Baseball Toaster Dodger Thoughts
Log in | Register | Help
Jon Weisman's outlet
for dealing psychologically
with the Los Angeles Dodgers
and baseball.
Hot from the Toaster
BlogAds
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Dodger Thoughts
Archives

2008
09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
09  08  07 
About Jon
Support Dodger Thoughts

Dodger Thoughts T-Shirts
On sale through February 16, 2008
DT Blue on WhiteDT-WhiteonBLue
Click here to order.

* * *

Cover 11.25 jpeg

The Best of Dodger Thoughts
A 325-page book featuring the top selections from this website from 2002-2005.

Click here for more information.

On Sale Now at Lulu.com

Support independent publishing: buy this book on Lulu.

* * *

Or, just make a donation to support the site. Many thanks.

"Dodger Thoughts, like TiVo, is one of those things you can completely do without until you start using it."

- Fanerman

Dodger Sites
Dodger Resources
Non-Partisan Baseball Sites
Partisan Baseball Sites
Baseball, Among Other Things
Invaluable Resources
Less Dodgers, More L.A.
All in the Family
Other Writing by Jon on the Web

SI.com
NL West Preview
Evaluating Defense
Colletti and Depo
World Baseball Classic
Minor League Broadcasters
Slow Starts
Eric Gagne
Groundball Pitchers
Dodger Prospects
Albert Pujols
Humbled Angels
You Be the Manager
Eric Gagne II
Unreliable Relievers
Revived Angels
It's Okay To Sell
Dodger Turnaround
Andre Ethier
Padres-Dodgers Showdown
NL Final Weekend
Mets-Dodgers NLDS
Postseason ratings
NL Wish Lists
Manny vs. J.D.
McGwire Controversy
Dodger Offense
Trainers Matter

Variety
Will Arnett
John C. McGinley
Laura Dern
Imelda Staunton
SAG Awards
Ellen Pompeo
Grey's Anatomy
2004-05 Rookie Dramas
Anthony Hopkins
NATPE
Scrubs
Award Shows
Topher Grace
Ashton Kutcher
Writing on Improv Shows
Rainn Wilson
T.R. Knight
Guest Actors
Animation Guests
Joey Carson and Tennis
Donald Trump and Golf
2006 Emmys Nominees*
*Comedy Series
*Comedy Director
*Comedy Writer
*Comedy Actor
*Comedy Supporting Actor
Blue's Clues
Lizzy Caplan
Ann Donahue
CMT: Giants
CMA Awards
Little Miss Sunshine
Actor-Directors
Freshman Series
Clint Eastwood
Showrunners vs. Censors
Little Children
Breaking and Entering
Tartikoff Legacy Awards
Jackie Earle Haley
Knights of Prosperity
Office Online
2007 Screenplay Noms
Friday Night Lights
Robert Benton
ABC Fridays
Rookie Actors
Global Casting
2007 Pilot Casting
Sublime Slime

Also ...
A Season in Savannah (Stanford Magazine)
Five Questions: Los Angeles Dodgers (2005) (Hardball Times)
Rick Monday (Baseball Analysts)
Baseball's Odd Couple (Baseball Prospectus)
Five Questions: Los Angeles Dodgers (2006) (Hardball Times)
Five Questions: Los Angeles Dodgers (2007) (Hardball Times)

More Shameless Self-Promotion
2008 Season

Dodger home record: 40-30 (.571)
When Jon attended: 6-3 (.667)
When Jon didn't: 34-27 (.557)

1991-2007

Dodgers at home: 745-600 (.554)
Jon attended: 293-233 (.557)*
Jon didn't: 457-374 (.550)
* includes road games attended

2008 Payroll Worksheet

Current Roster with Estimated 2008 Salaries
(updated March 28)

Most figures are estimates (some are wild estimates) but will be updated as information comes in. Corrections welcome.

More contract details here.

