
|
Bowa Constrictor
2008-02-29 07:02
I don't really want to get into the politics of new Dodger third-base coach Larry Bowa's rebellion against Major League Baseball's new helmet rule for coaches or I guess to be blunt, I don't want the commenters of Dodger Thoughts to do so, because political discussion is against the site rules. But to offer a few thoughts: 1) The argument that the helmets are uncomfortable echoes an argument people had against wearing seat belts when those became compulsory. If it wasn't common sense already, we learned that people get used to things and the discomfort disappears. Also, getting hurt less tends to be more comfortable than getting hurt more. 2) The argument that umpires are in more danger than coaches, if it's true, doesn't imply you should be fighting against helmets for coaches. It implies that we just need to consider helmets for umpires. 3) From a Dodger perspective, consider that Bowa is a man in authority, expecting to be listened to, telling the world that he has no intention of listening to authority. You may agree or disagree with Bowa's opinion on helmets (we know where Vin Scully would stand). But I do think it qualifies as irony that on a day that criticism renewed of Dodger players running through stop signs, Bowa is running through one himself. * * * I'm sure that during his time with the Dodgers, someone used "Julio Lugo" and "parasite" in the same sentence. To those people, here you go. * * * Craig Brown of The Hardball Times looks back at baseball collusion of the 1980s and how that helped Kirk Gibson become a Dodger. * * * From the Obscure but Memorable Dodger Department: Jack Perconte. * * * The starting lineup for today's exhibition game, televised by ESPN at 10 a.m. Rafael Furcal, SS Juan Pierre will not play, according to Diamond Leung of the Press-Enterprise. Update: MLB threatened coaches (or at least outspoken ones) with immediate ejection if they don't wear a helmet, reports Tony Jackson of the Daily News.
|
Leaving aside for a moment whether or not Bowa's anti-helmet rant is correct, this is the major problem that I have with what he is saying. He is not just a man in authority, he is an outspoken authoritarian, and for him to openly and loudly ignore the rules, while younger players on the team are criticized for their mistakes, shows a clear double standard. What if Matt Kemp were to say,"I am going to continue to run the bases with my head down, and if the Dodgers don't like it, they can fine me?" I think we all know what the reaction would be.
Also--it is just me, or do you all just wish that Bowa would keep his mouth shut? He is not the manager, nor has he ever been a good manager when he has gotten the chance, so his opinions don't carry much weight for me. He should just stand in the coach's box, either waving his arms or putting up the stop sign, and if he has something to say to a player, he should say it privately to that player.
It's not a matter of public policy. It's the rules of the job.
Larry Bowa's opinion probably reflects a majority of MLB coaches and I thought his concerns were reasoned and certainly a compromise could be reached.
http://www.640wgst.com/pages/jakeblog.html
For some reason Kuroda Time does not have the cache of Miller Time.
This would be a good thing.
Bowa has already surpassed Jack Clark as "Least Liked Coach in L.A. Dodger History" in my record book.
vr, Xei
The title goes back to 1971 and was first held by Bill Singer.
Your are right Larry Bowa is an idiot and has been his whole career but on this issue as BH said, his view shouldn't be discounted just because he is an idiot.
I will concede to Bob that this is an OSHA issue and if they were to study it and find that it makes sense from an occupational safety issue that coaches and umpires should be better protected then by all means do so. I just wonder when the 1st line drive to the chest of a baserunner on 3rd base stops his heart what will be the cry of those who want everyone protected from all things. Since catastrophic injury is possible as a hitter, fielder, or runner on every play maybe we should just stick to video games. That is safe for everyone concerned.
Plus we really should look into the idea of either putting helmets on all the spectators who are even in greater peril then the basecoaches, or at the least put up a net or plexiglass shield. Plus let us require that every person in the dugout be protected at all times and since the pitcher is closer to the action then the base coach, shouldn't he also be wearing protective gear? Babies who can't wear helmet shouldn't even be allowed to sit between the bases on the 1st level.
This game of baseball is a dangerous business, so let us make sure that everyone is protected not just the old fogies dancing in the coaching boxes.
Just curious about your hatred's. Bill Singer seemed to be a cool guy back in 1971 and you were I expect between 3-7, so what could he have done to you that you were already hating on him?
http://tinyurl.com/ynqzv4
But at a time where the Dodgers probably need or want to emphasize seeing the bigger picture beyond your own self-interest, this is an interesting counterpoint.
http://dodgerthoughts.baseballtoaster.com/archives/016821.html
My first and last trip ever to Dodgertown. So bittersweet...
I don't see the connection. He said he hated Singer in 1971, when Singer was our Chad Billingsley not after Singer turned into a drunken lout and insulted our Kim Ng.
