Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
Jon's other site:
Screen Jam
TV and more ...
1) using profanity or any euphemisms for profanity
2) personally attacking other commenters
3) baiting other commenters
4) arguing for the sake of arguing
5) discussing politics
6) using hyperbole when something less will suffice
7) using sarcasm in a way that can be misinterpreted negatively
8) making the same point over and over again
9) typing "no-hitter" or "perfect game" to describe either in progress
10) being annoyed by the existence of this list
11) commenting under the obvious influence
12) claiming your opinion isn't allowed when it's just being disagreed with
I'm hoping that Betimit will get the Loney treatment soon...
Most of all, it hits me that my kids will have no idea what "rewinding" is when they grow up.
Because Nomar is a better hitter vs. LH.
Or not.
2007 vs. LH:
Betemit: .231/.286/.385/.670
Nomar: .200/.290/.255/.545
This story has become legendary in our family.
http://tinyurl.com/2sz8ke
A Boras client being hard to sign. What are the odds.
Yes, they do let you go back. But the DVD was over...
My brother didn't want to review it. He wanted to rewind it before putting it back in the case to set a good example for his kids to rewind videos.
I think one of his kids corrected him.
With his $400k salary, large ISOs and three-true-outcomeness, I've been thinking that he might be attractive to a team like Oakland, particularly since they have Chavez at 3B putting up worse number for $9.5 million/year. Oakland could either trade Chavez to someone else and acquire Betemit from us, or even trade Chavez to us for Betemit.
Anyone see this happening? I'm not saying I want it to happen, but rather that I could see it happening, given Management's obvious lack of faith in Boom Boom's ability.
Except he does like the way the ball comes out of Tomko's hand.
Most of us just don't like how the ball comes off the opposition's bat after Tomko throws it.
The advantage of having Vegas as our AAA team is that DJ will be available today.
D Young now with 54 EBH. Seems to be hitting a double a game these days.
Isn't it also sad that Ned probably considers Nomar's Clutchness© for $8.5 million to be an even better bargain?
I continue to find it amazing how you can read Ned's mind.
Betemit has been leading the team in PrOPS for a little while, and now he's hitting .225/.353/.493, but his BABIP is still a mere .236 (.319 vs LHP, though). He's been pretty consistent in PrOPS, sitting now at .930, and if he got some playing time he'd probably still have some evening out to do to hit a very hard .260. Again, I was surprised Atlanta let him go, but I think they thought Baez was actually useful (ha!) and Aybar would be similar to Betemit but with an arbitration clock that starts a year later, so that probably helped in that deal.
Pierre,CF
Martin, C
Kent, 2B
Gonzo, LF
Nomar, 3B
Loney, 1B
Kemp, RF
Tomko, P
is today's line-up. Holten is back on the roster, as Tsao is now on the DL. (Holten to start Tuesday? nobody knows)
Same thing with LaRoche, yeah, he might not be ready yet, but could he be any worse than what we have at that position now?
You just turned 21 and your feeling old???
I wish I could swear on this site.
Should Matt's week in the lineup despite Ethier's production with lefties pitching today and tomorrow and then on Thursday and Friday.
I turned 21 just a few months before he was born. I actually went out to a bar and got a free beer that day when I showed my ID.
BOOO!!!!
Maybe Betemit is just what he is - a hitter who has good games and bad games, like other hitters - and we don't need to overthink it.
I think I like it more than when I went to a Wal Mart two years ago and the lady at the register thought I was 12.
I turned 21 last year and just graduated from college. Tomorrow I'm starting my first day of work at my first real job. I think I'm going to have an early-mid-life crisis.
Find out when you get fully vested in the company pension plan. I was fully vested in two different plans by the time I was 32.
Unless, it is something you love, then by all means, start working for the man or woman.
Fortunately, this job, I was fully vested from day 1, but then there isn't much of pension plan.
Bob works for City so he probably can retire on library money in 15 years or so.
42 I plan on going to grad school in a couple years. But I want to make sure I'm in the right field first. This is as close to an ideal job for me (seemingly) as I know of, so I don't mind working. I graduated a couple months ago so I've had plenty of time off.
He speaks with wisdom. Put off as long as you can joining the workforce. Enjoy your youth don't get sucked in by a paycheck.
It's an alternative route. It's not necessarily the best. It all depends upon what you value in life.
