of the dugout with two runners on.
Though Cory Wade once again put out the fire, he ended up throwing 33 pitches tonight, which limits what he can bring in relief of Derek Lowe in Game 4 Monday. The Dodgers will have Hong-Chih Kuo, Clayton Kershaw, Greg Maddux and Joe Beimel to help get the game from Lowe to Broxton, so that might be sufficient, but it was just such a shame that two near-outs prevented Kuroda from cruising past the seventh.
With the home team 11-0 in Phillies-Dodgers games this year, not only Game 4 but Game 5 on Wednesday would seem to remain critical for the Dodgers. But neither game is a gimme. Though Lowe is a decent bet on three days' rest, it's hard to know what he'll bring - and his opponent, Joe Blanton, will have had a week off since pitching six innings of one-run, seven-strikeout ball in the Phillies' NLDS clincher over Milwaukee. Meanwhile, Game 5 offers a brilliant matchup between Cole Hamels and Chad Billingsley that, no matter how much one esteems Billingsley or believes in his ability to recover from his Game 2 debacle, can't remotely be painted as a lock for Los Angeles.
On the other hand, if the Dodgers manage to get the series back to Philly, things could turn in their favor. Kuroda vs. Myers in Game 6? Lowe vs. Moyer (would it still be Moyer?) in Game 7? The road is still the road, and it will be all hands on deck in Game 7 if it gets that far. However, even if the Dodgers don't sweep the Los Angeles games, I wouldn't count them out.
But the Dodgers certainly need to win at least one of their next two, and their fans will feel heeps better if a win somehow comes Monday. Things are gonna be even more intense at 5:22 p.m. tomorrow than they were today. Get your rest ...
Here we go again,
East Coast ESPN (radio) condemning the Dodgers for not throwing back in Game 2. Brett Myers is now a marked man. I hate unwritten rules!
I was so fed up, I sent this email to ESPN:
"I am so sick of these stupid unwritten rules. You have to go [retaliate] with a guy in the same inning with two outs. I'm more interested in getting guys OUT. Yea Victorino isn't the best choice, but again, two outs, same inning.
For goodness sake, what do the Dodgers have to do? Throw at Chase Utley at every at bat? Get Juan Pierre to charge the mound? Get the whole team suspended by fighting the Phillies bullpen?! You can't risk losing players to ejections and suspensions. End of story."
Dodgers, don't give in to this junk... the bat is mightier than the sword!
In my mind, tomorrow is a must-win with Hamels going on Wednesday. That game is not necessarily a must-win, but it'd really take the wind out of the Phillies' sails if we could take that one. Bills'll have a real shot for redemption in that game.
I was at the game with my brother and niece, as well as Jacob Burch. We had a great time. I also had the pleasure of meeting sporky, as well as seeing bhsportsguy and dkminnick.
I hate to continue beating the Journey drum, but a funny moment happened when I told my brother Broxton would be even more effective if he had entrance music. I suggested the theme from Jaws, but about 1.2 seconds after the bullpen gates opened Don't Stop Believin' blared through the loud speakers. It was a total coincidence, but I thought it hilarious.
The good tidings continue tomorrow night. My collection of rally towels is growing by leaps and bounds this fall!
Pitchers born in Japan, from Baseball Reference:
http://preview.tinyurl.com/3wds2n
I didn't click on each one to see if they'd pitched with the Dodgers.
If he didn't see it, that's one thing, but if he was being conservative in that situation, I'd rather he wasn't.
I haven't seen any replays, but on first view I didn't think Ethier had a chance on that play. I could be wrong of course, but I thought Ethier was just trying to trick the runner into thinking it could be caught.
https://mikesrants.baseballtoaster.com/archives/1159356.html
;-)
Being on the field for the flag ceremony was a feeling unlike any I've experienced. We were out there during the player intros and being in the center of the outfield with about 40,000 (at the start) and with everyone waving those towels, it was amazing. One woman who was also helping carry the flag was in tears - she said it was just great being out there, in the center of the stadium, with real Dodger fans. I got some great photos from that vantage point too.
Man, I think we just renewed a big-time baseball rivalry. Do you think this will carry over into next season?
I get a kick out of how "bush league unsportsman like actions" are a show of courage, according to the East Coast. Um... I think beating the team 7-2 makes more of a statement.
That is AWESOME! Congratulations on getting the privilege to carry out that big flag!
milkshakeballa disagreed with you on whether security is needed during baseball brawls, and from that you've determined whether msb doesn't care if Manny gets run?
Are you trolling your own board?
And I agree.....the chemistry in the locker room after the game today is probably at its best since the day before Loduca got traded.
And I agree.....the chemistry in the locker room after the game today is probably at its best since the day before Loduca got traded.
