Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
Jon's other site:
Screen Jam
TV and more ...
1) using profanity or any euphemisms for profanity
2) personally attacking other commenters
3) baiting other commenters
4) arguing for the sake of arguing
5) discussing politics
6) using hyperbole when something less will suffice
7) using sarcasm in a way that can be misinterpreted negatively
8) making the same point over and over again
9) typing "no-hitter" or "perfect game" to describe either in progress
10) being annoyed by the existence of this list
11) commenting under the obvious influence
12) claiming your opinion isn't allowed when it's just being disagreed with
I believe this is the second time this has been mentioned this week, but Diamond Leung of the Press-Enterprise notes that Ned Colletti sees Jonathan Meloan as a potential starting pitcher in 2008, in Las Vegas if not Los Angeles.
The Dodgers have done a fine job of coaching him, though. His walks have drastically reduced since coming out of college, while K's have gone through the roof.
If we add Kuroda then we definitely do not need to have Meloan trying to start in my eyes.
Anyway, it's starting to look like Greg Brock snuck into the Winter Meetings, kidnapped Ned and put him on a freighter to China, and has been wearing a Ned disguise. Hence the "migraines." Greg/Ned is just worried about the makeup dripping.
Won't Mrs. Colletti be surprised!
I don't think this is going to happen. He has come up the ranks as a reliever. They floated this idea a bit with Broxton too.
I think Meloan will be closing in Vegas in 08 and will come up if there are injuries, a trade, a pennant push, or just a need before August.
Meloan showed after his first appearance last year that he wasn't ready for the pressure of the bigs just yet, I don't see him making the opening day roster, even with a good spring.
Maybe they are thinking he has Kuo disease and will do better taking the mound to start a game? I think they are different guys.
What is the real deal? He should have enough to be the 10th or 11th guy in the bullpen.
I like him.
Your actually judging Meloan on one game in the big leagues?
I think we are still in the thick of the Kuroda race. Meloan could just be a fall back option.
Bottom line, I wouldn't mind giving Meloan a shot a make the Dodgers' rotation in spring training.
If Schmidt and Loaiza are healthy (along with Kuroda), we already have capable starters to slot in the back end of the rotation. If we could maximize Meloan's ability as a reliever, I would rather do that.
That could work.
Honestly, I believe Meloan is a prime trading chip for us and if he can be marketed as a SP, that ups his value even more.
Time to scour the San Diego* area Del Taco restaurants! Side benefit: chili cheese fries.
*Kuroda's agent is San Diego based
The Phillies are out of the running for Japanese right-hander Hiroki Kuroda. A source tells me that Kuroda will visit Seattle, Arizona and Los Angeles next week. He doesn't appear interested in playing on the East Coast, and the latest offer made today by the Phillies wasn't as lucrative as Seattle's, which is believed to be climbing toward the $50 million mark.
50 mil is way too much for Kuroda.
Kuroda is our best option, but you're right, that's just too much.
If that falls through, our best bet is to go with in house options. Of course I'm assuming Schmidt will be well enough to pitch at least somewhat effectively. Also, for all we know Kershaw could win a spot in the rotation. Would a Schmidt, Penny, Lowe, Bills, Kershaw/Loaiza be the worst thing in the world? I'd certainly take that over giving Lohse millions...
Well that's the point. There really aren't many other options out there. If Kuroda is the best option and he's too pricey, then you just have to go with what you have. The last thing I'd want to see is Ned throw millions in a panic move at someone like Lohse or Silva. Heck, if those are our only options I'd rather see Houlton in the rotation.
The thing is, he is 32 so how much realistically does he have left in him? I hope Colleti would his 3yr speciality contract.
I wouldn't be opposed to 3yrs 39 mil. Anything more than that is really pushing it.
I am not advocating signing Kuroda, but if you spend 50 million on a starter he's the best bet to get you the most for your money, imo.
Insurance - Kuo, DJ Houlton, Stults, Hendrickson
KIW - McDonald, Orenduff, Elbert, Kershaw
Bullpen - Saito, Broxton, Beimel, Proctor, Brazoban, + whoever doesn't make the rotation.
KIW - Hull, Meloan,Troncoso, Wade
Wouldn't surprise me to see Orenduff and Elbert get some time in the bullpen in 2008.
Looks okay to me. It is the offense I'm worried about not the pitching. Come July we have plenty of help from the KIW to call upon. Or we have plenty of chips to trade.
If Loney, Kemp, and Eithier are allowed a full year to actually play with some probably improvement from Furcal then our offense may not be that big of a problem.
But I do see what you're saying....maybe if we all dream of replacing Pierre with Jones at the same time it'll actually happen!
Can we get a vote on a new DodgerThoughts rule to never speak that name again? ;)
Exactly how I feel. I just don't see him as a starter.
