Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
Jon's other site:
Screen Jam
TV and more ...
1) using profanity or any euphemisms for profanity
2) personally attacking other commenters
3) baiting other commenters
4) arguing for the sake of arguing
5) discussing politics
6) using hyperbole when something less will suffice
7) using sarcasm in a way that can be misinterpreted negatively
8) making the same point over and over again
9) typing "no-hitter" or "perfect game" to describe either in progress
10) being annoyed by the existence of this list
11) commenting under the obvious influence
12) claiming your opinion isn't allowed when it's just being disagreed with
It's been five years since this piece was first published: September 11, 2003. A lot has happened since then - including a very happy September 18, 2006. But this game will always remain special, and I hope you don't mind me continuing to remember it on this date.
* * *
Twenty years ago today, Dodger Stadium hosted its greatest game.
It began swathed in bright blue skies and triple-digit temperatures. When it ended, 228 crazy brilliant minutes later, shadows palmed most of the playing field, and every Dodger fan who witnessed the spectacle found themselves near joyous collapse.
The game was between the Dodgers of Steve Sax and Pedro Guerrero, of Greg Brock and Mike Marshall ... and the Braves of Dale Murphy, of Bruce Benedict, of Brad Komminsk.
In the end, however, it came down to one man. A rookie named R.J. Reynolds.
A Brave Battle
Los Angeles entered the game with a two-game lead in the National League Western Division over Atlanta. Their battle for the division crown came a year after a near-epic contest in which the Dodgers rallied from a 10 1/2-game deficit to the Braves in 12 days and took the lead, only to falter and have a home run by the Giants' Joe Morgan off Terry Forster knock them out on the final day of the season.
On September 11, 1983, coming off an extra-inning loss to Atlanta the night before, Los Angeles took the field behind starting pitcher Rick Honeycutt, making his fifth start for the team since being acquired from Texas in exchange for Dave Stewart, a player to be named later and $200,000. (Supplementary information in this article courtesy of Retrosheet.)
After a scoreless first inning, the Dodgers tallied two runs in the second off Braves starter Len Barker. With two out, catcher Jack Fimple, near the height of his brief but shining heyday as a fan favorite, doubled home Brock and Marshall.
Murphy brickwalled the Dodger momentum in the next inning, displaying the form that left his contemporaries certain he would become a Hall of Famer. In the top of the inning, Murphy hit a three-run home run, his 32nd of the season. In the bottom of the inning, he crashed into the center-field wall, glove extended above and beyond it, to rob Guerrero of a two-run homer.
Stunned at the end of the third, the crowd had no idea that the frenzy was only beginning.
Four on the Floor
With the kind of mathematical symmetry normally found in Schoolhouse Rock cartoons, the Dodgers used four pitchers in the fourth.
Honeycutt got the first two batters out in the top of the fourth, but then gave up back-to-back singles to Jerry Royster and Rafael Ramirez. Having seen his starting pitcher allow seven hits, two walks and a hit batsman in 3 2/3 innings, and with Murphy again at the plate, Dodger manager Tommy Lasorda brought in Pat Zachry.
Ramirez stole second base, and then Zachry walked Murphy.
With the bases loaded, Lasorda made another move, bringing lefthander Rich Rodas - in his second major league game - to face Chris Chambliss with the bases loaded.
Rodas walked Chambliss to force in the Braves' fourth run, then allowed a two-run single to Komminsk that made the score 6-2 Braves.
The fourth Dodger pitcher of the inning came in ... a young, young-looking guy by the name of Orel Hershiser. Compared to Rodas, Hershiser was a veteran. This was the Bulldog-to-be's third major-league game. To the naked eye, Lasorda was trying to win the way Buttermaker relied on Ogilvie and Miguel in The Bad News Bears.
Hershiser loaded the bases again with a walk to Benedict. The ninth batter of the inning, third baseman (no-not-that) Randy Johnson, came up with a chance to bury the Dodgers, but popped out to his hot corner counterpart Guerrero to end the top of the fourth.
The score stayed at 6-2 for two more innings. Marshall and Brock, who combined to reach base seven times in this game, led off the bottom of the fourth with singles. Reynolds, however, grounded into a double play. Fimple followed with a walk off Barker, but future Braves hero Sid Bream grounded out batting for Hershiser.