That said, I also agree with Jon that they had to do something, even if it's just a plunk pitch or throwing a few feet over Victorino's head. Are they supposed to get continually thrown at (Martin has been hit or thrown at at least 4 times in this series so far by my count) and take it like men? Again, it's a matter of judgment, as the umps knew pretty well, and as Martin understood (when he was later hit by that weak curveball he didn't get bent out of shape, despite Mike's Rant on the subject). But some of those others, well it adds up. Enough was enough. That's baseball. Time to move on. Don't let it get to you, Manny.
I don't remember whether Ozuna's on the NLCS roster, though, which might make it hard to have that happen.
The umps "handled" it by the skin of their teeth. There's a clear choice here: leave it at 6-on-60 and hope for the best, or throw in a few friendly reinforcements and feel more secure that the best players in the game don't get suspended over some macho code.
I'm not trying to change the world and certainly not trying to demean anyone, but I feel it's a legitimate question. What's the reason for not letting security get involved? Is there a significant cost if a guy in a white polo shirt and black pants gets in between a Dodger and a Phillie?
In rugby, which is a game involving constant violent physical contact, action has been taken for punches thrown by players that have caused serious injury. If someone really hurts someone with malice outside what's consented to as part of the game then that's the appropriate recourse.
But I think players must have the ability to stand up for themselves and their team mates to an extent. The game, like most good games, has an element of violence and intimidation about it: the takeout slide, the hard play at home. We don't want ice hockey, but some aggression is OK. As Crash Davis said 'fear and arrogance'.
I'd rather let players control the situation than security. If Manny is silly enough to get ejected and suspended then so be it.
Well said, underdog! This whole thing really is ridiculous. It's as if the Phillies knew they had weaker pitching (at least for starters), and figured they'd go with this junk to make up for it. So classless, and yet, so fitting.
I got a few good pictures but my most found memories will be hearing/seeing the crowd go crazy as Manny, Martin, and Nomar were announced.
Obviously the chance to do anything on the field does not come very often, but if you ever have the chance, jump on it. It is truly and indescribable feeling.
actually if you were following on Fox's hot corner one of the shots was of Manny walking out of the dugout snapping and swaying from side to side
You're a Dodger all the way
From your first hit-by-pitch
To your last dyin' day.
When you're a Dodger,
If the spit hits the fan,
You got brothers around,
You're a family man!
{snap snap snap}
I also had a close up view of Kuroda and Martin warming up (separately) in the outfield before the game.
I heard he's partying at Manny's house.
I have to thank bhsportsguy for giving me a ticket and a ride - I probably owe him a kidney. And it was great to finally meet a few DTers (Jacob Burch, Eric Stephen, Bob T, dkminnick, and Bluebleeder87)!
:) Coe on back Manny! At a discount! :)
By the way, I like how the Dodgers pitched Rollins inside during the at bat before Victorino's.
Lastly, what the heck did Victorino and Kuroda say to each other?
Kuroda: "So, Victorino-san. Don't stand on the plate."
"Can you imagine being Joe Torre in that situation? You're trying to calm your players down, looking for help from your coaches... until you realize two of your coaches are Mariano Duncan and Larry Bowathe most mentally unstable guys in the stadium."
http://www.clas.ufl.edu/users/creed/Law/Hackbart.html
http://www.clas.ufl.edu/users/creed/Law/Hackbart.html
The kid's a ball player sure 'nuff
Lots of clutch rbi's
Love it
Well, ahem, our own Jon Weisman isn't exactly a potted plant. That's quite an opus at 0 .
Blake DeWitt = Scott Brosius
Andre Ethier = Paul O'Neill
I also hope we don't get too comfortable after teeing off on Moyer, because i think Blanton can be dangerous..
A win was wonderful though, and I do like our chances...I hope the Ravine is rocking and that we can keep the mojo going
"To me, they're like a school of sharks, kind of on the prowl," he said. "And if you can keep kind of keep them all separated in the pool, you know, it's a great way to go after them. But when they kind of swarm together and they see the blood in the water, I think they attack and they do a very good job of it."
http://tinyurl.com/48vjhm
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oW2Qwy4gYgg
Are the Dodgers down on Billingsley for not throwing a retaliatory strike (or ball)? It sounds like the Dodgers are down on somebody specific for not throwing a brushback at the Phillies last week.
1) Jimmy Rollins has looked AWFUL all series. Like, he's completely forgotten how to swing at a baseball, or tell balls from strikes. It's just painful.
2) We should be winning every game because of this. I hate that we've pretty much contained the top of their line-up and we're down 2-1 in this series because we got killed by their 8 and 9 hitters in game 2.