I really hope that Torre and Bowa come through and put an end to such incredible stupidity on the part of highly paid professional players. While I appreciate the pure athleticism of these guys, I would like to see them using their brains a little more. Fighter pilots call it "situational awareness" and that concept applies to baseball players as well.
Maybe, the alternative is someone like Garrett Anderson or Shawn Green who always played the game in complete control but were always being accused of never giving it their all, probably by the same people who complain about the aggressiveness of Kemp and Repko.
Either they're "animals" with "no brains" and "stupidity" or they're young guys trying a little too hard to make the team and earn a starting spot, respectively.
Is it really time for us start insulting and criticizing our young players for playing too hard in the first game in spring training?
Maybe when they're "old school" they'll realize that spring training is for loafing.
1. Running into an outfield fence
2. Running into a foul area fence or structure
3. Sliding head first into a base
4. Just running to and fro
5. High Fiving Matt Kemp
6. Hitting the breaks on 3rd when Bowa throws up a late stop sign
7. Breaking up a fight between Bowa and Kemp
8. Breaking up a fight between Kent and Kemp
9. Getting in a fight with Kent
10. Sleeping
But really, Larry, a broken bat?
He was one of my favorite players right before the ankle injury. I truly hope he gets a chance to make it somewhere, since it looks like there is little room here. I love the way he plays, and he had a great start to that season...who knows how it would have gone if he had stayed healthy all year, no Pierre?
11. At a bar with Joe Beimel!
Marty says what I want to say so much more clearly than I do.
I understand. This was just fun at his expense. His injury history is extensive all the way back to his minor league days and I would have posted the list even if he had not been involved in the Furcal play. He ripped his hammy later, it had nothing to do with the play. I wish him well but sometimes I will go with a cheap laugh even if I'm the only one laughing.
37
I saw him pitch the lamest no-hitter in Dodger history so I had a different perception but I don't think it was 71. Mr. Allen was also my favorite player that year but for different reasons.
42
I will be happy to debate the issue with the both of you at the next DT outing. Just because you don't think it isn't important doesn't mean it isn't. It just isn't important to you.
vr, Xei
Simple, huh?
Yeah, this is stating the obvious. But I am more interested in seeing Miller for the first time.
Umpires generally have to pay attention to where the ball is, while coaches may be focusing on other parts of the game.
Was it the SD coach last year that was half way down the base path and Brad Penny called him on it?
On the helmet issue, I heard Terry Francona talk about it on XM this morning on a program that Bowa worked on in between managing and coaching jobs. It sounded like he came down to this conclusion, his coaches will have to follow this MLB rule but he understands all their frustration with it and that it will take some time to adjust. He also said that there were further rules re where coaches can stand and that was another problem because that goes against all that those guys were taught for many years.
YEAH!!! Did you people ever ONCE think about THAT!
Seriously though, if the old dudes don't want to wear helmets they shouldn't have to. Safety is the new tyranny. We're sanitizing the colour and risk right out of life. In 10 years we're ALL be thinking like safety nerds.
On that Dos Equis commercial...it's going along all cool, then the guy releases the bear from the trap and what? "DO NOT ATTEMPT" appears in small print below it.
OK, something is wrong.
We've got beer commercials telling us to drink responsibly. If everyone did they'd be out of business. If weekend drunk driving is such a problem you'd be seeing wrecks every 30 feet!
And I'm IN the safety business. In charge of safety for over a thousand workers. Safety has to make sense, or it loses it's force, it's legitimacy...people scoff. You never want your guys to scoff.
At the very least Safety should argue from probability. The ratio of hits in major league baseball history compared to the number of serious head injuries to coaches would probably be like 3 billion to 2. This is NOT a compelling reason to mess with tradition.
And Jon, you attempt to trivialize the issue when you say people were against seat belt laws because of "comfort", no it was about freedom. (Don't mean to sound like Rambo).
There is money to be made here. Someone needs to design a fashionably comfortable helmet for base coaches.
Sadly, no
As I recall, George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, et al., were in exactly the same position.
The motivation for this exercise was the death of Mike Coolbaugh, first base coach for the Rockies' AA Tulsa affiliate. The ball that struck him actually hit him in the neck, crushing his left vertebral artery. A helmet would not have made a difference.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_Coolbaugh
from all accounts (and I admit I have not seen it), it sounds like Loney was 1/3 of the way down the line when Kemp kept going. So, he may have looked up to see Loney going home, and Kemp just went for it.
But it is pretty amazing to slide head first with Loney on the bag. You would think Kemp would have stopped half way and made a run back to second. I tend to look at my 3rd base coach in softball, because I need to know if I should slide or not. Of course, most of them do nothing, so I have to gauge it by the third baseman's actions.