Burt Hooton, a longtime Dodger starter who went to the bullpen shortly after the acquisition of Honeycutt, became the team's fifth pitcher in the fifth. The teams gave the fans a breather with an uneventful inning, and Hooton retired the Braves in order in the top of the sixth.
Then the surreal moment arrived.
No, You're Not Even Warm
After Marshall flew out to open the bottom of the sixth, Brock walked, Reynolds singled him to second, and the Midas behind the recent Yankee dynasty, Atlanta manager Joe Torre, replaced Barker with Tommy Boggs.
Rick Monday, his heroic days behind him, batted for Fimple and was called out on strikes for the second out. But Ken Landreaux, the Dodgers' regular center fielder, pinch-hit for Hooton and walked to load the bases.
Torre went to the mound and signaled for a pitcher to replace Boggs. None other than Terry Forster - the fall guy of 1982 - emerged from the right-field bullpen.
But then a strange thing happened. Torre signaled again - for a right-handed pitcher.
The strange thing was not that Torre wanted a righty to face Sax. It was that he wanted a righty when none had been warming up.
On the telecast, Vin Scully reported that Tony Brizzolara had warmed up earlier in the game, but in this inning, it had clearly been Forster who was backing up Boggs. Brizzolara had been cooling off for some time.
As a puzzled Forster stood on the edge of the warning track and the outfield grass, looking back and forth between the mound and the bullpen, Torre insisted that Brizzolara come in to face Sax.
In Brizzolara came. He threw four pitches to Sax - in the dirt, low, low and high. In the Dodgers' third run came, and out went Torre to replace Brizzolara with Forster.
Atlanta was rattled, a thespian who had forgotten his lines on Broadway, but Los Angeles got the minimum out of the comedy, as shortstop Bill Russell struck out against Forster and left the bases loaded.
Joe Beckwith, the losing pitcher in the previous night's game, laid anchor for the Dodger bullpen, throwing three innings and scattering two singles and a walk. Meanwhile, the mythic Donnie Moore provided a dose of calm for the Braves, retiring the Dodger side in order in the seventh and the eighth.
And then came the bottom of the ninth.
With a Flick of the Wrists, It Begins
Jose Morales, 38 years and 116 pinch hits old, led off, batting for Beckwith. Against a change from Moore, Morales' off-balance swing, arms well behind his hips, wrists trailing his arms, presaged Kirk Gibson's flick at the backdoor slider from Dennis Eckersley five years and one month later. Morales' ball flew into the left-field corner, and Morales easily won a battle of his old legs and Brett Butler's weak arm, cruising into second with a stand-up double, and giving the master improvisationalist, Scully, his modest opening line ...
He just kind of felt for the ball.
Dave Anderson entered the game to run for Morales. As Sax batted (with S. Sax on the back of his uniform, to distinguish himself from his brother Dave for the easily confused), the television camera found a much-in-need-of-SlimFast Lasorda, sitting near Dodger coach Monty Basgall.
Lasorda, Basgall dying a little bit in the Dodger dugout. Tommy's not feeling well anyway. He's got a cold for about a month.
Gene Garber, sporting the kind of beard you just don't see ballplayers wear anymore, was warming up in the bullpen as Moore went 3-1 to Sax. One inside pitch later, Torre was out of the dugout with a hook for Moore. As Moore, the victim of a devastating playoff home run in October 1986, left the game, Tom Niedenfuer, his October 1983 counterpart, began warming up for in the Dodger bullpen for the 10th inning.
Russell, sporting the kind of physique you just don't see ballplayers compete with anymore, then struck out in his second consecutive critical at-bat.
Dusty Baker, in his last season with the Dodgers before his acrimonious departure, was the batter with one out and two on. Even Baker, with more than 200 career home runs, was thin back then.
Baker swung and missed at Garber's sidearm delivery, then took one low and outside. On the 1-1 pitch, Baker hit a pop fly that fell between second baseman Royster and right-fielder Claudell Washington, a defensive replacement for Komminsk. The bases were loaded with the tying runs.
This crowd is on its feet and pleading. They're all getting up. It is that time of day. Never mind the seventh-inning stretch. This is the wire.
Cecil Espy came in to run for Baker, and Guerrero came up to the plate. His at-bat took more than six minutes.