2004 Jeff Weaver is a good statistical comparison, except Kuroda is older and hasn't actually faced big league competition.
Though the preview of The Bucket List looks promising. As does PS I Love You (but I read the book, so I'm already disappointed by the changes).
I'm not a big believer in Dunn outside of Cincy, but that's just me.
Adam Dunn's been the subject of some debate here in the past (all through the season) and I'm on the side of the fence that worries about his defense, a lot. And we don't need him at first. So unless we can get the NL to instill a DH, I don't see a fit for him. (Though, I'd take him in exchange for Pierre out there in left, sure.)
I find it hard to believe that Dunn would hit less than 35 HR no matter where he played.
Dunn's career OPS+, which has a ballpark factor term is 130. His four seasons, oldest to current: 146, 141, 114, 136. But I agree with underdog about his defense.
288. Since LA doesn't have an NFL team, I defaulted to the Pittsburgh Steelers, my only exception.
I did the same thing. And the New England Patriots should be afraid. They should be very afraid. :-)
http://tinyurl.com/2w5lk5
A sample:
As for Rolen's desire to be traded, La Russa said, "The whole idea isn't to please Scott. It's to take care of the St. Louis Cardinals. I don't understand why he can be down on the Cardinals. I don't understand why he can be down on me, to be honest.
"The idea is to accommodate the St. Louis Cardinals, our team, our responsibility to our players and to the competition. So, no, I don't want to accomodate Scott.
GMs should approach the Cardinals with a, "If we help you with your Rolen problem, what can you do for us?"
It's my impression that by sabermetric measures, Dunn's OF defense is so awful it really does kill much of his offensive value. And it's not as if we have room for him at 1B.
WWSH
"How can someone not like me. I'm Tony La Russa, damnit!!!"
Saying Pierre was somewhat known mediocrity is giving him too much credit.
Would you rather have:
1. Rolen at 3rd for Dodgers, Pierre with Cardinals, LaRoche with DRays, crappy DRays reliever with Dodgers
2. Pierre with Dodgers, LaRoche at 3rd for Dodgers
And the difficulty of translating Japanese performance to the majors is another wildcard. I mean, did anyone expect Saito to be as good as he's been? Unfortunately, on the flip side, see what happened to Igawa.
WWSH
What did I miss?
if the Dodgers were an AL team I wouldn't mind having him around BUT he plays in the NL & last I seen he plays very VERY poor defense.
http://www.dailynews.com/dodgers/ci_7637252
http://jalopnik.com/cars/news/tony-la-russa-not-convincing-in-field-sobriety-tests-330250.php
I imagined Dunn with 2 left feet/legs reading your piece.
Thanks.
Rays vice president of baseball operations Andrew Friedman told reporters Wednesday that he had "productive conversation" with several teams and there is a "50-50" chance he will make a trade before leaving town.
"We've had talks that are mature enough to make me think that we could do something before we left," Friedman said.
Luis Gonzalez told ESPN.com that he's spoken with the Rays. The Tampa native has expressed interest in the past about playing for the Rays.
The Rays have also been linked in trade rumors with Andre Ethier of the Dodgers and Laynce Nix of the Brewers.
Meloan: I didn't and wouldn't judge Meloan on one game. His first shot in the bigs he got the side out and then walked the bases full and got out of it. He lost his confidence after that and gave up a bumch of hits and runs if I recall. I think he gave up at least one run in every appearance after that and we never used him in a pressure situation after that one game.
If you recall, a lot of us, myself included, wanted him to get called up when we were still in it. I think he showed he wasn't quite ready for the jump from AA just yet.
He reminds me of Bills when he got his first taste. Might be intimidated, might have butterflies, maybe gives the hitters too much credit, who knows. Young guys sometimes take some time to get comfortable at the major league level.
My only point is he isn't ready to be counted on for sure in 08, he needs some more seasoning. That doesn't follow that I'm judging him or giving up on him. Neither is true, I just think he is more of a work in progress than an arm for 08 just yet.
Hull: If he gets outs, he can stick around. We haven't been convinced of him enough to pencil him in anywhere for 08 yet as far as I can tell. That can change in the spring, or into the season. I don't think we are counting him as a blue chip.
Why are the names Reyes and Wheeler popping into my head?
10:49 p.m., from Enrique Rojas
The Dodgers have interest in third baseman Pedro Feliz, who are still trying to find a power hitter. Feliz, 32, has hit at least 20 home runs in each of the last four seasons. Just one Dodgers hitter (Jeff Kent) belted 20 home runs in 2007.
To make room on the 40-man roster, the Brewers designated outfielder Laynce Nix for assignment.
Doesn't sound like the Rays would have to send much.