Starting Pitchers (5)
$12,300,000 Hiroki Kuroda
$10,000,000 Derek Lowe
$9,500,000 Brad Penny
$7,000,000 Esteban Loaiza
*$500,000 Chad Billingsley
Total: $39,300,000

Bullpen (6)
$2,000,000 Takashi Saito
$1,925,000 Joe Beimel
$1,125,000 Scott Proctor
*$500,000 Jonathan Broxton
$500,000 Chan Ho Park
*$400,000 Hong-Chih Kuo
Total: $6,450,000

Starting Lineup (8)
$14,100,000 Andruw Jones
$13,000,000 Rafael Furcal
$9,000,000 Jeff Kent
$8,500,000 Nomar Garciaparra
$8,000,000 Juan Pierre
$500,000 Russell Martin
*$400,000 James Loney
*$400,000 Matt Kemp
Total: $53,900,000

Bench (6)
$875,000 Gary Bennett
$600,000 Mark Sweeney
$424,500 Andre Ethier
$391,000 Delwyn Young
$390,000 Chin-Lung Hu
$390,000 Blake DeWitt
Total: $3,071,000

Disabled List
$12,000,000 Jason Schmidt
*$400,000 Tony Abreu
*$390,000 Andy LaRoche
Total: $12,790,000

Also Paying ...
$1,000,000 Brett Tomko
$750,000 Odalis Perez
$540,000 Yhency Brazoban
$500,000 Randy Wolf
$487,500 Jason Repko
$135,225 Rudy Seanez
$100,000 Mike Lieberthal
$50,000 Ramon Martinez
Total: $3,562,725

Working total: *$113,268,725

*Rough salary estimate

The 2008 Dodgers

ESPN BR BP Cube Alvarez
ESPN BR BP Cube Abreu
ESPN BR BP Cube Beimel
ESPN BR BP Cube Bennett
ESPN BR BP Cube Billingsley
ESPN BR BP Cube Brazoban
ESPN BR BP Cube Broxton
ESPN BR BP Cube DeWitt
ESPN BR BP Cube Ethier
ESPN BR BP Cube Furcal
ESPN BR BP Cube Garciaparra
ESPN BR BP Cube Hu
ESPN BR BP Cube Jones
ESPN BR BP Cube Kemp
ESPN BR BP Cube Kent
ESPN BR BP Cube Kuo
ESPN BR BP Cube Kuroda
ESPN BR BP Cube LaRoche
ESPN BR BP Cube Loaiza
ESPN BR BP Cube Loney
ESPN BR BP Cube Lowe
ESPN BR BP Cube Martin
ESPN BR BP Cube May
ESPN BR BP Cube McDonald
ESPN BR BP Cube Meloan
ESPN BR BP Cube Miller
ESPN BR BP Cube Orenduff
ESPN BR BP Cube Park
ESPN BR BP Cube Paul
ESPN BR BP Cube Penny
ESPN BR BP Cube Pierre
ESPN BR BP Cube Proctor
ESPN BR BP Cube Repko
ESPN BR BP Cube Saito
ESPN BR BP Cube Schmidt
ESPN BR BP Cube Stults
ESPN BR BP Cube Sweeney
ESPN BR BP Cube Troncoso
ESPN BR BP Cube Wade
ESPN BR BP Cube Young

Selected Recent Ex-Dodgers

ESPN BR BP Cube Alomar
ESPN BR BP Cube Alvarez
ESPN BR BP Cube Aybar
ESPN BR BP Cube Baez
ESPN BR BP Cube Bako
ESPN BR BP Cube Beltre
ESPN BR BP Cube Bradley
ESPN BR BP Cube Cabrera
ESPN BR BP Cube Carrara
ESPN BR BP Cube Carter
ESPN BR BP Cube Chen
ESPN BR BP Cube Choi
ESPN BR BP Cube Cora
ESPN BR BP Cube Crosby
ESPN BR BP Cube Cruz
ESPN BR BP Cube Dessens
ESPN BR BP Cube Dreifort
ESPN BR BP Cube Drew
ESPN BR BP Cube Encarnacion
ESPN BR BP Cube Edwards
ESPN BR BP Cube Erickson
ESPN BR BP Cube Falkenborg
ESPN BR BP Cube Finley
ESPN BR BP Cube Flores
ESPN BR BP Cube Gagne
ESPN BR BP Cube Grabowski
ESPN BR BP Cube Green
ESPN BR BP Cube Guzman
ESPN BR BP Cube Hanrahan
ESPN BR BP Cube Hernandez
ESPN BR BP Cube Hundley
ESPN BR BP Cube Ishii
ESPN BR BP Cube Izturis
ESPN BR BP Cube Jackson
ESPN BR BP Cube Karros
ESPN BR BP Cube Ketchner
ESPN BR BP Cube Ledee
ESPN BR BP Cube Lima
ESPN BR BP Cube Lo Duca
ESPN BR BP Cube Lofton
ESPN BR BP Cube T. Martin
ESPN BR BP Cube Mayne
ESPN BR BP Cube G. Mota
ESPN BR BP Cube Mueller
ESPN BR BP Cube Myrow
ESPN BR BP Cube Nakamura
ESPN BR BP Cube Navarro
ESPN BR BP Cube Nomo
ESPN BR BP Cube Osoria
ESPN BR BP Cube A. Perez
ESPN BR BP Cube O. Perez
ESPN BR BP Cube Phillips
ESPN BR BP Cube Proctor
ESPN BR BP Cube Roberts
ESPN BR BP Cube Robles
ESPN BR BP Cube Romano
ESPN BR BP Cube C. Ross
ESPN BR BP Cube D. Ross
ESPN BR BP Cube Sanchez
ESPN BR BP Cube Schmoll
ESPN BR BP Cube Sele
ESPN BR BP Cube Seo
ESPN BR BP Cube Shuey
ESPN BR BP Cube Stanley
ESPN BR BP Cube S. Stewart
ESPN BR BP Cube Thompson
ESPN BR BP Cube Thurston
ESPN BR BP Cube Valentin
ESPN BR BP Cube Venafro
ESPN BR BP Cube Ventura
ESPN BR BP Cube Weaver
ESPN BR BP Cube Werth
ESPN BR BP Cube Wilson
ESPN BR BP Cube Wunsch