'This Is Hanging Time'
Guerrero swung and missed at the first pitch, took one low and outside, then hit a grounder just foul.
Boy, what an exhausting finish to a long afternoon at the ballpark. Well, it figured the Dodgers and the Braves are gonna put you through the ringer, right down to the last day. So naturally, they do it right down to the last minute.
Guerrero took one low, evening the count, 2-2. Then he grounded one by third base, just foul.
The table is set and the big man is in the chair.
Pitch No. 6 of the at-bat was six inches off the ground, outside - and still fouled off by Guerrero.
Boy, he was late. He just did get a piece of that. After you get that palmball trickery of Garber ... it was almost in Benedict's mitt.
No. 7: another grounder, just foul.
And the tension remains ...
With Garber about to throw the eighth pitch, Guerrero stepped out at the last moment and called time. Vinny, laughing:
Oh yeah, these are tough to take, I tell you what. Guerrero just had to back out. I mean, this is hanging time. Woo!
Garber bounced the resin bag back and forth on the front and back of his right hand. Guerrero stepped back in, and Garber threw. Low - ball three.
It is almost too much to take ...
Guerrero went back in for the ninth pitch of the at-bat, then called time again.
You can just imagine the pressure - you'd have to be a block of wood not to feel it.
Here came the pitch. Two feet outside. Guerrero flung the bat away backhanded and strutted to first base.
Anderson scored the first run of the inning, cutting the Braves' lead to 6-4. The ballpark shadows have just reached Garber. Third-base coach Joe Amalfitano counseled the next batter, Marshall.
Garber slipped on his right foot in delivering the first pitch outside for ball one. The next pitch was outside as well.
Marshall then hit a long drive to right. Washington, with his glove on his right hand, went toward the wall with his back to the right-field stands. But the ball was slicing behind him, and Washington turned his body 180 degrees to try to find and catch the ball in the late-afternoon sun.
It didn't take. The drive landed right at the base of the wall. Murphy, coming over to back up the play, nearly collided with Washington as the latter threw the ball back. Two runs scored on Marshall's double - tying the game at 6 - but Guerrero was held at third. On-deck hitter Brock stood near home plate, raising his hands behind his head like he thought Guerrero could have scored, but the replay showed that Amalfitano probably was wise to hold Guerrero.
With the winning run on third and first base open, Brock was walked intentionally - the first wide one barely snagged by a staggering Benedict.
The batter will be the kid, R.J. Reynolds, with a chance to win it.
Holding Back to the Last Second
Reynolds stood at home, looking at Amalfitano, and stretched the bat over both his shoulders.
And now, with the bases loaded, the infield is up, the outfield looks like a softball game, and the batter is R.J. Reynolds.
The first pitch is outside. Reynolds looked at Amalfitano again.
Gene Garber is battling to stay afloat.
If this was a game of Bad News Bears moments, this was Ahmad's.
Reynolds didn't give it away. In slow motion, the bat doesn't even start to come off Reynolds' shoulder until Garber's pitching arm is all the way back.
But then ... Reynolds' left hand finds the barrel of the bat. He lays the bat forward, relaxedly, at a slight downward diagonal pointing below his waist, then corrects it to a straight horizontal line to meet the ball.
Reynolds pauses a millisecond to watch. Garber's follow-through carries him toward the third-base side of the mound, but the bunt rolls toward the first base side.
The SQUEEZE! And here comes the run!!
By the time Garber reverses field and lunges for the ball, Guerrero is 15 feet away from home plate. Before Garber is even upright, Guerrero touches home, banging his hands together in exultation.
He squeezed it in!
Backs of jerseys from our past - Yeager, Thomas, Maldonado, Landestoy, Rivera - come out to rain congratulations on Guerrero. Lasorda risks smothering Reynolds in a headlock.
By the way, if you are keeping score in this madhouse, not only did R.J. squeeze, he got a base hit and an RBI. And Guerrero brought the winning run home. BEDLAM at Dodger Stadium.
Replays and images of celebrations pass in front of us for several seconds, without comentary - you know this is Vinny's way, to let the moment be the moment. We catch Ross Porter, in short-sleeved shirt and tie, is in the dugout to prepare to interview Reynolds.
Finally, Vin is ready to speak again.