That's not even funny to see in print as a rumor.
vr, Xei
The first part of that seems open-ended; the second part of it seems definitive. That's what's confusing. You seem to have decided he's not ready, which is no more valid than people deciding that he is.
Six months after his first major-league appearance, I personally think the jitters are likely to diminish greatly.
How Rolen managed to post almost 400 at-bats this season is a testament to his mental toughness to play through injuries. It turns out that he has a frozen left shoulder that needs surgery, and it was the main reason why he failed to get the double-digit home run totals for the second time in three years. This is the second significant surgery involving Rolen's shoulder in the past three years, and one has to wonder what that means for his future offensively
I will stay away from Dodger Thoughts for a week if Ned signs Feliz to be our starting 3rd baseman. I don't want to hear the sound of popping brain cells.
Phillies GM Pat Gillick conceded the obvious and told local reporters that the team's chances of re-signing center fielder Aaron Rowand are a "long shot." The Phillies love Rowand's grit and presence in the clubhouse, but some people in the organization think he might have to move from center field to left in a year or two, and 25 homers and 80 RBIs wouldn't be anything special for a corner man. And where Gillick is concerned, the shorter the contract, the better. It remains to be seen if Rowand and his agent, Craig Landis, can get five years from another club.
25 and 80? Rowand's done it exactly once, last year. How many of those has he got in him?
I might have been defensive as Phil asked if I was judging him on one game. While I can shoot from the hip to try to get a chuckle, I'm not that short sighted as a fan of the game to think one performance a player makes.
Defensive or not, I do not think we are counting on him in 08 at this point, either in the pen or starting. He'd be a very pleasant surprise if he proved ready to go in April. We'd also need a spot for him.
As always, I can be wrong. I don't mind being wrong. In this case, if he's a go-to guy in 08, I'll happily be wrong and buy a round after home game one of the NLCS.
That's right. He prefers players who get on base a lot, like Pierre.
If it means moving Kemp, I say no. If it means moving Pierre or Ethier, I think so.
Rumors are we offered three and they want five. He might get four somewhere. I'm not sure we'd go four.
His power was around last year when he didn't strike out.
Ugly half.
"Not really," Colletti said. "I don't want to get into [specifics]. We [the Dodgers and Andruw Jones] haven't got a deal, if we're inching or running toward each other." Yet the negotiations have continued throughout the Winter Meetings, with indications that Jones is warming to the idea of a two- or three-year contract that would allow him to rehabilitate his stats in time for another bite at the free-agent apple while still in his prime.
Colletti indicated that no third-base acquisition appeared imminent, even with the apparent availability of Detroit's Brandon Inge after the Miguel Cabrera trade. Free agent Tadahito Iguchi is willing to move from second base to third if the Dodgers want him.
Colletti also said that he will not spend significant salary on veteran relievers, because the Dodgers have as many as a half-dozen young pitchers who could pitch in the Major Leagues next year -- Clayton Kershaw, John Meloan, James McDonald, Scott Elbert, Ramon Troncoso and Greg Miller.
Colletti said that the club would exercise some caution with Kershaw.... But he was not worried about rushing him. "Because of his blend of ability and makeup, his birthdate is not as much of a concern," he said.
Did anyone surf today?
It's like he just bought a Mac.
Didn't Jackson say in his blog that the meetings were really, really boring?
WWSH
I for one appreciate the honesty, as opposed to the way ESPN has to hype everything. They made the Santana deal sound like it was all but done, but now it's just dribbled away...
WWSH
ps we only saw him a few times but I just feel he'd best serve the Dodgers as a reliever, I'm with NatePurcel on this one (plus he saw him pitch live at Arizona)
The London shows already sold out. They'll be in the US in May. No dates or venues announced yet.
I love Europe. Anybody else in for a trip to Holland?
I here there a great live band but I'm not really a fan of theres, wow your going all the way to Holland.
I'm traying to play it cool [can't hold it much longer) WHOO HOO!!!!!
if anything, he's got plenty to prove so I'm hoping for a nice bounce back year from him.
Shoot first. Ask questions later.
I prefer to stay blissfully ignorant of the other shoe that could drop any day now.
The Braves are becoming the Kansas City Athletics to our 1950s Yankees! :)
http://www.dailynews.com/dodgers/ci_7646252
Tomorrow's news: Jeff Kent announces his return for '08.
Uh.. I'm paranoid too senior trainwreck. Just let us keep Kemp.
MLB.com is also reporting the signing, so we are probably safe...
Been working 14 hour days, so I am behind on the chatter, but HALLELEUJAH!!! WOO HOO
If Slappy has to be in the outfield, here's hoping that Ethier/Young can bring in a solid starter.