47 I think that is the hardest thing because to do anything "fun," or get a car, etc., you need cash and getting that first paycheck is tempting.
Has anyone seen the commercial for Chase Bank where the young woman gets her first paycheck and then deposits in the bank and then goes off and starts having fun.
She buys lunch for her friends (with a credit card), then she is with her boyfriend outside a movie theater (they used the Rialto in South Pasadena). She gets a text message indicating that another $220 was deposited (apparently she gets some other automatic deposits on Saturday nights) and then whisks the boyfriend away for more fun.
But if she were at the Rialto, I think all she could do for fun at that time would be either a trip to Jamba Juice or Starbucks.
Given this I am fine with Abreu going to Vegas until Sept. callup. Still waiting for Pierre to get a rest in center so we can have an Eithier, Gonzo, Kemp outfield. Overall not a bad lineup (you can sub Betemit for Nomar for even more power).
Russ Martin should never be allowed to play in day games, where he has a 700 OPS. Also, he really sucks against the Angels, Blue Jays, Cubs, Mets, and Rockies. He shouldn't play against them anymore. Oh, and don't EVER let him hit cleanup; 250 OPS there. He's also terrible in the clutch with a 622 OPS in close and late situations.
So, I propose we forbid him from playing in any of those situations. He has HOF numbers otherwise. Then if he falters in any other situations we'll know more things he can't do and cut him back there as well. Eventually he'll be in a position where he can't ever fail.
You can watch an infomercial by Kevin Trudeau for 24 straight hours and your life will be better than watching a minute of the ESPYs.
I'm not sure what rationale Bochy uses to decide between Aurilia and Feliz at third base.
But is there a pattern or do they just trade off each day?
It's not like either guy is setting the NL on fire.
Also, and again, Baseball Prospectus never claimed to be objective but they have not been above snide comments by many of their writers about the Dodgers since they fired Paul. But I am not sure I would say with any conviction that Kevin Towers vs. Ned is such a huge mismatch, you could not bet on it in Vegas because they would take it off the board. Last day for the free preview at BP.
http://baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=6456
What does everyone else think?
The Dodgers appear set to play out the year with a .313 OBP in the leadoff spot, and the fourth-best third baseman in the organization as the everyday guy at the position. Good luck with that, guys. All the great relief pitching in the world won't make up for those two decisions
Is that place just living off the fact that it has a cool neon sign?
Any runner is out when --
(a) (1) He runs more than three feet away from his baseline to avoid being tagged unless his action is to avoid interference with a fielder fielding a batted ball. A runner's baseline is established when the tag attempt occurs and is a straight line from the runner to the base he is attempting to reach safely;
Dynomite!
Not his fault. Server hiccough.
Curse of the ESPYs!
what would WILSON do? Nomar kills me with his first pitch swinging. I guess Betemit didn't show enough yesterday to deserve another start today.
No, you cannot.
Watching on gameday made me notice hwo station to station we've been. Partly due to Furcal's health and Pierres "barely hits" and bunts.
On Bronx Batter someone suggested they trade Mat Desalvo for him. The arrogance or ignorance of such an offer left me typelist.
Looked like his suckitude kicked in instead.
Let's see how many times I can type that today.
Not sure what Russell was doing, even if he missed a sign, the pitch looked very hittable.
1. J & J's on Adams, east of Fairfax
2. Jaybees on Avalon in Compton
3. Phillip's on Leimart Park in Leimart Park
4. Woody's on Slausen.
5. The guy on Lake Ave in Altadena on Saturdays in an old gas station parking lot.
Seems like Jeff's errors in this series have been because he was rushing for some reason.
Have you been to "the Pit" on S. Vermont?
We shall see...
What a difference a letter makes.
Patsy Donovan and Burleigh Grimes are ready to dispute that.
And if you didn't have teeth, it rhymed.
What a difference a letter makes
Which letter? Should the Dodgers start Matt Kenp at second base?
That BBQ spot on Fig. and Chavez is overrated...and it is run by Giants fans...
What? Somehow I find it hard to be critical of a manager who despite what you may think, managed one team to a playoff spot and has his current team holding the best record in the league.