3) I can see what Jon's saying, and I'm not opposed to having security on the field. I was absolutely expecting one of their mop-up relievers to throw the ball at Manny's head in retaliation for the Victorino thing just to see if he would charge the mound and take a swing--which he most certainly would have done at that point. Because if random guy gets suspended and Manny gets suspended, it's a huge plus for the Phillies.
Thing is, I don't really know if a security guard would be able to stop that. It seems like most brawls start within a couple of seconds. Assuming the guard isn't standing right there on the mound, I don't know how he stops Manny from clocking that pitcher.
75. ToyCannon
It is easy to retaliate up 7-1 and throw at the head of the smallest player in the linup. Real balls shown by the Dodgers there. I guess Martin didn't want to bounce off of Howards thighs when he went to go tackle him.
Getting a ball thrown at his head and complaining about his complaining. Give me a break. That's his life and it wasn't a 84 mile an error patsy ball that hit Martin but a Kuroda fast ball. Victorino had every right to speak up. They had 3 opportunities to nail Myers in the last game and instead they gave up three hits. This is the NL not the AL where if you want to respond to a message, reply to the people responsible in the 1st place.
Bingo.
That's the take-away point for tonight's game.
Myers is a good pitcher who uses intimidation as a part of his repertoire. He got a free pass.
Blanton is a so-so pitcher who uses intimidation to compensate for his other issues.
The onus is on the Phillies to knock it off.
Do we get James Loney tonight?
An under the radar Danny Heep reference!
That's funny. My father, with his infinite hatred for all things Boston, wondered aloud why in the Florida where there are goons aplenty, aren't the Red Sox getting beat up at their hotels. I think he was serious too.
apparently, I also left out "celebrating a strikeout down 5 runs in the 8th inning". Shades of Bill Gramatica...
It's amazing that he's able to go out by himself and be such a functioning part of society. :)
If a Dodger gets hit, he should be happy about it because he gets to go down to 1st base. He doesnt make an out. Thats a good AB.
Meanwhile, it doesnt make much sense IMO to have the Dodger pitcher hit guys & put the other team on base.
I also dont think any batter should make a fuss about being hit, or being nearly hit. Baseball pitchers have the right to throw any pitch in any direction. Thats what batters helmets are for.
The Phillies have fewer Hollywood celebrity fans, although it would be interesting to see if the two most notable Phillies fans: Ben Bernanke and Samuel Alito would show up on the video board.
But both guys are a bit busy now.
You're right, the robots on the field should only strive to achieve the prime directive.
I went to grade school with a Brian Baumgartner...To whom do you refer...?
* The Phillies didn't relaize the Dodgers secret weapon last night: My wife and I in the stands! We are now 10-0 in games we have attended this year alone. We are just 2-3 when going with friends and/or groups. Just the two of us went last night running our record to 10-0. We can't make it tonight, hopefully Lowe and company can do it without us! We are trying to get tickets for Wednesday thinking the Dodgers will need all the help they can get against Hamels and Co. on Wednesday.
See 96
The Phillies's starting pitching really is remarkably bad outside of Hamels, especially for a team that won 92 games and finished in first place.
Oh. He doesn't appear to be "my" Brian Baumgartner.
>>I feel bad for Chad Billingsley. He is a great kid and a great pitcher who has been caught in the middle of something that frankly isn't his fault, and for some reason, Fox kept showing tight shots of him in the Dodgers' dugout tonight during a game he wasn't even involved in other than as a supportive teammate. Yes, he should have retaliated in Game 2 for what happened to Martin and Manny. But no, he didn't commit some sort of affront to all that is sacred about this grand, old game. This stuff appears to be over now, and this series appears to be shaping up as one for the ages.<<
Because the home team won each of the first 3 games, in non-dramatic fashion...? Sheesh. Someone's easily excited.
Right on, pardner. Jeff Kent takes more punishment washing his truck.
It's nothing a strong 7 innings Wednesday can't cure.
Please don't have Mary Hart read the Dodgers line-up ever again.
Sincerely,
All Dodger Fans outside of the Hart fanily
Shades of K-Rod (5 postseason wins in 2002).
Did Mary have a hard time delivering the lineup? I didn't see it.
She probably should have dropped a Troy from WV reference; that's comedy gold.
107 - oo good one, my turn:
"The Dodgers' offense really is remarkably bad outside of Manny, especially for a team that won 84 games and finished in first place."
Also, tonight, how many innings does Lowe have to go before we can start speculating about starting Kershaw over Billz in Game 5?
Bravo! Well played.
I have no intention of defending the Dodgers, but this doesn't really compute. LA had the 15th best record in the MLB, and (arguably) the best pitching staff. Why would anyone expect, then, that their offense would be good?