The pictures told it all. There isn't any way I could improve on the picture. What a story. The squeeze in the ninth. The Dodgers score four times and pull it out and beat the Braves, 7 to 6. They show the squeeze on Diamond Vision and the crowd, EUPHORIC in its joy, roars again.
R.J. Reynolds has put the Dodgers in the right direction.
And so he had. The victory put the Dodgers three games up in the NL West, and three games up in the NL West is how the Dodgers finished the 1983 season.
Reynolds was a hero. A baseball hero, at least.
And a game for the ages, a game worth remembering, I hope, even on the saddest of anniversaries, was over.
anyway while Manny was again a stud, and i was of course ecstatic about Loney's bomb..
tonight I was most pleased with Dewitt and Wade. Wade continues to quietly be wonderful and its comforting to see.
if dewitt does keep stroking and playing great defense will we keep him at 2nd the rest of the way?
Go to 1983:
Reynolds' Bunt Squeezes Braves in 1983 and click Watch.
Absolute chills. Incredible moment.
http://www.azsnakepit.com/2008/9/10/611450/apocalypse-now-or-how-the
I'd heard he left in bad terms.
I don't rate GM's moves in my little evaluations by what they should have, or could have, known. I'd never get to the bottom of each one. I go by results, with a caveat. For example, I judge Depo's trade of LoDuca for Penny by what Penny has given and don't take away credit because Penny kind of fell into his lap while he was making a play for Johnson, or something. The caveat I make in my judging criteria is to not remove credit if a player gets hurt but, clearly, after we aquired him. I don't fault Colletti because Furcal is injured now. His was an excellent pickup, IMO.
That being said, wouldn't people agree that Colletti's "Good Move" side of the sheet has gotten a huge bump since the middle of the season? For me, at least, it's beside the point to argue, as some have done, that Manny somehow fell into his lap. Colletti did it, and Manny's been great. The Dodgers are in first and rolling. No downside, period.
Where's that leave Colletti now in the handling-the-development-of-the-young-Dodger-team department? He's:
1)basically retained the core and let them develop, growing pains and all;
2)made a couple of horrible trades of talent like Navarro and Jackson. Very bad;
3)(kills his grade) made some lousy free-agent signings, but, except for Pierre, all short-lasting, and Pierre, many say, is tradeable now. Plus, some of the old guys, like Kent (resigned) and Nomar, have produced, at times;
4)Furcal was his excellent free-agent signing;
5)made the moves, 2, mind you, of the 2010 season, turning a "Bleh!" team into an actual contender.
I don't know. Right now I'm thinking he's turned a "C-/D+" grade into a solid "B". I may just be hollering "Yippee!" at the top of the roller-coaster, probably am.
so I guess no news yet on his condition. It didn't look all that bad but still.
Except Garber turned a threw out Reynolds at first. To this day, no one knows why.
On a happier note, I present today's BP postseason odds:
Dodgers: 93.1%
D-backs: 6.8%
Magic number is 14. I wonder how BP runs its simulation, because 93% really feels like it's too high. The Dodgers are only three games up in the loss column, and there are still 16 games left to play. The division title is still very much up in the air.
I guess the tougher remaining schedules, and the head-to-head matchups have something to do with that.
The Pierre signing was universally lambasted from the moment it happened but it doesn't take much detective work to check out DT and the thoughts on the two dead contracts that currently weigh us down headed into the future. We may have expected regression from Schmidt but not to get anything out of him for three years would have taken a soothsayer. A Jones was a high risk gamble that he lost, but I'd rather he take the gamble then count on an outfield of Ethier/Pierre/Kemp in 2008.
It hugely backfired but even in that you can find a silver lining. If A Jones had just stayed at his 2007 level and not sunk into a hole of despair, Manny would not be wearing Dodger Blue, and who knows if Ethier or Kemp would have gotten the at bats they have gotten this season. While many point at the A Jones signing as one of the worse things Ned has ever done, it caused an action that became the best thing Ned has ever done.
http://www.cbs2.com/video/?id=76944@kcbs.dayport.com
Thank you for the wonderful site, I've been visiting it most of the year and registered today.
It's funny what made me register today - my disappointment in Brad Penny.
It was not the poor showing in last night's game or the poor record and high ERA this year but rather his quotes in Dylan Hernandez article in the LA Times.