Maybe its because I have 35+ years of watching so I don't try to get too excited on the day to day or even year to year but since Grady is trying to do something that has only happened once in the last 30 years, go to the playoffs in back to back years and right now has as a good chance as anyone, I cut Grady a lot of slack and besides all that, the man is funny.
DT commenters would have crucified Chuck Dressen.
1 run on 276 hits...
The Wizard was an old man by the time I was old enought to really "watch" baseball....
But in 1974, Alston called for 9 IBBs the whole season.
Just nine!
Alston hated the IBB as he got older. Game 3 of the 1962 playoff against the Giants would have been fun to read.
Jon would have been deleting a series of Rule 1 violations directed toward Alston, Roebuck, Williams, and Burright.
Murray's team:
In a little over 2400 plate appearances:
0.261/0.329/0.383, 4.4 runs per game.
Mueller's team through yesterday:
In a little over 1000 plate appearances:
0.306/0.370/0.437, 5.2 runs per game
We shall see...
We still do roast Lasorda. He was the designated bad guy in DePodesta's ouster.
Don't understand why people are eager to willfully ignore Grady's mismanagement of the lineup and the pitching staff. Especially on a day where he's starting Tomko for no reason besides stubbornness. We should have the best record in the NL with at least a few games to spare.
Sick of the Grady bashing.....
I figured it out. I tabbed to the "preview post" and hit backspace to get rid of the check mark. I think what that did, besides getting rid of the mark, was recall a previous post. I tabbed again to hit submit and aren't we all richer for knowing this crap?
Wasn't it just a couple years ago when Jim Tracy was the worst manager ever? People here accused Tracy of tanking games to spite DePodesta.
And now Little is worse? With the best record in the NL?
Just because you don't understand the reason doesn't mean there isn't one.
An old man like me, who better appreciates "Freaks and Geeks" than Greg Brock, only has one more manager to remember.
Somehow I don't see Murray and Kent having lots of talks about anything.
Jeff Kent doesn't understand black people.
Little and Alston have much different personalities. Alston was not known for having much of a sense of humor. Alston was very quiet. A lot of people thought that Alston was generally clueless and just kept his job because he was a company man and didn't cause trouble.
Alston had much more of a temper than Little.
I'm telling you...youtube Lasorda's "audio stew" fabulous....
Just think: you too could make millions and get a contract extension for putting such a lineup together. Oh: and for paying Barry Zito $100 million bucks.
Which Tommy Lasorda were you watching? Which pitcher's arm did you not mind Lasorda shredding into ribbons?
Alston was more extreme that Grittle in that if there was a move to be made, he would do it. He could also turn on a strategy like a Creon turned on Antigone (thank you, I'm here all week).
Being a loudmouth phony and bigot is just the icing on the cake.
Lasorda was a very good manager because he won. I was always resentful that Bill James stopped writing his abstracts after the '87 season. He wrote a book a couple of yars later and wrote an off-hand comment that Lasorda did something like twenty different things during the '88 season that made the difference between the team winning and losing.
Lasorda could've done many things to avoid wining. Some years, he probably did. But my favorite team has flags flying thanks to him. He did a lot of things very right.
It's OK. The Dodgers did win four pennants under Lasorda, but for the most part the Dodgers won in spite of Lasorda. Managing the 1977-78 Dodgers was not taxing.
This is really a big problem.
And every time he makes an out, it proves that he's not ready for the major leagues yet.
With Kemp and Loney:
.306/.370/.437
Without Kemp and Loney:
.299/.364/.423
He certainly needs to work on that if he's going to stick around.
Hu 3-4, HR
Young 3-4, HR
Laroche 2-4, 2B
Not counting today's game.
.342/.399/.510
Are you confined to Raleigh per se, or can you get out to Durham and Chapel Hill?
If the former, and if you're like me, I suppose you might want to visit NC State University, and the capital area. Both are more or less in downtown Raleigh, and not too far from each other.
If you can get out, Duke and UNC are worth visiting. Downtown Durham is kinda interesting too, as you can see all the old tobacco warehouses that are being converted into other things.
Nonetheless, hope he does start to turn things around!
... Nice Casey Stengel reference.
I have spent almost no time in downtown Raleigh, but in the little time I was there, it looked like there's a lot of restaurants and bars and stuff down there.
Do you know where you're staying?
Nope.
Pierre: .655
Nomar: .655
OPS
Pierre: .655
Nomar: .646
Better players are playing now.