One wouldn't. One would almost inevitably conclude that their offense must have been pretty bad, which, in fact, it was.
I don't think anyone's that foolish.
Chip Caray would be very disappointed in the Dodgers team OPS with two outs.
I hate disappointing Chip Caray.
I took issue with how the Sportscenter guys (I know, what a surprise) made light of Manny's enthusiastic response - after all, he had a ball thrown behind him in game 2, it seems to me he had reason to be steamed. Thank God that someone was there to hold him back, though.
Btw, I've been moving and internet-less the past few days (and living without Dodger Thoughts during the NLCS is a terrible, terrible ordeal), but I can't stand how Tim McCarver calls out Manny for being despicable, but says not a word about Brett Myers, who is a scum bag of the highest order.
So, did anyone notice the Reserve Level section right behind home plate? It was practically empty all night. Was it reserved for the extra press? The few people sitting there seemed to be dressed more formally than the rest of the crowd.
The only thing I can think of is that it's a timing mechanism.
Section 5 is the auxiliary press box.
And why is all the focus on Billz and not the relievers who followed him.
What's Torre's history on beanball wars from NY days? Maybe he thinks his team should be the bigger men until the provocation becomes extreme, as it did last night.
At that point, I think the fastball aimed near Victorino's head was perfect. He got out of the way, but it scared him and probably scared his manager. Plus it got the umpires involved.
I think it could be a turning point, emotionally. I hope they've taken the measure of Joe Blanton. They can't let that guy ever get comfortable.
148. seesdifferent
remarkably bad offense as of July: with the remarkably helpless Andruw Jones and without Manny and Raffy.... no leadoff man, no cleanup hitter, while featuring a record breaking whiff machine who wasn't hitting within 50 points of his weight. So what does that July offense have to do with the October offense? Hmmm.
...But until the Dodgers sent a Phillie spinning to the dirt, nothing was going to stop Philadelphia from continuing to make the Dodgers duck and cover.
[with emphasis] I am not endorsing hitting people with pitches. I am not endorsing throwing at someone's head.
I'm not TRYING to be fastidious here, but that does sound like a bold contradiction.
You desire a certain outcome (peace), and rationalize the means of achieving it (retaliatory bean ball), then reject it (bean balls) in principle.
Since there is a big difference between actually beaning a batter, and buzzing a batter, your phrase "spinning in the dirt" leaves your meaning vague, (perhaps intentionally) as McCarver did by employing the term "buzzing", out of a desire to not appear uncivilized, yet tacitly actually approving of the bean ball.
Are you, or are you not, in favor of beaning a batter under certain circumstances?
Either way is fine by me. But it's confusing as a reader to try and make sense of an approval, then a denial of that approval in the very next sentence. It's as if you want to have it both ways.
Like, "Hey, I told him don't do anything foolish this game is too important." Even if you didn't say that it takes heat of Billingsley in the media and clubhouse. There's a way to protect your game 5 starter from any of that crap.
I didn't watch it. Was it really an incredible game, or do you just mean you're happy the Dodgers won?
I had an absolutely incredible time at the game with great company abound. It is sort of fun watching such an event as a bullpen clearing, though I doubt its worth the aftermath of backwash useless commentary.
Blake DeWitt made Picture of the Game on the livejournal community I made, not Victorino. What a fun inning.
The first reflects my personal preference. the second reflects my interpretation of reality.
I'm hoping none of this is part of tonight's game.
When you keep score, do you enter the official scoring or your own interpretation?
Bob scores based on what he thinks should have happened. For instance, Jack Clark never hit a home run in the '85 NLCS.
I believe that Billz is fine with his teammates. I think it's just another storyline for the media. The best thing Torre could do, and maybe he already did, is to take Manny and maybe some of the other "vets" asside and explain the game 2 situation to them. Explain it wasn't Billz fault, he wasn't in a position to retaliate and that he was instructed not to retaliate at that moment. Deflect any blame from Billz to Torre whether Torre ever said anything to Billz or not.
An infinite series of CIs...?
The first inning had enough intrigue to fill out any journalists card. The fact it was a successful Dodger 1st inning certainly made it an incredible game. Blake DeWitt besting a man twice his age in the postseason. How often has that happened? The game was still in doubt when Wade came in and did what he's done all year long. A three run jack and the pressure starts to tighten.
The Dodgers have now gotten solid performances from four players who had never played in a major league game until this year. Usually these players will have smelled the coffee in Sept callups but Wade and DeWitt were so far removed from the idea of helping in 2008 they were ignored. McDonald and Kershaw were shut down for pitch count reasons. This is unusual. Very unusual for postseason play.
Maybe they've had good game plans to open the game, but then fall away from them as the game progresses...?