Brad Penny said he wants to start again this year and that he is "absolutely" certain that he can regain the form that made him an All-Star in each of the last two seasons.
"I know who I am as a pitcher," said Penny, who was 6-9 with a 6.05 earned-run average in 17 starts.
"I don't want to play somewhere where I'm not wanted. If they don't want me, that's fine."
"It just tells me they were never sold on me, which is fine," Penny said.
"That's why I was out there trying to push myself -- because I didn't have a guaranteed job next year," he said. "I went about the whole situation wrong. If I had to do it over again, I would've just shut myself down."
So in the middle of a pennant race Penny decided to play the "me first" attitude (sounds like Pierre after the Manny trade). He wants to start again, and it's Ned's fault he pushed himself because the Dodger's didn't pick up his option.
While his teammates have won #10 of 11, Penny is more concerned with an extension and having his option pick-up. And he admits they he was pitching while he was hurt earlier in the season (joining Procter and Jones as selfish players who hurt the team playing through pain).
I've have been a fan of Penny in the past, and I've defended his past attitude on the mound as a completive athlete who wanted to win. Today I'm hoping we pick-up his option and ship him to Pittsburg.
Btw, great post Jon, thanks for the memories. Casey Blake's beard has nothing on Gene Garber's.
--
I don't know why, but I always get a kick out of seeing Sid Bream run on the field in that celebration.
One of a stream of promising and ultimately disappointing first basemen the Dodgers ran out there in the 80s.
The Andruw Jones (18mils owed in 2009) signing in and of itself could prevent the Dodgers from signing Manny as a free agent.
Thats not much of a silver lining.
UCLA fans can speak of "Michigan hot," but I always remember how hot it was that day.
Since August 1st, Manny Ramirez leads NL in OBP, Slugging (over 100 PA), HRs and RBI.
He's not. Bet on it.
International Federation of Associated Wrestling Styles
Now that is a cool name.
It's abbreviated FILA.
He's gone; I don't care how much he makes.
I think Torre wants to use him when he can to see what's left. If he needs surgery I expect he's gone. If he is structurally sound I think we will exercise the option.
vr, Xei
No. Manny and Casey Blake are free agents at the end of the season. The Dodgers are disgorging prospects faster than they can promote and groom them. It is entirely possible that the Dodgers will have neither Manny nor Blake in spring training 2009. This is a team built to win now and only for 2008. Beyond that it's a mystery. I absolutely do not think the Manny acquisition is a sound one.
True, but this silver lining may get us some post season victories, so as brief as it might be, I'll try to enjoy it while I have it.
I'm unaware of Ned being dissatisfied with Penny publicly. When healthy you just can't throw away a Penny for 6.75. I think they would rather pay him 6.75 to pitch then to just give him 2 mill to walk away but who know how Ned thinks.
Penny is not a bright bulb if he thinks pitching lousy gives him better leverage then taking care of his arm.
http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/LAN/LAN198309110.shtml
The Times' account of the action also had Garber tagging Reynolds out on the first-base line.
Amazing how much we disagree.
Billingsley/Kershaw/Kuroda/?/?
If the plan is CC or bust, I'm not sure if signing CC and Manny can work given McCourt's finances.
But compare the Dodgers to the Dbacks right now. Who much more close to literally mortgaged their farm system to win now and may not make the playoffs. Which situation would you rather be in, theirs (minus the haul of top prospects they gave up), or ours?
All that said, I still hope Colletti isn't back next season.
I do agree about worries about Colletti and a plan, or lack of one, though.
It also dates back to the '06 off season (when Schmidt signed) when there were rumors everywhere that Ned wanted to trade Penny.
"Mike Marshall was given the Mr. Potatohead Award."
I think mortgaging your farm system to win now means acquiring short term players~ which the Dodgers did with Manny/Blake.
The only guy the Dbax did that with was the Bonafacio for Rauch trade. Bonafacio isnt that good of player.
Sure they gave up a bundle of prospects for Dan Haren, but they also resigned Haren to a very good contract for 4 years.
I would love to get CC and Sheets. That's probably not possible, though.
Thats the key.
As long as the Dodgers dont get swept the rest of the season, I think its smooth sailing to the playoffs.