This is EXACTLY right. Some time ago, I discovered that the safety cover on my table saw was more of a nuisance than a help. Trust me, I have no problems with safety devices on a saw spinning at 3,000 RPM with my fingers only inches away... I've also encountered kickback when I ill-advisedly released pressure on a workpiece and the saw shot it back at me like a rocket. But the fact is -- and this is something even the saw makers will agree with -- a badly designed safety device is worse than useless.
vr, Xei
Amen
Even Phil Jackson gives those in-game interviews, and he probably things those are more dangerous to his health than a flying baseball to his head.
How about aluminum bats, and the base coaches and infield umpires all wear catchers gear?
And some credence DOES have to be given to older guys like Bowa when they talk of 'comfort'. It's not going to be too pleasant standing out in the August sun in a plastic and foam helmet. Ever sleep on a foam pillow? Hype aside, those things are HOT.
Actually, I was going to compare Larry Bowa to Henry David Thoreau, with the threat of civil disobedience and all that.
Larry Bowa is what Thoreau would have been like if he violated Rule 1 every third word.
over under is May 21
vr, Xei
As for this paragraph:
"We've got beer commercials telling us to drink responsibly. If everyone did they'd be out of business. If weekend drunk driving is such a problem you'd be seeing wrecks every 30 feet! "
It's nonsensical. Drinking responsibly won't put beer companies out of business. And the third sentence is particularly baffling: 1) maybe the call to limit drunk driving has curtailed the problem; 2) you don't need to see accidents every 30 feet for something to qualify as a problem, 3) are you really suggesting that life was better before we had any admonitions against drunk driving?
Better for the beer companies to be hypocritical about drunk driving than completely ignore the problem.
I understand the position against the helmets and even sympathize with it to a degree (to the extent that injuries to coaches are rare), but talk about an overreaction.
http://tinyurl.com/2qwvpj
Foam helmets are hot, but they aren't the end of the world. There are other people on the field that are worse off.
vr, Xei
Sighting law suits is not the be-all end-all arguement. We can change those laws and become human again. WE are in charge. The law is not some Fact-of-Life immovable cold force outside of ourselves.
Ok I'm done, sorry.
vr, Xei
Has it really been 5 moths?
Lets go Dodgers!
I am still trying to figure out how to get a shared office with access to ESPN.
My Amen was for the parts I agreed with. Yes, most of it was nonsense but Frip hit the phrase freedom of choice and I spasmed.
In a nutshell I would like the freedom of choice to have my coconut split open by pavement, car, or horsehide without someone else imposing their own view of what life is about. My friends would understand or should. Life is full of dangers, trying to protect adults from all of them is foolhardy. For some the goal is to live the longest for others it is simply to live. Those with families should think hard before making the decision but they should still be allowed to make the decision. It is not for society to decide for them. JMO
I skied for 30 years without a helmet. Now, mostly against my will, I wear one - even though I don't really feel the need. Guess what: skiing is still fun.
Life goes on quite nicely and is full of color, I find, even with safety regulations.
And LaRoche crushes it to center...nice. I like that 3-4-5.
It was cool to hear Kruk and Phillips rave about Kemp's five-tool potential, even if they had to bring up the baserunning "issues" too.
http://www.insidesocal.com/dodgers/archives/2008/02/bowa_agrees_to.html
kuroda 2ip, 4er and for some reason tejeda was on the braves.
We're talking helmets here man. Helmets. Just in case a ball comes screaming at his noggin, he might stand a better chance to survive it.
Kruk also just called Russell Martin "a stud, man".
Gary Bennett = not quite as fast as Matt Kemp.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2008/02/28/wtoilet128.xml
Seriously, couldn't really tell. I just hope he starts making pitchers nervous. He started the DP cleanly, too.
If Kemp's base-running followed the script yesterday, shouldn't we see Bowa, safely, take a liner off his helmet today?
I find all helmets uncomfortable, especially the shower helmets that Izzy invented.
76mph.
91.
91.
90 (on a curve).
92. (that one was well out of the zone)
90. (fouled off)
89 - sinker, ground ball to Loney.
vr, Xei
My theory on ST, is basically don't get hurt. Period.
After that, I'll let everything play out.
Just don't get hurt.
i know he had some arm issues last year, so doesn't look like we have schmidt part deux on our hands.
I think it would be better if he took a shot off his shin since that is now unprotected.
Larry would be stylish & comfortable in that, yes?
Joe Torre was interviewed in the dugout. "He seemed relaxed, he found a place," said Kruk. And then something about how Torre used to carry Jeter's bat around with him all the time, and is he carrying anyone's bat around yet...? Not yet, he says.
Buddy Carlyle!
Steve Phillips harping on Kemp for not knowing how many outs there are (he caught a line drive and then started running in). C'mon Bison, stop giving the old boys network fodder to criticize you with! Kruk came to his defense of course.