Dodger Thoughts Land
Thank You For Not ...

1) using profanity or any euphemisms for profanity
2) personally attacking other commenters
3) baiting other commenters
4) arguing for the sake of arguing
5) discussing politics
6) using hyperbole when something less will suffice
7) using sarcasm in a way that can be misinterpreted negatively
8) making the same point over and over again
9) typing "no-hitter" or "perfect game" to describe either in progress
10) being annoyed by the existence of this list
11) commenting under the obvious influence
12) claiming your opinion isn't allowed when it's just being disagreed with

Syndication

rss2.0

Add to My Yahoo!
Bennett To Back Up Martin
2007-12-17 13:19
by Jon Weisman

Backup catcher Gary Bennett has signed a one-year deal with the Dodgers, the team announced today. You may have seen his name in the news recently, but my memory of him will always be this: "Jordan knocks Bennett into Chinatown."

Advertisement
Comments (159)
Show/Hide Comments 1-50
2007-12-17 13:24:12
1.   natepurcell
Our team is tainted again!
2007-12-17 13:26:22
2.   Humma Kavula
What's the over/under on Gary Bennett starts? 20?
2007-12-17 13:26:32
3.   Eric Stephen
That was the hardest I've ever seen a catcher hit, surpassing J.Clark/Scioscia and Erstad/Estrada.
2007-12-17 13:26:36
4.   hernari
Is this guy a glutton for punishment or what?

http://tinyurl.com/2fj8br

2007-12-17 13:27:47
5.   D4P
Bennett's career 64 OPS+ was HGH-aided.
2007-12-17 13:27:56
6.   Eric Enders
Ugh. Gary Bennett has always been one of those players I just can't stand and I can't explain why. He's just always seemed like a jerk, although if I have actual concrete reasons for thinking that they've faded into oblivion.

Well, I guess the Dodgers will still be able to claim they had nobody named in the Mitchell report at the time the report actually came out.

2007-12-17 13:29:06
7.   Humma Kavula
5 At the risk of violating rule 8...

It doesn't really matter what Bennett used to get whatever his terrible OPS+ is. He'll never play.

2007-12-17 13:29:17
8.   Eric Stephen
Keith Law on Kuroda: fringy stuff guy, should benefit from being in the NL and Dodger Stadium (a slight pitchers park), and a slight upgrade over Esteban Loaiza as the 5th starter.

I don't think the ESPNews host knew his subject as he asked Law, "Kuroda's not the Dodgers' #1, is he?" Why can't Brian Kenny be on ESPNews 24/7?

2007-12-17 13:30:34
9.   Eric Enders
If this was the alternative, then why the heck didn't we exercise the Lieberthal option? Who really cares if we would have been overpaying him? What's another $600,000?

Ned's first misstep of the offseason. It may not seem like much, but he's probably sentenced Martin to another year of overwork.

2007-12-17 13:32:09
10.   Eric Stephen
2 20 is a good number (non-Russ got 19 starts in 2007). I might go just a tad higher (25?) thinking Russ might get an occasional extra day off.
2007-12-17 13:32:13
11.   trainwreck
Makes no sense when McCourt keeps bragging about how no current Dodgers were in the Mitchell Report.

It just goes to show how useless that report was for actual baseball. A completely media driven story.

2007-12-17 13:34:19
12.   natepurcell
8

Maybe Keith Law can find Kuroda's groundball rates.