Manny batting 3rd might have something to do with it, but that is just a wild guess. No one wants to walk the dangerous hitter in the 1st inning unless forced to because of an open base.
Joe Blanton will walk Manny tonight.
Come now, optimism for the future while playing in the NLCS! Those who can only deal in negatives will not want to hear such possibilities. If their mental makeup does not allow them to enjoy the current postseason they will instead focus on what the team will look like in 2009 based on mass free agent exodus.
Bhsportsguy was the 1st to point all this out. I'm strictly a repeater of useful information.
Thought I'd never get the chance to go this postseason, but the planets aligned for me.
Looking forward to the win...
I reflect the official scoring of the game.
I'll be in Reserved 1 tonight as opposed to Loge 166 last night, so watching plays develop will be a lot easier.
Sadly, I will miss all my friends in the Algonquin Round Table that are in that part of the stands. I play the part of George S. Kaufman.
I started off 0-2 after World Series losses in 1977 and 1978. Then after 1981, I was 2-3. Then there were losses in 1995 and 1996.
I reflect the official scoring of the game
Even when you object? (Nay, strenuously object?)
As for throwing at players, I have no real problem with it one way or the other. Some people have already pointed out the strategic aspect of it, with which I agree-- that is, it's a way to get the other team to stop throwing pitches so far inside on your guys. What I was desperately afraid of was Manny going out there and getting suspended. Ugh.
Very exciting stuff, this series.
"Restaurant 15, located near Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles, plans to shut later this month. Open for about a year, the restaurant has seen its revenue on weekend nights cut in half since June, says Alex Eusebio, the executive chef and part owner. He has laid off more than half his wait staff in the last month."
Dear Blake DeWitt,
Thank you.
Restaurant goes out of business! Film at 11!
Repeat each day.
Having a successful restaurant in any economic climate is extremely difficult. When I worked in the Business Department and people would come in looking for help writing a business plan for a restaurant, I often thought to myself "When are they going to come back for the bankruptcy books?"
What a contrast to the NLDS clincher. I know that there were many reports of an ugly crowd there, but as I posted here, from my vantage point the crowd at that game was joyful and was rewarded with a well-played, exciting contest that (fortunately) the Dodgers led all the way. Others didn't have this experience, but it was one of the best games for me that I'd ever attended.
Still, because so many people had such a different experience than I had, I was wary of the crowd but hopeful that things would be OK.
Things were not OK. I don't know if it was the fact that the Dodgers were down 0-2 in the series, or that in the first inning, the team took an (as it turned out) insurmountable lead, or that there was weird violence on the field, but this crowd was ugly.
From the very beginning of the game, the one Phillie fan in our section -- Loge, near the right-field foul pole -- took it. At first, he was cheery about it, tipping his cap to the crowd with a big grin. But as the game went on, the verbal abuse got worse and worse. Threats to smack him down in the parking lot. One 90-pound woman screamed, "Get outta here! We don't want your kind here!" (Yes, "your kind.") Things were thrown -- peanuts, I think.
You could see the Phillie fan struggling to maintain his temper. Fortunately, there was no fight.
And the only thing I could think the whole time was: where were the ushers?
Frank McCourt keeps touting Dodger Stadium as a premier family destination in Los Angeles. The crowd was so surly last night that it kinda puts the lie to that.
I'll put it this way: the crowd rivalled the legendary crowds of $2 Tuesdays from a few years back (was it 2005?). It got to the point then that I refused to attend Tuesday games until the promotion ended, and it was such a disaster that it ended quickly. Last night didn't have anybody running onto the field, so it wasn't QUITE as bad as $2 Tuesdays, but it certainly wasn't the joyful buzz I was expecting of an NLCS game and it was bad enough that I now think that my NLDS experience was a fluke and that this is more representative of the stuff that goes on.
I support McCourt's attempts to put the Dodgers front-and-center in LA by making Dodger Stadium the destination, but for all the money he's poured into seats, food, and parking, I wonder if he has a plan to reshape the in-seat fan experience. One place to start might be more ushers, trained in crowd control, watching the crowd and quick to step in to defuse tensions. But I'm not an expert and if McCourt has another plan, that's fine.
All of these Dodger Stadium games should be must wins.
Interesting. Assuming a home team wins roughly 55.68% of the games (as they did in 2008), we'd only expect the team down 3-2 to win both remaining games roughly 31% of the time.
TB: 70.4%
Bos: 69.1
Cubs: 67.9
ChiSox: 67.5
Angels: 61.7
Mil: 60.5
Phi/LA: 59.3
But even the Rays would only be expected to win the remaining 2 games 49.5% of the time.
But the other big issue is that the team who at home for games 6 and 7 had the better season record, at least outside the World Series.