Kemp for Contreras? Pleeeease.
I blame Bob.
Also not giving a day off to Russell keeps the catching numbers up for now.
Maybe Honeycutt put in some serious work...
But unless the other guys were hitting too, the improvement would not be as pronounced.
I agree, Nomar isn't this bad. But the gooder Nomar won't be that much gooder.
God doesn't like me this much, does he?
Tomko isn't going anywhere. I've made peace with it. We all should.
"Let's tell him what he's won...It's...A trip back to the bench!"
Unfortunately, that is $18M down the drain, not to mention the waste of a roster spot.
The other two just aren't very good baseballers.
So, unless you are implying that there is some mathmatic formula that makes their hits have a higher value, I stand by the numbers that the team even without their numbers is hitting and getting on base better since the hitting coach change.
... Looked to me that he was just unhappy about the pitch he threw to Durham. I don't see what's so wrong there; I would want my players to be competitors.
They had three triples in a game at Arizona last year on May 2. And they lost that game.
We bunt here 3-1.
... With Pierre, he had better.
I get what you are saying, from a subjective point, Loney and Kemp have impacted the team much more their numbers say they have and their numbers are great but its not like their success alone boosted the offense, it has been a team effort.
But a meek groundout to second would have done the same job.
Im posting from an iphone so I'll have to defer for now.
Showoff! ;)
And since 2002, it's been a debacle.
He shouldn't have quit his day job.
The thing I don't understand is why putting a bunch of .700 OPS veterans around Bonds was the optimum strategy for getting him and the team a ring. This seems to be taken for granted, but I don't get it.
332. What's the fun of having one if you can't show off! Actually, I usually hide it in public for fear of looking like the guy who has to show off his iPhone. But I must say that this site is so totally accessible and it is so easy to view and post, it almost looks like Apple considered DT in designing the darn thing. Just sick.
(sigh)
One day, I'll learn how to use the internet.
It also sucks up battery power fast.
After you log on, you have to refresh the page for it to show that you logged in. The BlackBerry has a weird way of caching pages.
Flip it back vertically and hit refresh and you're back to the 10-12 posts with your latest at the bottom. Almost as easy as posting from home and a lot more fun! I must admit, I have read and even posted comments while driving... today.
Only thing missing is a spell check.
BTW, I'm home now so this is NOT posted from my iPhone.
The ball has a way of ending up in right field.
You stink, stinky!
So Grittle will (continue to) think he's a good pitcher and keep him on the roster for the rest of the year!
Thanks for helping me relive that nightmare.
I had to go eat a pizza with garlic, anchovies, and capers to get that taste out of my mouth.
So: what was the "Better than Peanut Butter" made of? Did it contain nuts, or some kind of nut substitute?
Oh, and Chan Ho Park.
Free Greg Anderson!!!
I believe it contained recycled tires, peach pits, and brown food coloring.
My man GB is on fire!
There should be a massive firesale of this whole team. Trade everybody. Trade the bullpen catcher.
Or a manager?
I would bring in Saito now.
Is this a joke?
Is this it...?
http://www.betternpeanutbutter.com/
"Jonathan, you need to trust your stuff. Now throw a cutter."
"But I don't throw a cutter."
"Of course you do."
EEK! NOOOOOO!!!!
Only time will tel.
Wouldn't that be funny if the Giants got A-Rod and then decided they needed to surround him with even more veteran "talent"?
Yeah, pretty much. Brian Sabean might be the worst GM in baseball.
I still wish he had a changeup.
I don't know, the Giants have had the advantage of a bigger payroll and Barry Bonds. Anonymous Pittsburgh Guy has been pretty terrible, but he did get Jason Bay and Adam La Roche.
When Tomko spoke with reporters Friday, he hinted that he would soon meet with Colletti to discuss his future with the club, immediate and long-term. Tomko would not go into details about the conversation, but said it was productive.
I bet Depo never had sofa-side chats...
429 I have to go with every Pirates GM from Cam Bonifay to today as the worst.
Andy MacPhail is good at MacPhailing upwards as well.
Who was the Oriols guy?...Sid Thryft?
Excuse me while I wipe the water from my laptop...
Joe actually can't comment on Torre's racism because he hasn't seen him be racist enough.
Russ Ortiz threw a simulated game today and he seems to be close to coming back.