2007-12-17 13:35:28
13.   Eric Stephen
Nice to see we were complaining about the Dodger 3rd base coach as far back as 2003. Some things never change.

Let's hope Larry Bowa doesn't uphold this tradition.

2007-12-17 13:35:34
14.   Jon Weisman
3 - Parker-Yeager. No. 1.
2007-12-17 13:35:49
15.   Wilbert Robinson
8 it does actually seem like a valid question considering when you look at this:

*$500,000 Chad Billingsley
$10,000,000 Derek Lowe
$9,500,000 Brad Penny
$12,300,000 Hiroki Kuroda
$12,000,000 Jason Schmidt

2007-12-17 13:37:02
16.   D4P
Shouldn't a story like this at least mention "Shawshenk Redemption"...?

http://www.cnn.com/2007/US/law/12/17/jail.escape.ap/index.html

2007-12-17 13:37:45
17.   natepurcell
15

If you include his bonus, Schmidt makes more.

2007-12-17 13:38:46
18.   wronghanded
14 That was a great one but I think Pete Rose and Brian Jordan (a couple of times) might argue otherwise.
2007-12-17 13:39:51
19.   Penarol1916
My daughter just called me at work with some of the oddest homework questions. Does anyone know of any synonyms or antonyms for "Snowman"? I did snow person for synonym, but that sounds like the stupidest assignment I've ever heard.
2007-12-17 13:40:54
20.   Eric Stephen
19
Antonym for Snowman: Falcon?
2007-12-17 13:41:22
21.   wronghanded
19 antonym- waterwoman?
2007-12-17 13:42:07
22.   Bob Timmermann
I'm on the case of finding out Kuroda's GO/FO ratio, but I may not have an answer for a few days.

It's likely that NPB keeps the stats, but they don't publish them online and/or in English.

2007-12-17 13:43:25
23.   Jon Weisman
19 - Heatmeiser.
2007-12-17 13:43:53
24.   Eric Stephen
This makes two straight years the Dodgers have signed a backup catcher who was drafted by the Phillies in 1990.
2007-12-17 13:44:08
25.   bhsportsguy
40-man roster is now full.

25-man roster as of 12/17/2007 1:30 p.m. PST

Pitchers (9)
Penny, Lowe, Billingsley, Kuroda, Loiaza, Proctor, Beimel, Broxton, and Saito
Catchers (2)
Martin, Bennett
Infield (5)
Loney, Kent, Furcal, Garciaparra, LaRoche
Outfield (4)
Kemp, Ethier, Jones, and Pierre

Probables
Pitchers (2-3 from this group):
Schmidt, Meloan, Kuo, Brazoban, Hull, Houlton, Stults, or NRI
Infield (1-2):
Abreu, Hu, Valdez, Sweeney, or NRI
Outfield (1):
Young, Repko

2007-12-17 13:45:07
26.   wronghanded
I got it... Sun Goddess
2007-12-17 13:46:53
27.   bhsportsguy
23 Off the top of my head.

"I'm Mister Heatmiser, I'm Mister Sun;
I'm Mister Heatmiser, I'm Mister hundred and one;
They call me Heatmiser, whatever touch, simplys turns into mush, he's too much."

2007-12-17 13:47:16
28.   Ken Noe
Man, Camille leaves and McCourt's PR goes to pot.

19 "Yeti" works if the snowman is, well, abominable.

2007-12-17 13:49:12
29.   Eric Enders
24 Next year we'll have Marvin Benard.
2007-12-17 13:49:55
30.   Bob Timmermann
27
Messrs. Rankin and Bass have made Christmastime truly a nightmare of bad programming for those of us in the tail end of the Baby Boom or vanguard of Generation X.

I'm still shopping for a generation.

2007-12-17 13:50:34
31.   Eric Stephen
29
Wasn't he also in the Mitchell Report?
2007-12-17 13:50:57
32.   Ken Noe
Tony Jackson says that Bennett will cost $325,000 less than Liberthal. Diamond Leung says that McCourt's okay with HGH users as long as they've owned up, as Bennett has.
2007-12-17 13:51:11
33.   Bob Timmermann
31
Yep, and this guy from the New Republic is way too fascinated with Marvin Benard.