Also, has everybody noticed what happens when you click on those 0 links? Is it just a way of getting extra pinky-typing practicing?
But then, would would attend the parking lot?
Oh, right: Frank McCourt.
In 1965 we lost the first 2 games of the WS in Minnesota; came home and took all 3; went back to Minnesota and lost game 6 and then won game 7 (on the 14th of October).
Of course, having Koufax pitch a shutout in game 5 and come back and pitch another one on two days rest in game 7 was a big help.
To the game, I agree with Jon that Victorino has no right to be upset or complain about a thing. In fact when the moment happened I stood in my chair, watched and thought now why is he so mad? I do however think that a "retaliation" was in order whether it be a hard slide into a base or very inside pitch. Quotes from Manny express frustration that it did not incur in Philly. I gave Myers the benefit of doubt that night. Gave Moyer the benefit for the first one but seriously at Martin's head? Now it was in order and I think Kuroda made a large statement, I think the entire Dodger team made a whole statement from the first inning, Furcal swinging at the first pitch and smashing a homerun? Furcal nevers swings at the first pitch but he was already decided. Manny rushing from the outfield after the inning was over, Plaschke was right that towards the end he was "playing" it up but he should and the team should have. They needed to get angry, they needed some fire, not because it was entirely lost but because to turn this series around, this game and incidents that ensued may be just what the doctor ordered. I want to go as far and say this could be turning point in the series. The Phillies seemed bullied after that Victorino groundout, like a bully having just been stood up to. They looked clueless and just plain beat. finally I loved seeing Dewitt step up and become a major leaguer, not that he wasn't but big hit, big pressure, first postseason, I see nothing but good things coming from him. Kuroda was the last piece of greatness last night, he showed flashes of greatness throughout the season but he has stepped up when its counted and I have every faith Mr. Lowe will do so again tonight. This is playoff time and not time to rest our seasoned vet ace.
I've rarely seen bad behavior from a known season ticket holder. This isn't a class or economic observation as the seats in my area are owned by the same ethnic and economic distribution as the people who buy the game day tickets.
California Dreaming last night even made my wife proud to life in LA and she's wanted to move for 20 years. Stopped into a church and showing Dodger Stadium. Good stuff.
I seem to remembering seeing that the chef at Restaurant 15 is going to be on Top Chef this season.
"Five Days in August" (or whatever Bissinger's book was called) has in its index the heading of
"Drew, J.D.,
Underachivement of.."
They were out for blood.
I hope all their dreams in life have gone unfulfilled.
This has been a problem for almost a decade now. I think the best thing we can do is write a letter to the Dodgers, a paper letter, at least to express what is happening and the frustration therin.
You'd hate for games to be ruined by lousy fans. The second thing is, why all the hate for people who wear the other teams' colors? I don't get that at all! So what, they root for the other team. It's just a game.
188 Clearly, and it is my observation--if not others--that a somewhat long hibernating Raider element and mentality has some found its way to Chavez Ravine.
We cannot kid ourselves; this is a group that is more akin to being that of a soccer-hooligan found in London or Brazil; whose lack of knowledge about the beauty and strategy of the Game does not compare to a ill-conceived racial insult. These types of fans like upheaval because they have a lot of anger in their lives. These types just want to see a fight when others want to escape all of that nonsense. Home plate is nothing more then a battle ground of contempt, anger and deceit. Sometimes even revenge.
Some of you longtime Jon's Dodger Thoughts readers will remember sometime back when Jon posted that letter from the brother of the Giant fan who was ruthlessly killed at Dodger Stadium after just another heated Dodgers/Giants contest. I still think of that kid from time to time--alls he wanted to do was watch a great baseball game between two teams with one of the more storied rivalries in all of sports. His brother described in that letter, just how much he loved baseball and despite him being a Giant fan I cannot think of a better type person to watch a baseball game with.
My best friend is a life-long Angel fan who detests the Dodgers; and I'm not that much different about the Angels either. Still, I would rather go enjoy a game with him then anyone because we love the game and its an even better way to enjoy our friendship. We have different likes and dislikes, but one thing we share is our love for baseball.
You just wish some of this rabid element at Dodger Stadium could be the same...Before someone else gets hurt.
And UCLA is usually getting throttled in that game.
Then there are Notre Dame fans. The fans there are freakishly polite to out of towners. Except to Michigan fans. They hate them.
My uncle's second wife's son (which would make us step-cousins, I suppose) is building a hotel/restaurant in Buenos Aires. The zero order goal should always be thrift; second should be location; third should be the actual running of the thing. He's building the thing himself and it's costing him a fortune. I wonder that he will ever see a profit on it.