Isn't that pretty much all he does?
Time for Saito.
Great stuff and where do you get it? Is this all baseball reference?
I'm off the Blair Field to watch exciting American Legion action.
Best. Series. Ever.
http://www.baseball-reference.com/pi/shareit/bwm3
This is just too much fun.
13 consecutive wins in SF:
8/1/1976, game 1, 4-1, Sutton beats Barr, Hough gets the save, Buckner goes 3-4 with a walk and 3 runs scored.
8/1/1976, game 2, 4-3 in 10 innings, Hough beats Heaverlo, Giants score 2 in the ninth off of Rhoden to tie, Dodgers get a run in the 10th on a sac fly by Bill Russell.
9/21/1976, 3-2, Rau beats Moffitt, save for Hough, Cey homers in the 8th to break a 2-2 tie. Another three-hit game for Buckner.
9/22/1976, 3-1, Sutton beats Knepper for his 20th win on a CG six-hitter.
9/23/1976, 4-1, Hooton beats Montefusco on a CG three-hitter.
4/15/1977, 7-1, Rau beats Halicki, Reggie Smith hits two-run home runs in the first and third innings.
4/16/1977, 5-0, Hooten beats McGlothen on a CG five-hit shutout, another two-run home run in the first inning for Reggie Smith.
4/17/1977, 7-6, Hough beats Moffitt, behind 6-5 after seven, the Dodgers get two in the 8th on a Cey home run, walk to Garvey, and double by Lacy.
7/1/1977, 10-5, Rau beats Charlie Williams, Dodgers get 17 hits, including 2 doubles, 3 triples (didn't Bob mentions this earlier in this thread?) and 2 HR. The triples were by Lopes, Yeager, and Reggie Smith.
7/2/1977, 10-3, Hooten beats Knepper, Hooten CG, Dodgers get 13 hits, including two more triples (Russell and Garvey).
7/3/1977, 10-7, John beats Barr, save for Garman, Cey went 5-5 with two doubles, 2 runs, 4 RBI, Garvey kept the triple barrage going.
7/4/1977, 4-0, Sutton beats Halicki on a CG three-hit shutout, triple of the day is provided by Reggie Smith. Cey is 3-4 with 2 RBI.
9/20/1977, 3-1, John beats Halicki, save for Rautzhan, Dodgers get all three runs in the second inning when Garvey singles, steals second, scores on a double by Baker, and Monday homers.
The next day they lost, 5-4.
For the record, except for the 1984 Tigers, the 1977 Dodgers were the best team I ever saw.
April 8, 2001 at LA
0 for 5, K, 8, 6 vs Gagne, K vs Nunez, 2F vs Shaw
April 10, 2001 at SD
0 for 5, K, 8 vs Jarvis, 5 vs Witasick, 7 and 6-3 ground out vs Maurer.
Dustbustered?
"While the Giants wait for Barry Bonds to hit another long ball, the Los Angeles Dodgers played small ball to beat their archrival again."
I think I need to send in the Miller Beer truck driver to Trader Joe's to repossess that peanut butter.
Swiffer Wet-jetted...?
Jerry Seinfeld: "They sell them by the side of the road. Blueberry blackberry."
George: "Blackberry boysenberry."
Jerry: "Boysenberry huckleberry."
George: "Huckleberry raspberry."
Jerry: "Raspberry strawberry."
George: "Strawberry cranberry."
Jerry: "Peach."
"heard rumors" -- Does that mean someone within baseball or the Mets told you that as opposed to reading it somewhere. Can you expound on where you learned of this rumor. I have an inquiring mind in my house who would like details.
Hard to believe that Noah Lowry once was someone I feared.
D Young has to be the hottest hitter in the minor leagues right now. 57 EBH. He couldn't have timed it better as we head into trading deadline time.
Could SW be a closet Giants fan?
Did Bob read it or hear it?
Will Doc. Technical make it into Battle?
Who knows? Who cares?
As long as the D's don't make a stupid trade, which probably boils down to as long as the D's don't make a trade.
Apropos of something a couple hundred comments back. . .I think it's unlikely that the BP team is willing to tank its predictions because they don't like that McCourt fired their boy. It's pretty easy to guess what Sheehan doesn't like about Colletti, without looking for ricochet grudges.