This morning I unfortunately caught the last few words of a BBC news story on Takashi Saito death after a beating. Search
at BBC and sure enough, some wrestling coaches killed a guy named Takashi Saito. Seemed really bizzare at the time.
You win. I can run with that.
174
He should have been wearing a helmet.
Btw, I don't think it fair to rip on someone for their first appearance in early February, no, just that Loiaza looked awful to start. I'm sure he'll get better. If he doesn't, he won't be on the team, yet alone the 5th starter.
I also am pretending today doesn't exist, since it's Leap Day, so I'm working at home and watching baseball and taking my time leaving the house, since today doesn't exist no one should care about my whereabouts.
:) vr, Xei
he gave up the 3 runs on a 3 run-hr to... you guessed it juan gone.
Also Loaza's cutter at 84 is not going to cut it, when his slider/change is sitting at 80.
vr, Xei
Again, I would not base my opinion on one appearance but the fact that he is falling into the same patterns that plagued him all last year is not good.
Did you turn white when you heard Kazmir needed an MRI and are you breathing easier now or still concerned?
217 Why do you hate him?
222 i hate his game.
Suffice to say I don't think we will ever see a Kuroda bat flip.
He's not expected to make the team anyway. He's not out of options. So it's not like there's all this pressure, other than what he must put on himself. But that still doesn't make this a particularly tough spot.
And Logan White drafted him! Who was the last major leaguer who fit that profile? Where is the LAPD when you need them?
:(
I'm old enough that my heart was broken by Mike Torrez at the first postseason game I ever attended.
Mike Torrez!
Lowe
Billingsley
Kuroda
Kuo (when the 5th spot comes up)
Loaiza is only good for mop-up.
I'm checking to see if Patrick Henry is available. If not my 2nd will be Steve McQueen.
239 - Hey - me too!
My biggest memory of that day is still the pregame moment of silence for Bing Crosby. And Mike Torrez pitched. And Dusty Baker homered. In fact, those are my only memories of that day.
Linda Rondstadt sang the National Anthem before the game.
I think Manny Mota struck out looking to end the game.
(stops to check)
Mota was the next to last out. Lopes struck out looking to end the game.
Jon says denounce, you say renounce.
I went to Game 3 of the 1977 WS. I went to Game 6 of the 1978 WS. I went to Game 4 of the 1981 WS.
I also went to Game 4 of the 1981 DS, Game 2 of the 1981 NLCS, Game 2 of the 1995 DS, and Game 1 of the 1996 DS.
The Dodgers are 2-5 in postseason play when I show up.
Not to brag but the latest quote by Nomar just made me gag.
http://tinyurl.com/2mvpov
The Dodgers are 1-2 when I show up at the playoffs.
I have a better record at Angel playoff games.
Hmm.
And I am not necessarily disagreeing with you either.
I made it simplistic but I know we weren't winning because Nomar was in the lineup and playing like crap.
Which is why I've haven't been fond of OP since then.
1995: 7-2 loss to the Reds in Game 1 of the NLDS
1996: 3-2 loss to the Braves in Game 2 of the NLDS
2006: 9-5 loss to the Mets in Game 3 of the NLDS.
My dad got us tickets to Game 6 of the '88 Series, but we all know how that turned out.
Little bobble on grounder, but game over.
2 ip 4 hits, 3 er, 2 bb, 1 so
http://www.notmartha.org/archives/2008/02/27/bacon-cups/
The issue isn't personal freedom. It isn't civil liberties. It is MLB telling its employees to wear a helmet. The Republic will stand
Also, as someone who has been accused of being a Nazi sleeper agent (very long story), but we spell it Fuhrer (if I could type an umlaut) or Fuerher.
Danke.
http://www.beloblog.com/Pe_Blogs/prosports/2008/02/kuo_to_the_bullpen_for_now.html
It is one thing to accept a job knowing what the rules are. It is another to have the rules change once you've been working for 30 years. Isn't that why they came up with the term "grandfathered"? I guess the other gender was out of luck as usual.
Now that I know how the rest of the game turns out, I think I will FFWD through the bottom of the 5th.
The bad - Loaiza's belt-high fest
The ugly - Miller's meltdown
Look, I said I was sorry. Aren't you ever going to let it go?
http://dragonbreath.dk/Topics.html
289 Joe wants 2 lefthanded guys in the pen, Kuo is out of options and if he can't be DLed, maybe he is trying to see if he can fit there. Kuo probably would be the 5th guy out of the pen so its not like he would have do it that often, maybe he would be the second lefty and emergency starter , long man.
290 Did you get your tickets?
Thank you. And when you say something like "greatly overexaggerated" again, I'll be sure to point it out next time.
on it.
Not sure if my tastes have really grown much since then.