Was that the "rubber ball to the neck" incident...?
If our Phillie fan had been seated in the bleachers, it would have been a zoo of insults and thrown items, and then, even if the Phillie fan did nothing but sit pleasantly, the cops would have removed him and not the unruly Yankee fans. (She doesn't know if he would have been moved to another section or removed from the stadium entirely.)
I don't know if that's a good solution. It keeps the guy from getting assaulted, but rewards the fans for bad behavior.
At Game 1 in Philly, Fox had Harry Kalas read the starting lineup.
The guy in second is Harry McIntire, who managed to hit 82 guys in just five seasons in Brooklyn from 1905-1909.
Of active Dodger pitchers, Chan Ho Park leads in HBPs as a Dodger with 74, which is fourth alltime and one ahead of Nap Rucker.
Burt Hooton pitched 10 seasons for the Dodgers and hit 12 guys.
The rubber ball to the neck was a Dodgers-Braves game at the start of the 2005 season.
The guy I saw at the NLDS clincher who was gently and good-naturedly teasing the Cubs fans isn't necessarily worried about his capital gains taxes, but he had class.
Can we take that out of the equation, please?
They talked about Vin and showed him on TV and even did a little graphic on his career.
It's a hard hard business with tiny margins on food; you've got to make it up on liquor. If you don't sell booze, that obviously makes it even harder. And you're subject to the real estate mantra: "Location, location, location."
I'm usually more worried about the AMT.
Sounds like you've had multiple "incidents".
The only one I've ever had remains the "(Presumably) Giants fans dumping beer on my dad and I at Candlestick back in 1983 for (presumably) being outwardly pro-Dodger".
Dodger Stadium incidents for me:
Guy spilling beer on me in 1981 NLCS and other person laughing at me whole game.
Sitting next to jerky Cardinal fans in 2005.
Same reason NBC/ABC wouldn't have Chick Hearn calling Laker games in the playoffs, viewers would have been given a treat, but it would degrade their announcers.
Which is strange to me, because we're talking about icons, as opposed so say, Sutton and Grace.
That's my only incident.
http://tinyurl.com/4sl2th
Are you planning on recreating scenes from "The Naked Gun?"
Never heard of it before. I will say that several weeks ago near the foul pole an older heavy lady in the first row was showing some erratic behavior or such and those guys you see walking out to the outfield and doing their best secret service imitations pulled her over the rail and took her down. Within seconds she was handcuffed and escorted out the bullpen gate. If you blinked you missed the whole thing.
I'm guessing they misinterpreted her intentions as she was in the same seat the next game I attended but the speed in which they acted was quite unlike the snail like movement of the LAPD who handle the security in the stands.
At the moment far far away. Griffith Park would have to burn down for there to be any effect on tonights game.
But, I will say that nothing I've seen at DS -- not even being in the left field pavillion when Barry Bonds was playing -- compares to a summer day in the bleachers at Fenway when the Yankees are in town. It's been many years since I had that experience, but it was one long drunken brawl. Guys were getting tossed by the dozen, dragged out by a legion of guards and ushers. It was the wildest thing I ever saw outside of the mosh pit when the Dead Kennedys were playing (which I observed from a safe distance, unlike my experience at Fenway).
Ethier, RF
Manny, LF
Martin, C
Loney, 1B
DeWitt, 2B
Blake, 3B
Pierre, CF
Lowe, P
Surprised considering Kemp got a couple of hits last night that Joe would go with JP. However saying that glad he is batting 8th.
Ethier, RF
Manny, LF
Martin, C
Loney, 1B
DeWitt, 2B
Blake, 3B
Pierre, CF
Lowe, P
Pitchfork? Check. Torch? Check. Keyboard? Check.
Great write-up, and picture, Jon. I got back last night still jacked with adrenaline and your piece was just what the doctor ordered.
We have one ticket available for tonight - Loge section 165, Row R, for 81.30. njr, myself, and a friend will be rabidly cheering next to you. Tix are computer print-outs, alas, but guaranteed good times.
Also, 104 we have 2 tix for Wed., Loge 162, Row F, seats 13-14, 162.60 total.
If anyone's interested, you can e-mail me at tinker @ tinkerlindsay dot com , or njr at
thomasbeatty @ gmail dot com
238 No scalping for us!
Last night's game was great. Watching all the pitchers lumbering across the field to back up their boys was somehow hilarious and totally exciting at the same time, and Blake Dewitt's triple was a pure, peak baseball experience.
go dodgers.
Kemp must not have thrown enough punches last night.
Does Pierre own Blanton or something?
I mean, I'm sitting here in my pajamas, making $19,000 a year, and I can look it up in a few seconds.