Somehow it reminds me of Abrue and Hu, although the first pair probably weren't as good. Then cam a pair of successive third basemen, Hamilton and Hansen, I think. Always in pairs.
510 No apologee needed; I think our feeling is the appropriate one, and hate to see him bashed.
513,514 Excellent ideas, but no. This could be imag. Or maybe it is someone even earlier. But I remember dreaming of this DP team that never materialized
Mark-Paul Gosselaar is going to now be on the show. Dylan from 90210, Al Bundy, and Zach from Saved by the Bell all on the same show. It is insanity.
http://tinyurl.com/2w4gu6
N.Y. Times article on new Met's hitting coach.
But to say that a hitting coach is in charge of only hitting is to minimize the importance of one of the more multifaceted jobs in baseball. Almost in equal parts, a hitting coach must be a teacher, a friend, a communicator, a psychologist, a father figure and a comedian. At various times during the Mets' hourlong batting practice before last night's game against the Cincinnati Reds, Johnson resembled them all.
He tutored José Valentín on hitting to the opposite field. He reminded Carlos Beltrán to spray the ball to all parts of the field. He cracked jokes with David Wright. He put his arm around Damion Easley while making a point.
"A lot of the job is being a rah-rah guy," Shawn Green said. "We all know how to hit or else we wouldn't be here. Sometimes all we want is to be held and told that everything's going to be all right."
In 1928, Cab Calloway tried out for the Harlem Globetrotters.
Calloway made the team. He decided to follow music instead.
Come on, you knew this was coming so you shouldn't be surprised.
"Little said Tomko earned another start while Wolf recovers from a shoulder impingement. It will come Friday against the Mets at home, where the fans have been very tough on Tomko. He'll worry about that Friday."
http://tinyurl.com/2n5d69
Did anyone post that Kuo felt pain today and he shut down his thowing program?
Now Perez is the Mets ace. Tomko keeps getting reprieves from the governor. And Jae Seo is in Durham.
What will happen this year?
Beats me, I'll be working.
Message to big pharma--if I experience anything for more than four hours, I will probably call my "physician" on general principles!
I'm with you. I can't see Tomko being DFA'ed. He's owed a lot of money and he has a long standing relationship with the GM. If no one will take him in a trade then we're stuck with him. So we may as well root for him to do well either way.
Here's EY's draft year (there are links to the year before and after at the top of each page):
http://tinyurl.com/ytku37
"Coming this summer
The ability to search through minor league stats"
A nation waits with baited breath.
16. Jon, Jon, Jon, Jon, Jon.....
Thirty-somethin'-or-other. Jon, Jon, Jon, Jon, Jon.......
Clear violations of 2,3,4,6, 7 and a host of unwritten others....
St. Vincent of the Rams, five or six or more years ago, was waxing enthusiatic about a fairly nice but repeatable catch by a well-paid professional named Hollandsworth near an outfield wall. Vin's first report (and so the one His Ego-Eminence was forced by his own flawed character to defend) was that Todd had robbed so-and-so of a home run, immensely aiding the Good Guys' cause. Those bothersome new-fangled replays insisted on contradicting him - the liftoff (unnecesaary, as it turned out, since the ball was snagged while on the return to earth) was initiated several feet short of the wall, and the rest of the drama nowhere near the altitude necessary to predict a ball over it that continued its refusal to climb higher with each dance of the humble electrons. I am happy to report to all of you who've been cured of terminal disease just by listening to Saint Vin that he budged not an inch from his original take, full-color contradictions, one after after another, notwithstanding.
Which, of course, leads me to the jaundiced comments of the Head Rascal re: the story of Sad Wilson's Redemption.
Wil was held in low esteem here (turn you away, Andrew Shimmin) because HE WAS STINKIN' UP THE JOINT!!!!!!! I, and others of the Impatient Ilk, as opposed to contrary seers like Grady and y'self, saw him, as the early - season regular sad third-sacker, creating new meanings for the term "Black Hole." In an offensively-challenged lineup, he obviously needed some sorting- out time (and I suggested the desert an estimable locale).