http://tinyurl.com/yt6knu

2007-12-17 13:52:02
34.   Bob Timmermann
My St. Louis connection says that Gary Bennett will not be missed there.
2007-12-17 13:52:34
35.   Eric Enders
I'm fine with HGH users, too. I'm not fine with catchers who stink, though. Lieberthal would have been worth $325K more than Bennett.
2007-12-17 13:52:45
36.   Humma Kavula
20 is the winner. The quickest answer and the best so far.
2007-12-17 13:52:57
37.   GobiasIndustries
3
How bout Pete Rose and Ray Fosse in the 1970 All-Star game. That was a gooooooood one.
2007-12-17 13:56:18
38.   Wilbert Robinson
I remember reading somewhere that GORO was Japanese for groundball. It was coined by Issei in WRA camps. It comes from "goro goro" in Japanese which means thunder or the sound of something rolling.
2007-12-17 13:58:24
39.   Eric Enders
In case you were wondering, Bennett in his career has thrown out 71 of 326 basestealers (21.8 percent). His catcher's ERA is 4.64.
2007-12-17 13:59:53
40.   underdog
Yeah, I agree with Eric, I don't understand why we didn't resign Lieberthal, who clearly wanted to be in LA, is a good guy, and already knows most of the pitching staff. I guess they felt like the extra money was too much to justify for someone only getting 20 starts, but still...

Oh well, at least he's not Chad Kreuter, still my least favorite all-time Dodger backup catcher.

2007-12-17 14:00:48
41.   trainwreck
I miss Chad Moeller.
2007-12-17 14:01:52
42.   Eric Stephen
39
Great. Can't hit. Doesn't throw out runners.

Perfect for a backup C. Lieberthal must have reacted Kemp-like (trash can) when Gonzo and the gang gave him flowers and balloons when he started late last year. :)

2007-12-17 14:02:58
43.   Eric Stephen
40
Is the lack of Kreuter love because of the Wrigley incident? I kind of liked Chad.
2007-12-17 14:03:29
44.   Bob Timmermann
Chad Kreuter was the first Dodger DH to hit a home run!
2007-12-17 14:03:37
45.   Disabled List
What a worthless signing. What good is Gary Bennett going to do? He's completely washed up, can't hit major-league pitching, and his very presence will stain the Dodgers because of his past impropriety. Also, I always thought Gary Bennett was completely heartless for those nasty things he said about the female kicker at Colorado that he kicked off the team. The Buffaloes were like Animal House when he was in charge of that program. I can't understand why the Dodgers would sign a jerk like him, especially because he's a former football coach, not a catch-- ohhhh wait, that's Gary Barnett.

Nevermind.

2007-12-17 14:04:17
46.   Humma Kavula
OK, now I'm really going to violate Rule 8, but this signing does kind of beg us to do it. It's like the Andruw Jones signing and talking about Juan Pierre...

Do the Dodgers have any long-term plan to preserve Martin? Surely they realize that he is the very best asset that the team has, because he can hit and he plays catcher. Catchers have a short shelf-life, career-wise.

I realize that arguing about a team's backup catcher is a little pedantic, but how long can the team keep running Martin out there every day before our Golden God will be tarnished?

2007-12-17 14:08:53
47.   regfairfield
I'd really like to see the Dodgers go after J.R. House and make him the backup plan in case he gets hurt. Guy put up an OPS over .800 in the biggest pitchers park in baseball, he deserves a shot.
2007-12-17 14:09:48
48.   underdog
43 He was a hothead. And a former coworker of mine went to school with him and said he used to get in fights all the time. But maybe I missed the nicer side of him. Gary Bennett could well take his spot though.
2007-12-17 14:11:00
49.   Bob Timmermann
I would assume Kreuter has mellowed out or else USC wouldn't have hired him.
2007-12-17 14:21:47
50.   berkowit28
35 Lieberthal would have been worth $325K more than Bennett.

In which ways?

Show/Hide Comments 51-100
2007-12-17 14:22:54
51.   TheBigGrabowski
Well, this destroys my dream of having Piazza back up Martin.
2007-12-17 14:22:58
52.   madmac
Just curious. What could Ned do to make everyone here happy? It's the backup catcher who won't see many innings. If it doesn't work out it won't be too hard to find another one.

I'm not convinced that had he kept Leiberthal around there wouldn't be the same complaints. Heck Ned has pretty much done everything the majority here hoped he would do. So without anything really to complain about it's Kuroda isn't very good and he's overpaid (granted that's the minority). Others refuse to give Ned credit and insist he's being forced to hold onto the kids.

I guess we're lucky if we have to try and find things to complain about.