Not that outhitting RH necessarily means that Kemp should start over Pierre vs. a RH, but I doubt Pierre would be starting if the opposing pitcher were an LH.
If by "own" you mean "has never faced in his life".
He's a tabula rasa.
http://www.bb-ref.com/pi/shareit/Mafm
The home team of game 3, trailing 0-2, Series wins: 3-21, 12.5%
The home team of game 4, trailing 1-2, Series wins: 19-35, 35.2%.
According to:
http://www.whowins.com/tables/up21.html
Juan Pierre?
Its the playoffs.
Every player is trying their hardest.
There's no good reason to start Pierre over Kemp in the regular season, let alone the playoffs.
If Joe would start Pierre in the biggest game of the season, I have to think 2009 he could do the same thing.
But you know all that.
Pierre may just have his head in a better place right now and he will certainly be motivated
Hey, I wish Pierre was in, um, "a better place."
Thank you! I'll be here all week!
Theories?
I don't agree with the decision but it's not the end of the world.
And where does Midas fit in?
279- Kemp may have stolen Torre's dentures while he was napping, then used them to clamp on to an ceiling fan. The whole thing may have ended in busting up the dentures (and, presumably, permanently marring the fan). But, I'm just guessing, I don't have any hard evidence.
Except Torre's statement might be grammatical.
For those of you who love to look toward 2009 while we are still playing, nothing would help 2009 right now then to have Juan Pierre do some serious S & S work to make him tradeable while also helping us win a game.
If Lowe can go 5 solid innings again, I would have him on a very short leash with guys like Kershaw in the pen.
I know it's sorta bad form and all, but that really made me laugh.
Happily, I will be out (planning a Pinewood Derby!) for much of the game.
I started looking for these numbers after I posted and I can't seem to find anything. Let's hope we win two in a row so I can get easily accessed numbers ;-)
----------------------
He was ignored most of the year.
Dirt, sweat, and speed replaced by Glamour, power, and pouting.
Last night he reminded those of us who remember what baseball looks like.
It's wasn't OBP, or OPS, or VORP. It was high socks, oversized helmets, and headfirst passion.
With every slap, dash, and cloud of dust, he brought an ungrateful fan base closer to a 20 year dream.
---------------------
Feel free to take it from there....
We need more angst for 300 to work. This settling is not going to cut it.
Nice, lets hope that proves prophetic.
I hate it when someone spills angst all over my keyboard.
Are you the real Bill Plaschke?
It probably doesn't if you have been doing it all of your career during the era he played.
Yes, you are the king. Why Magic Marlon would have been Ordinary Anderson if you hadn't pointed out what a senseless trade it was.
When the team traded for Mannny Ramirez, he took more batting practice
When Andre Ethier had his month-long moment, he ran sprints in the outfield.
When Matt Kemp started slumping, he was ready.
319 young = younger
320
Funny, really funny :)
Haren - didn't work
Harden - didn't work
Blanton - ??
If the Dodgers win tonight, we can conclude that Moneyball is a farce. No Moneyball team has successfully scattered its young pitchers around the league for the purpose of derailing the Dodgers in the pennant race/post-season.
So go get 'em, Scrappy McPopup!
Will it be hard to root against our lil' darlins?
"But to make sure Victorino understood him, moments later Kuroda ran over to first base while Victorino was grounding out to first baseman Ryan Howard."
Hmm, I didn't realize we had acquired Ryan Howard.
Gawd! Plashke is horrible.
And height.
And sitting out in the sun a lot.
I like that angle.
So, to me, pitch selection is not the answer to why Billingsley was bad Friday.
More angst! We need more angst! The future I saw is not the future that must occur!
Did the LA Times turn to the JC's for their editors?
The replay showed Kuroda saying something to Victorino, and I think Shane was surprised to see him over there.
You're welcome.
Which GM is going to decide Pierre's worth trading for due to 1 post season game?
On 2nd thought, its Sabean so anything is possible.
http://www.beloblog.com/Pe_Blogs/prosports/2008/10/nlcs-torres-take-on-pierre-ove.html
Pretty much what was expected. I don't mind Torre's reasoning.
"In this series Kemp is hitting .273 with a double and two walks".
But I'm a contrarian around here on that point. The Rays served their purpose in keeping the Yankees out of the playoffs - the rest of the AL is on notice for allowing the Red Sox in.
So, the double switch in the 6th or 7th?
http://www.latimes.com/sports/la-sp-fines14-2008oct14,0,219393.story
$500 from Ken Rosenthal?
I wonder if ownership ever offers to pay individual fines when the behavior that inspired the fine was encouraged/mandated by management (either directly, or indirectly through some kind of unspoken "that's how we do things around here" milieu).
Cuban Tourny style baseball.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.