Then, God bless, if nothing else in his manager's bag-o-tricks, Grady's stubborn persistence (and the unimpressive play of everyone else they tried there) with Wilson and his astoundin' performance in the toughest role in the game, as a semi-late-inning pinch-hitter. There followed, roughly, sporadic continued failure as a spot regular, and some more impactful hits as a one-timer. I praised him to the heavens; I congrat-ed his supporters. I asked if there was any way we could get him to a shrink to discover the difference in his approach as the wildy successful one and the pretty dismal other.
Grady stayed with him, and yes, now, finally, there is some evidence to support his worth in the everyday lineup, and calls for patience with his failures. But before this recent run, the weight of evidence was on the side of the Impatient Angels, and before his pinch-hitting magic, almost all of it. On a great offensive team, he might have been wished and granted more time. On this one, calls for him to find his stroke without contributing four pathetic outs night after young-season night in the majors were entirely warranted (Andrew) BY THE THEN AVAILABLE EVIDENCE!!!!!!! We did not make this up, as Saint Vin often does; we did not tell it the way we wanted it to unfold (as you often do) but honored the day-in day-out actual flesh-and-blood-and-electronically-verifiable way IT WAS UNFOLDING!!!!!!!
So, I suspect, as in previous difficult circumstances, you will punish y'self for the aforementioned rules violations more harshly than you would any of the rest of the Woebegone.
PS: My doubts (continuing) about Wilson,
are generated more by respect for the extraordinary work done by the Braves in the last fifteen seasons (not so much whom they trade for, but whom they are willing to let go), and not by any disrespect for fans of the Flock who see him as a big plus. He was the Prize of Prizes in a system fairly rich in everyday players, and, needing him, from time to time over the course of his ascendancy, never could find him regular work, and let him go for what I still think was a suspiciously modest price (unless some Dodger ML scouts were part-timing for John S., re: Danys).
In this org, at this time, among Nomar, Tony, Wilson (and, as I've occasionally seen here, Olmedo), if I'm the manager,
the guy who gets the lion's share of the PT at 3b, for now, is Senor Betemit. Unless and until, as at the beginning of the season, he plays himself back to hero-off-the-bench, based on (Andrew) CONSISTENTLY
CLUELESS AT-BATS!!!!!
And for all those who love power baseball, and do diligent daily dirges about the absence of same, please inform me who has the best record in the senior circuit right now? And please, while at it, inform me of the flaws in the Great Walt's Game, such that his teams contended almost every year, absent that magic power, and occasionally brought a championship to your city. Please. Alms for the poor, enlightenment for those of us darkened by Walt's evil pall.
PPS - to the guy crackin' wise about sitting Russell in various low-expectation situations. I know you were stretching the limits in making your point, but the next great revolution in baseball will be to recognize and take advantage of those insights, and cultivate a culture wherein a bright strategist of a manager can rely on his guys to understand such machinations serve a greater good, and more importantly, give nourishing lessons to kids of all ages, about the One and the Many.
And lastly, I apologize that time constraints don't allow or encourage live exchanges. I try to honor the folks I read;
I pin my tales, mostly, at the end of the donkey, since that seems the best place...
Xavier Paul, CF (Bats Left)
Chin-Lung Hu, SS (Bats Right)
Russell Martin, C (Bats Right)
Matt Kemp, RF (Bats Right)
James Loney, 1B (Bats Left)
Andy LaRoche, 3B (Bats Right)
Andre Ethier, LF (Bats Left)
Tony Abreu, 2B (Bats Switch)
The only thing that really stands in the way of that line-up coming to pass is Pierre's contract. Sure, a whole bunch of other things COULD happen that would keep any or all of the other seven players from being there, but they are all things that are OPTIONAL on the Dodgers' part, like re-signing Furcal, signing other free agents, trades, etc.
So I was right with 16.
And I wasn't attacking you, certainly wasn't trying to encourage you to attack me (would have been much happier to have you not do so), wasn't arguing for the sake of arguing, wasn't using hyperbole and wasn't being sarcastic. I don't see that I violated any rules, written or unwritten. I made a declarative, unemotional, sincere statement.
Tomko starting on Friday is unspeakable, but maybe we could win three of four leading up to that. And maybe Nomar could take over as third-base COACH? He'd be good at that gig. Poor sad Nomar.
Can someone give me the Cliff's Notes version of that post? Main characters, significant plot points, themes, etc.
I'm not sure what I have to do with any of it. Though, something, it seems.