2007-12-17 14:23:09
53.   Sagehen
I keep wondering about Lieberthal because resigning him was such an obvious move. Was there something we don't know about? Was he one of the complaining vets? (although who could blame him) Was he the focus of the complaints coming from Gonzo and Kent about vets not getting respect (and hence caught in the middle while remaining a good guy himself)? Did he ask to go elsewhere so that he could play? Did the pitching staff complain about his game calling? (Hence explaining some of Martin's overuse). I just have to wonder if there's something else going on here because if not, this really truly appears to be a birdbrained move.
2007-12-17 14:24:39
54.   Sagehen
Yes, it's the backup catcher, so perhaps we shouldn't be complaining. But there is little to no depth at catcher in the organization. If, heaven forbid, Martin goes down briefly, there is no satisfactory backup. At least with Lieberthal, we knew that he could play for two weeks if necessary.
2007-12-17 14:24:48
55.   Eric Enders
50 Well, the injury insurance aspect, for one. If Martin gets hurt, Lieberthal is a guy who could conceivably fill in on a temporary basis. With Bennett as your backup, if Martin pulls a hamstring and goes on the DL for three weeks, you're still going to have to go trade something of value to get a real catcher.
2007-12-17 14:25:02
56.   dzzrtRatt
20 Antonym: Sludgeman?

How many times did Lieberthal pinch hit last season? My recollection is he was used a few times in that role. Bennett is just a space plug on the 25-man roster. Irritating signing.

2007-12-17 14:26:29
57.   Sagehen
Please tell me that Bennett has a split contract so that he will start the year in AAA and serve as the third string catcher? Please, oh please. This can't be it.
2007-12-17 14:26:58
58.   Eric Enders
How about snowwoman?
2007-12-17 14:27:40
59.   Sagehen
58 Sunwoman.
2007-12-17 14:28:17
60.   Eric Stephen
Gary Bennett wore number 28 the last two seasons with St. Louis. Shea Hillenbrand wore that number with LA last year.
2007-12-17 14:28:46
61.   Eric Enders
Is the opposite of snow "sun," or "water"?

Waterwoman?

2007-12-17 14:29:08
62.   FirstMohican
52 - When the Dodgers signed Kuroda/Jones nobody here (as far as I know) took anything away from those singings because of Ned's past bad moves.

To answer your question, I think this offseason overall has made a number of skeptical people reasonably happy, including me.

2007-12-17 14:29:35
63.   regfairfield
52 My concerns about Kuroda are completely valid. I'm not complaining for the sake of complaining.
2007-12-17 14:30:40
64.   Bob Timmermann
Mike Lieberthal was 3 for 9 as a pinch hitter in 2007.
2007-12-17 14:31:20
65.   Sagehen
61 Aquawoman
2007-12-17 14:32:06
66.   Eric Stephen
56
Lieberthal pinch hit 9 times last season(3 for 9), and stayed in 3 of those games as catcher.
2007-12-17 14:32:30
67.   Sagehen
60 Ah, so that explains it! Bennett was signed because the Dodgers MUST have someone who can neither hit nor field to wear #28.
2007-12-17 14:32:52
68.   Eric Enders
Bennett has 41 career pinch hitting appearances in which he is batting .175/.195/.200.
2007-12-17 14:34:23
69.   regfairfield
To be fair, it's going to be really hard for Bennett to be worse than Lieberthal was last year.
2007-12-17 14:37:29
70.   Ghost of Carlos Perez
61
To me, the opposite of snow would be fire.

I actually like the Bennett signing. If the Dodgers can make the playoffs, I'd say Bennett is the perfect candidate for "unlikely postseason hero."

2007-12-17 14:38:29
71.   madmac
62 I think the attitude has gotten better, but then just the other day there is a post how maybe it's best the dodgers don't make the post-season so Ned will lose his job. Why such hate?
2007-12-17 14:38:33
72.   regfairfield
70 Quite unlikely, since there's no way he'd ever touch a bat in the post season.
2007-12-17 14:39:24
73.   Eric Stephen
69
True. Only 21 men post-integration have had more plate appearances with one or less RBI than Lieberthal in 2007.

http://www.bb-ref.com/pi/shareit/Kd8T

2007-12-17 14:39:42
74.   StolenMonkey86
Is Joe Torre less likely to run Martin into the ground?
2007-12-17 14:39:59
75.   Humma Kavula
I wouldn't necessarily advocate re-signing Liberthal, but considering that for most of last year, Martin's overuse (or potential overuse) was a big topic of conversation, I think many of us thought that it was an area that could be addressed by getting a backup catcher that the team could rely upon. To see the potential problem addressed this way shows that the Dodgers don't see it as a problem. And maybe it isn't... but it's not a bet that I'd make.
2007-12-17 14:40:38
76.   Eric Enders
I guess I prefer the likely postseason heroes. But it's an interesting thought, compiling a roster of guys who everybody expects to suck.