Garber definitely didn't tag Reynolds, so that's wrong. There's video of him throwing the ball. But there's no video of what happened at first.
I'd be curious to know what Retrosheet's source for calling it a sac was. Did the scoring change his ruling after Vin was off the air? Was Vin wrong? Or is it possible Vin was right?
left-handers Brett Anderson, Dana Eveland and Greg Smith; infielder Chris Carter; and outfielders Aaron Cunningham and Carlos Gonzalez. How are the A's enjoying that one now? And then yeah the Bonifacio for Rauch trade, a middle infield prospect for a middle reliever, another concept none of us are ever too keen on.
Maybe "mortgage" is overstating it but as great as Haren is if the Dodgers made the equivalent trade I can only imagine the feelings here. Reading some DBacks forums earlier this season a lot of fans were already worried about it. Certainly, they have some other good young prospects out there so the cupboard's not dry. But still.
Mark Heisler's story claimed that Garber tagged Reynolds, but I had always thought he threw over to first. Probably out of frustration.
Retrosheet would have used the official daily totals which would have indicated a sacrifice for Reynolds. Also Garber is credited with an assist and Chris Chambliss got a putout.
Guerrero was a step away from the plate, the game was an instant from being over, but Garber chased the ball down, reached out and just managed to tag Reynolds. What better did he have to do?
If we traded that bunch for Dan Haren, I'd be thrilled.
You know, if you pay off a mortgage in Monopoly you're supposed to pay 10% interest.
But nobody ever does.
Nor do they properly sell back their houses.
Nor do they exploit the limited number of houses.
Well, Eric Byrnes is still in his prime & on a multi-year deal.
Its not like they traded Quentin for a rental.
1. Gets into this post-season's revenue stream by trading bodies instead of cash (Toy Cannon's piece on True Blue regarding this is excellent).
2. Fires Ned and promotes White, who is better equipped to build cheaply from the draft, and can't be blamed for Jones.
3. Resigns Manny to keep filling seats and coffers.
4. Unloads as many other expensive PVLs as possible.
5. Hopes for more breathing room after Schmidt and Jones are gone in '10.
They could move him to 1st base ;)
Have a seat Brad, join Juan and Andrew and Jason and Nomar and Kent and Furcal. The 8+ million club of cheerleaders.
http://theguyreport.com/news-190/Interview-with-Dodgers-Derek-Lowe.html
Penny's shown how good he can be.
Just last year he was great. His velocity is still good & he's still in his prime.
Dewitt, you dont know how good he can be, but my expectations would be .720 OPS at 2nd base. That doesnt excite me.
Thank God for Rule 5, too.
That was the best interview that i have read in a long time. Thanks for posting that.
Carlos Quentin should be included in that since they did trade him for Chris Carter...
I found the answer.
I'll take an OPS of 720 from a 23 year old 2nd baseman with good defense if that is the downside. I expect the upside to be close to a 850 OPS by the time he's 26.
Nor, do I suspect, is it something that will change anytime soon.
That agrees with what I've found so far.
Last night on ESPN's broadcast, Rick Sutcliffe was remarking about Mark Kotsay that "he has the same kind of back injury as JD Drew....But he's still out there playing."
I'll say Dewitt at 2nd base is much more acceptable than 3b.
Seth (Los Angeles): Are the Dodgers going to get burned by the Casey Blake deal in two years? Is Carlos Santana going to rock in the majors?
Keith Law: (1:34 PM ET ) Yes. It will turn out that they gave up more for Blake than they did for Santana.
I don't get that part.
TGR: What do you think of Tommy Lasorda?
DL: He talks a lot.
TGR: We knew that.
DL: He's passionate about the Dodgers.
TGR: Does this generation of players listen to him?
DL: Um .
TGR: (Laughter)
I agree also.
If the Dodgers had only dealt Santana/Meloan to the Pirates, kept Laroche & still had Manny - that would have been better.
93 - I'm just pointing out the difference between trading for the bauble that is Manny Ramirez and trading for the bauble that is Julio Lugo.
So says the New York media.
4 Unfortunately, Baker did leave on bad terms because of some unfortunate rumors and whispers which I don't believe were true.
If you want to be accused of being a drug addict and a lot of other things, I think you can understand Baker's bitterness.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.