Now, as then, I would not argue Betemit is an All-Star. I only have argued that he's the best option the Dodgers have at third base, at least until LaRoche ascends.
So this whole thing about what Atlanta does and doesn't do is largely irrelevant. The question has never been whether Atlanta gives up good prospects, it's been whether Atlanta would give up a better third baseman than the 2007 version of Tony Abreu. And in a trade for Danys Baez and Willy Aybar, the answer to that question is and has been yes.
So I may be taking a risk to dance with Mr. bojangles, but 5, 6, 7, 8....
I think those three things are called fiction-writing, analysis, and reporting. Analyzing and commenting on game action are practically a time-honored tradition in baseball, and other endeavors as well. Consider chess for example. (Bridge players can mentally supply their own similar comparison here.) What would chess be without kibbitzers? Are not chess matches analyzed and annotated with fine-toothed combs, complete with commentary, question marks, and exclamation points inserting the opinion of the analyst?
Is there something inherently wrong in analyzing baseball games, providing arguments and opinions on manager's moves, batter's approaches, pitcher's pitch selections, considering alternate decisions?
It is one thing to report that Wilson Betemit's batting statistics are significantly different when considering pinch-hitting appearance separate from the others. It is another thing to consider if there is or is not any causal relationship from situation to result and to opine whether or not this statistic should affect starting lineup decisions. Is there not room for both? Is a blog, with the system of initial post and comment in reply, not a medium that begs for both?
Giants' position players on the current 25-man roster, through Saturday:
Player OPS+
Barry Bonds - 184
Ryan Klesko - 121
Fred Lewis - 115
Randy Winn - 98
Ray Durham - 89
Bengie Molina - 84
Kevin Frandsen - 84
Mark Sweeney - 77
Pedro Feliz - 74
Rich Aurilia - 72
Dave Roberts - 70
Omar Vizquel - 57
Guillermo Rodriguez - 40
Man. Not groovy.
Wilson Betemit's year has been too weird for me to form an opinion of it. He's beating his 90th percentile PECOTA projection for EQA, right now. I was happy when LaRoche came up, irritated when he got sent back down, but the rest of the time, I've thought Betemit should be playing. One of the problems of giving up on people after April is that you end up with a player who doesn't have a full year's worth of stats, ever. Just pieces, split two ways with heavy benching. It's doubly frustrating, given what non-Betemit 3Bs have been good for. Not only do we go another year wondering what this guy is really good for, but we get to do so without having gained anything by it.
Ethier .407/.507/.593
Gonzo .302/.394/.442
Pierre .297/.325/.356
Martin .375/.450/.594
Kent .326/.408/.465
Furcal .256/.318/.347
Nomar .263/.306/.313
Furcal is batting .321 with an .832 OPS in July while Gonzo has cooled down from his hot June.
Nomar is so bad on the road (5 for 37 in this study) that you do have wonder if he will be moved even further down in the order. One note about of Betemit's struggles is that while its true that historically he is much better hitter lefthanded than right, this year, outside the 9 to 1 homer ratio batting left to right, batting average wise he is about the same from either side of the plate.
My point is that you could start Wilson against lefties as much as Nomar because this year, Nomar does not lefties well.
Tomko might be in the rotation for the rest of the season if Wolf's arm doesnt fully recover.
Unless the Dodgers acquire D-Train--which I could honestly see happening.
Why did the Dodgers trade for Danys Baez?
Why did the Dodgers trade for Lance Carter?
Why did the Dodgers trade for Mark Hendrickson?
Pre All-Star 2006
Rolen - 331/398/577
Nomar-358/426/578
Post All-Star 2006
Rolen - 253/333/447
Nomar-229/286/408
Nomar has fallen further then Rolen but other then PreAllStar 2006 he hasn't been in Rolen's class for several years. The dropoff of both players over the last 162 games is an interesting sideline to the 2007 season. As Andru Jones has heated up after a first half of futility, Dodger and Cardinal fans have to hope that the cliff isn't on the horizon for their respective 3rd baseman but a revival instead. Chances of a post season may depend on it.
That is right up Ned's alley.
Willis would be the Nomar of the pitching staff, and considering there's not much on the pitching market this month---I think he might be the guy the Dodgers will target.
I dont think they should, but I think they will.
I don't disagree, though Tomko and Wolf hadn't done much for anyone lately when they were signed.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.