Do we still have Tomas Perez?

2007-12-17 14:41:53
77.   kinbote
After a day of catching up on the weekend's posts, I have a few general reactions, mostly about the Kuroda signing.

1. I really disagee with this notion of Kuroda's having "no upside." True, it's unlikely he'll win 20 games or finish in the top five of the Cy Young vote, but it's possible he could achieve a great level of success here. It's entirely possible he could be our 3rd best pitcher this year, and on a contending team, that's not small potatoes.

2. While the amount of money spent is a bit alarming, I think the true test of fiscal prudence [i.e., saving for the future--whether it's Martin, Kemp, or Santana] will come next offseason. I count about $47m coming off the books next offseason: that's when we need to decide what direction we're heading. I hate to sound like Colletti, but we're still smack in the middle of that transition/bridge period where we're just adding veterans to supplement the youngsters.

3. I have no opinion of Bennet. All I ask is that he's better with the bat than Bako.

2007-12-17 14:43:30
78.   regfairfield
74 Posada has caught at least 131 games since 2000.
2007-12-17 14:44:00
79.   D4P
Is Bennett better than all of our minor league catchers...?

Heck, is he better than any?

2007-12-17 14:46:05
80.   trainwreck
How about a firebird.

So you could either say a phoenix or a car.

2007-12-17 14:46:22
81.   Humma Kavula
74 Jorge Posada, games caught:

2007 - 138
2006 - 134
2005 - 133
2004 - 134
2003 - 137
2002 - 138

Last year, the Yankees' backup was Jose Molina. In 2006, Kelly Stinett. In 2003, 2004, and 2005, John Flaherty.

2007-12-17 14:46:28
82.   madmac
63 I'm not singling anyone out or saying your concerns aren't valid. My point is he is doing basically what the majority here wanted. It's not his fault the free agent market is what it is. It's not his fault teams won't accept trades with us that don't involve our ML players. What should he have done on the pitching front? I haven't seen anyone offer up another solution. I think I'd rather have Kuroda right now than go with our in house options. Sure Kuroda is a gamble, but one that I think is in our favor and puts the Dodgers in a better position than they were 4 days ago.
2007-12-17 14:47:12
83.   Lexinthedena
Lieberthal seemed lost behind the plate last year..and the Dodger's didn't win when he pitched.....I have not seen Bennet play in a long time....but people should keep their eyes open with Rene Rivera.....Not sure if he can hit in the Majors...but I watched him play against Leones De Caracas during the Caribbean WS and he was excellent behind the plate.....I hope he is given the chance to win the job over Bennet...
2007-12-17 14:47:50
84.   regfairfield
82 Hold the fort, our pitching is fine. We are a better team in 2008, but I'm concered about what it means in the future.

79 I'd say he's better than all of them. They're really, really bad.

2007-12-17 14:48:43
85.   Eric Enders
Probably our three most promising minor league catchers (May, Santana, Jansen) all played at various steps of Class A last year, so I don't think we can count on any help from the system in 2008 (or perhaps over the next 4-5 years, as those guys aren't realy great prospects anyway).

Logan White needs to draft a few catchers. Perhaps in 2009, when we'll have as many as seven first round picks (our own, plus compensation picks for Lowe, Penny, Furcal, possibly even Kent).

2007-12-17 14:49:16
86.   regfairfield
83 He's only 24, but he hit .214/.275/.310 in AA last year. He's part of the really, really bad that I mentioned.
2007-12-17 14:50:12
87.   regfairfield
85 Penny isn't going anywhere next year, there's no reason to not pick up a 9.5 million dollar option.
2007-12-17 14:50:27
88.   berkowit28
55 I must have missed where someone has posted comparison stats on Bennett vs. Lieberthal fielding and batting. The only stats I've seen were in the dodgers.com report:

"[Bennett] hit .252 with two homers and 17 RBIs in 155 at-bats in 2007....Bennett replaces Mike Lieberthal, who hit .234 with no homers and one RBI in only 77 at-bats as Martin's backup."

FWIW, those don't seem actually worse. So there must be other stats to make many people so contemptuous of him. Yes?

Also FWIW, I liked Lieberthal: he seemed a nice guy. He was used throughout the season more as a package with Wolf, who's gone.