Furcal
Pierre
Loney
Jones
Kent
Kemp
Martin
Nomar/LaRoche
I'd prefer to see:
Furcal
Martin
Loney
Jones
Kent
Kemp
LaRoche/Nomar
Pierre
Thanks!
Keep Kemp and shop Pierre if possible, Ethier if not. Dang, I've posted that a few times. I'll lay off it now.
Would trading Pierre for Rolen be considered by the Cards? I hope so.
I'm good so long as Kemp doesn't leave for anything less than Santana or Bedard.
I fear he's ours for four more years. At least he can do less damage in left field. Maybe if we play softball rules and add a fourth outfielder he'd make a bit more sense.
Enough on him. I think you're right about Ethier going before Pierre.
I accept the reality and Pierre in left or batting 8th is progress. Slow and painful, but progress.
Are you sure? The only things that makes Pierre acceptable in CF is his speed, which gives him range and allows him to make up for his average skills at jumps and reads. With the foul line and the stands to one side, his speed asset is devalued. The noodle arm doesn't change, although he is closer to third base. Ethier is a better fielder, more power and a higher OBP - just no SBs.
Maybe Andruw will wear #36.
His arm in left rather than center is less of a problem for runners taking an extra base.
Maybe we Kemp/Ethier both play right? I don't really think so, but it is possible. We learned last year that this was foolish, never knowing who was going to play from day to day.
I think Ethier is the odd man out. Either the fourth outfielder and you don't sign Sweeney, or he's trade bait.
Great leaders admit their mistakes, Ned. You're going through an important transformation. Walk into the light, Ned. Walk into the light.
No wait! Boras got him the BIGGEST CONTRACT EVER SIGNED.
I'd like to have a few of those bad years.
The contract will pay Jones a $12 million signing bonus, a $9 million salary in 2008 and $15 million in 2009
Motivated enough to play through an injury most of the season.
Who's being naive now, Blubleeder?
Sorry, I got the Godfather bug from dzzrtRatt. :)
One less centerfielder is on the market now, and I hope that once Rowand and Cameron sign too there will be at least one team left that wants a "proven" centerfielder and leadoff-man. I think the White Sox could be that team but we'll see. Now everybody knows that while we have been openly seeking a new centerfielder the media has been talking about the plan being to move Pierre to left, and I'm sure that the front office has said that, and that is okay, because it would have been stupid to undermine what little trade value Pierre has (if our intention was to trade him all along) by making it sound like the Dodgers think Pierre is garbage. No, the front office played it correctly if they PRETENDED to still want Pierre but really intended to dump him on any sucker they can find as soon as a CF replacement was brought in. Now lets pray that that has been the game plan. I don't want to see Kemp or Ethier traded, and if either guy is traded, I'll say we should have stuck with the status quo instead of signing Jones.
I hope he and Kemp both hit 40 next year.
(from another article then i posted before)
Stay after Kazmir Ned. You are my hero.
I'm ok with Signing Feliz if... a meteor crashes into planet earth, instantly killing Andy LaRoche and all other major and minor league third basemen.
As for Boras, even when he's made the scapegoat in the ARod fiasco, his take was still $14 mil. from that deal.
He'll either develope some strength, or he'll get caught and get suspended without pay.
We can spike his Gatorade? Any takers?
I thought for sure Pierre would play CF for 810 Dodger games. So anything's possible I guess.
I would rather have Pierre play third than see Feliz at third.
A lineup with a lot of power already and not much speed, plus a smaller outfield...the Phillies? If they don't sign Rowand, they've got to get someone else too.
Don't cross The Stache™
As much as I think we would be better off without him, releasing him is not necessary. Even if we have to eat $20 mil of the contract, we could get something for him. Not much, but something.
Pierre (64/79, 81%) would be a perfect fit!
What's the over/under on the times per game Vinny wonders aloud why Andruw doesn't use two hands to catch flyballs?
Where is the nearest Gold Club to Dodger Stadium? Andruw demands to know...
If Pierre is playing somewhere else next year, than this is a great move. If Pierre is in left for the Dodgers next year, it's a lateral move.
Still, hope springs eternal.
Reasons to keep Kemp and Ethier:
(1) They're better than Pierre (might as well begin with the obvious)
(2) Jones has a short term contract, and the Dodgers do not have much outfield depth in the system. All the more reason to keep some young outfielders.
(3) As a left-handed hitter, Ethier provides some balance to the heart of the lineup -- otherwise, only Loney hits left. Yeah, Pierre is a lefty as well, but that's less important batting after Furcal or in the 8 slot.
(4) Kemp could hit 40. Keep him. Keep him. He stings the ball like no one I've seen play for the Dodgers since, well, Piazza.
Is their anybody worthwhile on the Texas Rangers?
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.