Let's say it was time to start resting Martin twice as much as last year. Wouldn't we need someone better and younger than either Lieberthal or Bennett? And more expensive? Might it not make sense to wait until sometime mid-season to look for one of those, when they'll be both more plentiful and cheaper? Then Bennett will become the 3rd-string catcher. I can't see how getting Lieberthal helps in this scenario. Use the money towards the more expensive guy mid-season.

2007-12-17 14:51:50
89.   Eric Enders
87 Oh, I didn't even realize we had a Penny option. I thought he was FA after this year.

Still the worst trade in franchise history, though.

2007-12-17 14:52:19
90.   Eric Stephen
85
Dodgers hold a relatively cheap $9.25m 2009 option on Penny, so I hope they don't lose him after 2008.

83
Lieberthal started 17 games for the Dodgers last season, and the team was 3-14 in those games. Ouch.

2007-12-17 14:52:30
91.   Eric Enders
88 Two words: Sample Size.
2007-12-17 14:52:38
92.   bhsportsguy
85 He drafts them but usually only for filler on the Rookie clubs. He's looking for the next Russell Martin (conversion project, see Lucas May and Carlos Santana)

I don't think he would ever use a top ten round pick on a catcher (Mike Nixon anyone).

I say that will checking the records so I will be proven wrong, I know it.

2007-12-17 14:53:41
93.   D4P
Still the worst trade in franchise history, though

Actually, we're allowed to revisit the trade iff Depo traded Lo Duca for steroid reasons.

2007-12-17 14:54:04
94.   Daniel Zappala
My antonym for snowman: puddle.
2007-12-17 14:55:12
95.   Humma Kavula
Not knowing much about John Flaherty, I decided to look him up. After all, the Yankees had been pretty happy with him, re-signing him twice. How did he lose his job?

Answer: he turned 37. Or he got unlucky. Either way, after following up campaigns of .267/.297/.457 and .252/.286/.465, his hits didn't fall and he lost his power and batted a positively anemic .165/.206/.252 in 2005. That is an OPS+ of 23. Joe Torre gave him 127 at-bats to do that.

2007-12-17 14:55:58
96.   Bob Timmermann
94
The puddle was Frosty's fate when he went someplace warm.
2007-12-17 14:56:13
97.   Eric Enders
Humanoid figure built on top of the snow = snowman
Humanoid figure depressed into the snow = snow angel
2007-12-17 14:57:31
98.   Humma Kavula
88 Also, see my post in 75 . Lieberthal was clearly a problem last year, considering how much we complained about Martin's lack of rest. I disagree with Enders -- I thought he had to be replaced. Bennett does not do that adequately.
2007-12-17 14:57:33
99.   madmac
84 I really think this solution bodes better for our future than the other options. We needed to try and improve our pitching this year. We did what we had to do. Three years isn't bad. Trading away our future (and present) would have been worse. I really don't see this signing as holding up our young pitchers, but it probably buys them some needed time.
2007-12-17 14:59:14
100.   D4P
Gurnick is predicting (just his opinion) that Pierre will bat 8th.
Show/Hide Comments 101-150
2007-12-17 14:59:53
101.   Eric Enders
98 I'm OK with the notion that Lieberthal should have been improved upon. It's just that we don't know whether there were any genuine options for doing that.

What we do know for a fact is that Ned was able to choose between Lieberthal and Bennett, and chose Bennett despite Lieberthal being the obviously better pick.

2007-12-17 15:01:57
102.   D4P
At $825,000, I think it's say to conclude that Bennett will be overpaid. Does he really deserve more than twice the major league minimum?
2007-12-17 15:03:44
103.   Bob Timmermann
102
You think mendicant orders of monks are overpaid.
2007-12-17 15:06:00
104.   regfairfield
102 I don't think it matters.
2007-12-17 15:06:34
105.   Humma Kavula
I know he really isn't all that good, but I miss Dioner Navarro.

Or, as he was once called by the LA Dogtrainer, "De Owner of De Area behind De Plate."

2007-12-17 15:06:40
106.   D4P
103
Paying someone $825,000 to stop the ball from hitting the umpire/going to the backstop 20 games a year is an awful lot.

I hope some reporter makes Ned say something good about Bennett. He can't say he's good on offense, can't say he's good on defense, and can't brag about his character.

What's left?

2007-12-17 15:08:09
107.   MC Safety
100 And he even penciled in LaRoche at 3b on top of putting the Rolen rumor to rest! I am convinced someone said something.
2007-12-17 15:09:58
108.   Ghost of Carlos Perez